3 ms·
Except it’s not nearly a large enough employer to single-handedly prop up the places where it dominates. Coal mining has been substantially automated compared t
by jacobolus 10y ago
Except it’s not nearly a large enough employer to single-handedly prop up the places where it dominates. Coal mining has been substantially automated compared to a few decades ago, and the total number of coal jobs is down to a small fraction of its peak.
Even if we doubled or tripled coal production, local economies in coal country would still be limping. It’s not like executives/stockholders of coal companies are dumping all their profits back into the local economy.
As a country/world we’d be better off paying former coal workers a living wage indefinitely, no strings attached, for nothing in return but keeping the coal in the ground.
The US already employs more people in the solar industry than the coal industry. We could conceivably make a policy like big federal wage subsidies to renewable companies willing to relocate to West Virginia or wherever.
- pfraze 10y agoDo you think there isn't any remaining connection between labor and coal's political resilience? Coal-politics could be explained as a lobbied interest, but that doesn't feel like a complete enough picture to me.
- jacobolus 10y agoSure, there is some connection. But a big part of it is a mix of desperation and wishful thinking. Same story with the steel industry, auto industry, textile industry, etc., in other parts of the country. And of course the coal companies are still willing to throw lots of money at lobbying, which buys a lot of influence among local politicians.
- pfraze 10y agoYeah. About your previous comment, > We could conceivably make a policy like big federal wage subsidies to renewable companies willing to relocate to West Virginia or wherever I wonder if the renewables need the labor? If so, I can see that working. If not, then really the only problem is how to handle political dissatisfaction in the short term, and (perhaps) thus our election today.
- ethbro 10y agoI think this is one of the reasons the election went the way it did, and I'm as guilty as anyone. You can't discount pride. You can't discount being trained and good at a difficult job, and proud at being the one who does it. Money from the government doesn't replace that in the hierarchy of needs. And job retraining is tough when you're 40+.
- stcredzero 10y agoExcept it’s not nearly a large enough employer to single-handedly prop up the places where it dominates. And the paychecks it generates aren't really enough to justify even just the local impacts to health and the environment.