10 ms·
There's a lot of room to wonder about his trustworthiness given his record as a businessman, but even in this document, he doesn't address campaign finance refo
by noobermin 10y ago
There's a lot of room to wonder about his trustworthiness given his record as a businessman, but even in this document, he doesn't address campaign finance reform. Congressional term-limits just consolidate power in the moneyed elites--the problems is not just the politicians, it's who corrupted them. If anything, this is a document to passify those moneyed interests who, unlike say Sheldon Adelson, worry about a Trump presidency.
Everything I've seen so far suggests Trump isn't what blue-collar voters ordered for.
- rurban 10y agoNo. The problem are the corrupt selfserving politicians, and not the ones who corrupt them. And his program is not only term-limits. mostly going after the criminals and clean up the mess. They should be worried, and are already crying. Should be doable even with the press witchhunting him and later with the antiliberal nonsense he will come up to please his voter base.
- josho 10y agoTrump railed against the system that allowed politicians to be bought. It turns out his solution is to term limit congress. Sounds like treating a symptom not the root cause.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- postcarnival 10y agoso what, then let's offer solutions and try to get them enacted? why all the armchair bitching on this site as if everyone is an expert just because they write code? what he did is nothing short of monumental and he WANTS to help America. If everyone is so damn smart then get involved and suggest changes. It's not like he's a fucking robot that is going to sit back and count how many marble statues he has in his garden!
- SMUx 10y agoI understand the sentiment but comments like this detract from the value of this community.
- postcarnival 10y agoactually I just read the replies and I see quite a few productive ones! just saying...
- legodt 10y agoHe wants to help white, cis male America. Trump has demonstrated great disdain for anybody who isn't that
- r_smart 10y agoYes, for example one of the first things he talked about in his victory speech was helping out the inner cities. He must not know that there are high populations of black people in those areas.
- ubernostrum 10y agoWant money out of presidential politics? Make everybody run using only the presidential-campaign fund. You know, that one that you check the box on your tax return to give a couple bucks to? As for Congress, we also already have a good fix, we just never got around to passing it. Congressional politics are full of money because the districts are too large, on average. The districts are too large because in the 50 states, with 320 million people, we have only 435 voting members in the House of Representatives. The solution is more Representatives and smaller districts; when you don't have to run a campaign in multiple expensive markets across a broad area, you don't need as much money (and can get to know your constituents better). And it turns out... there's a constitutional amendment for that. Way back in 1789 when Congress met for the first time after the Constitution went into effect, they submitted twelve amendments to the states. Ten of them were ratified quickly and became what we know as the Bill of Rights. The other two were not ratified by enough states, and were mostly forgotten. Today, it's common for Congress to put a time limit on an amendment, saying it has to be ratified within X years or it's dead. But back then they didn't do that. So in 1992 a random university student discovered one of the two "forgotten" amendments and that it was still legislatively "live" -- it would take effect if enough states ratified them. He campaigned hard and got the amendment (which says any increase in salary for members of Congress doesn't take effect until after the next House election) ratified, as the 27th amendment. The other one is still sitting out there, and would become part of the Constitution if enough states (currently, 27) would ratify it. And it changes the formula for how many Representatives there are, and how they're apportioned. The original text of the Constitution set a cap on the size of the House of Representatives, at one Representative per 30,000 people. The apportionment amendment would raise that to 1 per 50,000, and the version passed by the Senate would require increasing the number of Representatives as the population of the US grows. So if you want real change in Congress, campaign to get the House of Representatives enlarged. There's even already an amendment available to help you, if you can get it ratified.
- JosephHatfield 10y agoI don't see how elections themselves aren't term limits. You want to end someone's reign, vote them out. Am I missing something?
- inimino 10y agoIncumbents have an advantage and tend to get reelected. Term limits introduce more outsiders by kicking people out after a while.
- baddox 10y agoIt's a check on direct democracy, which I think is fine in principle. It's the same reason the US has a constitution.
- laughfactory 10y agoYou're missing the incumbent bias. It's well known we prefer the devil we know to the one we don't--even if we objectively have good reason to dislike the incumbent. Which is to say if, after electing someone to office, we immediately 1) forgot we voted for them, and 2) became completely unaware of their continuing existence and actions in office only then would elections be truly a sufficient substitute for term limits. Otherwise, given the choice, enough votes will be cast to keep the incumbent in office just because he/she is familiar. The thinking seems to go something like: well, that's the name I recognize, and hey, the world hasn't come to an end in the past few years, so... why not. Let's just keep 'em. Versus this other person who might do all kinds of things I can't foresee and may not like.
