5 ms·
So what if a lease isn't renewed. The tenant doesn't have a 'right' to a lease. If property managers don't want to renew leases because of AirBnB fine -- soon t
by briandear 10y ago
So what if a lease isn't renewed. The tenant doesn't have a 'right' to a lease. If property managers don't want to renew leases because of AirBnB fine -- soon there'll be an oversupply of AirBnB and the market will reach equilibrium. However since places like San Fran put artificial constraints on supply through tight regulation, then the market can't reach equilibrium because of a government-created market distortion.
As a thought experiment, pretend that every home in San Fran was an AirBnB. What would happen? The demand would drop and landlords would then begin leasing their places out to where the AirBnB demand and the leasing demand was at equilibrium -- assuming San Fran allows new housing supplies to enter the market.
Why doesn't San Fran allow massive high rise apartments like in China or Korea? Because the NIMBYs want to protect their own property values. All of these regulations are anti-market and thus promote inefficiencies.
If we accept that there is a housing problem in San Fran, the solution isn't to tightly restrict the existing supply but to increase the supply. As it is now it's like two junkies negotiating over a plastic spoon.
- rspeer 10y agoLook, I'm a YIMBY but I think that cities need to keep AirBNB under control. Competition won't solve all housing problems, particularly if you throw residential housing and hotels into the same market, as AirBNB does. Cities have every reason to incentivize people to actually live there -- and yes, most successful cities need a lot more space for people to actually live in. Any gains you could accomplish here are defeated when the new living space is set aside for visitors instead of residents.
- LanceH 10y agoPerhaps cities like SF and Portland should let owners of property build more housing on that property instead of further restricting their rights.
- pyrophane 10y agoIt's not an either/or situation. Yes, crowded cities need to take steps to increase the housing supply, but they should also make sure Airbnb isn't further diminishing the supply.
- mikeyouse 10y agoIt's also a temporal issue -- Building housing lowers house prices in the future, restricting AirBnB lowers house prices today.
- smallnamespace 10y ago> Building housing lowers house prices in the future That's not strictly true -- if market participants pay attention to planned new starts, then the effect of additional supply should be seen immediately in today's prices.
- mikeyouse 10y agoIn a city like SF, that's far from given. There's the discount rate of rent-in-hand today vs. when the construction completes, but more importantly there's a ton of uncertainty around projects. Planned new starts means very little in a city / region that regularly scraps or significantly delays projects due to random bureaucratic machinations.
- smallnamespace 10y agoYou're right that information doesn't perfectly filter through and starts aren't a particularly reliable metric. My intended point was very narrow though: your default assumption should be that changes in expectations of future cashflows have an immediate impact on price, unless you can point to a particular market friction that prevents this adjustment. Basically, you should distinguish between timing of cash flows (which don't generally matter except for discounting), and the timing of the information flowing into the market (which does). If there were a credible plan to build more much housing and the market believed in it, it should affect the price more or less immediately. Discount rates are very low -- $1 a year from now is more or less worth $1 today.
- geofft 10y ago1. While you're waiting for the market to correct itself, people would be getting evicted. Even if they get an apartment back, there's little public good accomplished in the interim. (And, at least from a cold economic perspective, a serious loss to the rest of the economy while they figure out interim housing.) Most of the reason we don't have a pure free market is because it's worth capping how bad things can be if everything goes wrong, even if that has the effect of capping how good things can be if everything goes right. 2. The other reason we don't have a pure free market is because we want cities to be able to make themselves into the sort of city they want to be. This is fundamentally why zoning is legal and accepted: a property owner doesn't have the right to turn an office building into a residence, or a storefront into a factory, at their own discretion. San Francisco may not want to be a city of Airbnb residents and no locals. We might think they're wrong, but they get to choose that. Note that it would be very easy to arrive at the same situation from a pure-free-market perspective: the US government, with its guns, owns all the land in the US. It delegates ownership of the land in SF to the City of SF, a corporation, under certain conditions. In turn, the City grants long-term leases to landlords under certain conditions. Tenants don't have a right to renew their short-term leases, but the City has the right to decide which landlords keep their long-term leases, and chooses to let tenants have the ability to expect their leases renewed. People freely and rationally choose to live in US land instead of land where they can actually own their property, because it's economically better for them. This is exactly what happens right now, modulo changes in terminology.
- lmm 10y agoOf course there are those of us who believe SF zoning (and US zoning in general) is shooting itself in the foot. But that's ok, and the correct response is to vote with one's feet.
- Spooky23 10y ago> Why doesn't San Fran allow massive high rise apartments like in China or Korea? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1906_San_Francisco_earthquake https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1906_San_Francisco_earthquak... Capitalism doesn't require SFO to transform into Hong Kong. You can move anywhere. I live in a mid-size city where my housing costs are approximately the same as a San Francisco bathroom. Personally, I despise the Bay Area fetishism because I'm 3000 miles away and my livlihood will be impacted significantly when an earthquake destroys hundreds of billions of property and those mortgages get vaporized.
- kspaans 10y agowhen an earthquake destroys hundreds of billions of property and those mortgages get vaporized. A mortgage is house + land ("real property"), so an earthquake won't necessarily wipe out the value of the underlying asset. And, these days, due to the scarcity of land in the SFBA and high demand, the land under most homes could be worth more than the homes themselves! That said, however, if the quake were bad enough and infrastructure were ruined, that could also kill the demand and hence the land values.
- closeparen 10y agoBeen to the Financial District? 30+ story towers are definitely possible, and their prevalence is increasing. Just not fast enough, and only in a few tiny corners where the neighbors don't stop them.
- literallycancer 10y agoI really don't get why you'd deregulate housing/construction. You don't allow free market to "balance itself" in industries with natural monopolies (e.g. utilities, cellular operators). Beyond a certain distance, commuting to a city is impractical, so the space for residential development is limited (= there is a hard cap on how much stuff you can build). The utilities are heavily regulated (for good reasons), why shouldn't the government start regulating the housing market on the same grounds? Another thing to consider, there is nothing inherently "free market" about letting anyone build whatever they want, as long as it's on their land. Taxing, classifying and partitioning land by area covered is as arbitrary as taxing by window count[1] or house width[2]. Why not evaluate and sell vertical lots? Up from certain height, large areas are reserved for air traffic already, so there is a precedent. It could look like this picture[3], the central beam would be regulated akin to roads today. 1 http://www.historyhouse.co.uk/articles/window_tax.html http://www.historyhouse.co.uk/articles/window_tax.html http://www.colinsnotes.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/154-22.jpg http://www.colinsnotes.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/154-22... 2 https://mjwrightnz.wordpress.com/2012/10/28/amsterdams-taxing-narrow-houses/ https://mjwrightnz.wordpress.com/2012/10/28/amsterdams-taxin... 3 http://www.evolo.us/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/vertical-street-1.jpg http://www.evolo.us/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/vertical-stre...
- michaelmrose 10y agoRegardless of the reason for the shortage its not going away tomorrow. The business owner doesn't have a right to operate a particular kind of business in a particular place and manner.