2 ms·
1. While you're waiting for the market to correct itself, people would be getting evicted. Even if they get an apartment back, there's little public good accomp
by geofft 10y ago
1. While you're waiting for the market to correct itself, people would be getting evicted. Even if they get an apartment back, there's little public good accomplished in the interim. (And, at least from a cold economic perspective, a serious loss to the rest of the economy while they figure out interim housing.) Most of the reason we don't have a pure free market is because it's worth capping how bad things can be if everything goes wrong, even if that has the effect of capping how good things can be if everything goes right.
2. The other reason we don't have a pure free market is because we want cities to be able to make themselves into the sort of city they want to be. This is fundamentally why zoning is legal and accepted: a property owner doesn't have the right to turn an office building into a residence, or a storefront into a factory, at their own discretion. San Francisco may not want to be a city of Airbnb residents and no locals. We might think they're wrong, but they get to choose that.
Note that it would be very easy to arrive at the same situation from a pure-free-market perspective: the US government, with its guns, owns all the land in the US. It delegates ownership of the land in SF to the City of SF, a corporation, under certain conditions. In turn, the City grants long-term leases to landlords under certain conditions. Tenants don't have a right to renew their short-term leases, but the City has the right to decide which landlords keep their long-term leases, and chooses to let tenants have the ability to expect their leases renewed. People freely and rationally choose to live in US land instead of land where they can actually own their property, because it's economically better for them. This is exactly what happens right now, modulo changes in terminology.
- lmm 10y agoOf course there are those of us who believe SF zoning (and US zoning in general) is shooting itself in the foot. But that's ok, and the correct response is to vote with one's feet.