- notahacker 10y agoBut of course incumbent bias is still dependent on the candidate not being unpopular. I can see arguments for term limits, particularly in positions where the composition of the electorate means the other major party isn't likely to seriously challenge the governing party's preferred candidate (usually the incumbent) which makes their position very safe indeed. But anti-corruption isn't one of them. Arguably, from a point of view of anti-corruption, the incumbent needs the special interests a lot less than the new challengers...
- Shivetya 10y agoWell let us be honest here. Electing politicians hasn't exactly been doing us that much good. If anything we have learned we cannot accept their word at all. I am of the opinion that politicians corrupted themselves by selling their ability to shape the laws that govern the country and decide who is punished and who is rewarded.
- blintz 10y agoSo then what's your alternative? Would you prefer a system without politicians? What kind of system is that? We must elect trustworthy politicians, we must make it harder for big money to interfere, and we must have faith in our government. It's hard for me to say right now, given our current president-elect, but it's true. There truly is no good alternative to democracy.
- susam 10y agoYour comment reminds me of the following famous quote by Winston Churchill. "Many forms of Government have been tried and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed, it has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all those other forms that have been tried from time to time." -- Speech in the House of Commons (11 November 1947)
- mindcrime 10y agoWould you prefer a system without politicians? Yes. What kind of system is that? Self-government[1] and/or a stateless society[2]. [1]: https://www.theadvocates.org/ https://www.theadvocates.org/ [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stateless_society https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stateless_society
- exergy 10y agoI'm sorry, but that sounds like the kind of thing an edy 18 year old would say. There are no examples of 350 million people being governed WITHOUT a government, and for good reasons.
- feld 10y agoIt doesn't stop the flow of money, just requires that it's more fairly distributed throughout the party.
- bmmayer1 10y agoIs campaign finance reform really that big an issue, considering Trump just proved it's possible to win an election without any big money or support from special interests?
- bduerst 10y agoThat's a lie. Trump courted and accepted money from special interests - there was even a Planet Money podcast on it.
- tribune 10y agoSure he did - but nearly as much as did Clinton. This election absolutely proved that a candidate can't simple "buy" an election
- swsieber 10y agoYou're right - he demonstrated one can flaunt bigotry and appeal to our basest emotions to get equal media attention wothout paying for it. So in my opinion he hasn't demonstrated anything useful.
- fusiongyro 10y agoAdding to your point, he was also hugely successful in the primary despite being massively outspent by Jeb.
- bduerst 10y agoI disagree. I would argue that his campaign proved otherwise. Promising to never accept special interest money, only to go on to actively seek out and take it a mere months later, proves that it's necessary to win in an election.
- facetube 10y agoHe has demonstrated something dangerous. It is dangerous to dispense bigotry from the highest office in the land. It has consequences. It gets people hurt and killed. The consequences are foreseeable.
- randiantech 10y agoFunny, that "if one created, two removed" was a law imposed by a Principal Software Architect to me and my team regarding apps and apis as part of a rationalization program. "If you create this new API, make sure to remove at least two". I have to say, after two years there, that helped a lot to reduce redundancy and complexity. But well, apps and api are not the same of public policies... who knows.
- maxxxxx 10y agoAt some point you have to stop cutting. You can't go thus forever.
- ethbro 10y ago"If this rule needs to be broken, then bring me a proposal for why" is a good addition. The idea should be to swap the default to less-complexity rather than more-complexity. If more is less, then it should be possible to write a succinct justification for it.
- Beltiras 10y agoThe US code is 22 million words. [1] is a good visualization of it. I'd wager there are tons of redundancies that could be refactored. That being said, I'd also wager that careful refactoring is not on DJT's mind. More slash-and-burn the parts he doesn't like. [1] https://twitter.com/harlanyu/status/165184504527462400/photo/1?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw https://twitter.com/harlanyu/status/165184504527462400/photo...
- dragonwriter 10y agoThe US Code is law, not regulation, and so is completely irrelevant here. What you want to cite is the Code of Federal Regulations, which is much larger than the U.S. Code. Of course you provide no reason at all except an unsupported assumption to believe that the size of the completely wrong thing that you cite is an indicator of unnecessary complexity, and the fact that you cite the completely wrong thing is a pretty good sign that you have zero knowledge of the domain from which to form a judgement.