4 ms·
>Yet net migration figures stayed around 350k, which showed that either the politicians were not really engaging or were ineffective. Which, consulting Wikiped
by foldr 10y ago
>Yet net migration figures stayed around 350k, which showed that either the politicians were not really engaging or were ineffective.
Which, consulting Wikipedia’s list of countries by net migration, puts us below (amongst many others) Norway, Spain, Australia, Canada, Sweden, Switzerland, Italy, Ireland and Portugal. So it’s not exactly an unreasonably large number of immigrants we’re talking about here. (Especially when you consider that our net migration figures are bogus, since international students are wrongly included in them. Around 135,000 non-EU students entered the UK in 2014, for example.)
>I also don't see how you can call the idea of restricting that "mad". Genuinely I don't. I understand you can disagree, I understand you can disagree with the premises it's based on. But how is it "mad"?
We have an aging population and an economy that was just coming out of a recession. It’s not difficult to see why we need more immigrants. They’re young and net contributors to the economy. The idea that we could make things any better by shutting everyone out is, simply, mad. Perhaps in the short term some unemployed British people could switch from being unemployed to doing very badly paid, very menial jobs that are currently being done by Polish people. The net cost to the economy would most likely be far greater than the cost of simply increasing their benefits, though.
>Your insistence on only dealing with the conservative government is also puzzling when we're talking about something that goes far further back.
I don’t think I am insisting on that (?) I’m not quite sure what you mean.
- Nursie 10y agoThe British people considered it unreasonably large, for whatever reasons. They considered it important enough that after years of being ignored millions voted for UKIP or the Tories. Again I'm not here to argue merits. What you have there is more justifications for ignoring the views of large sections of the electorate. The rest of your argument is purely economic, as if that is or should be everything to everyone. And some of those points are arguable. I don't think that warrants calling people who disagree "mad". >> I don’t think I am insisting on that (?) I’m not quite sure what you mean. Oh just that I've been trying to make the point that politicians have been at this for decades and you bring up the conservatives as having tried to engage. I don't think they really did, and by the time they did it was too late. Engagement should have been there from Blair onward.
- foldr 10y ago>The British people considered it unreasonably large, for whatever reasons. For no good reason. That's why I said that it's mad. The economic argument is the only respectable argument against immigration, which is why I focused on it. The only other arguments against immigration that people put forward are racist and/or xenophobic.
- Nursie 10y agoMore of the smug I'm afraid. You don't think it's important so it's mad. You don't agree with other arguments so they're racist.
- foldr 10y agoOk, so what is an argument against current levels of immigration to the UK that is neither racist, xenophobic, nor based primarily on economic considerations?
- Nursie 10y agoMost EU immigration is to London and the South East, somewhere that already feels like it's creaking at the seems and overcrowded. We could start a massive programme of building houses and infrastructure, but that would further change the face of the country. Limiting immigration would alleviate some of the pressure. That's just one off the top of my head. Remember, the point made in this article is not that you have to agree. The point is that calling people mad and shouting them down as racist is toxic to politics and drives people away. --edit-- I also find it strange when people bring up racism in the context of limiting migration from the EU - a region primarily peopled by white Europeans.
- foldr 10y ago>Most EU immigration is to London and the South East, somewhere that already feels like it's creaking at the seems and overcrowded. > Limiting immigration would alleviate some of the pressure. First of all, housing is an economic issue. Second, London voted overwhelmingly for remain. I live in London. No-one here seriously thinks that London’s housing crisis can be solved by stopping immigration. Nor did the country vote Leave because people in the North were particularly interested in solving London’s housing crisis. Third, London out of all areas of the UK would be harmed the most by greater restrictions on immigration, and the vast majority of the people who live here know that. >I also find it strange when people bring up racism in the context of limiting migration from the EU - a region primarily peopled by white Europeans. Actually I was careful to say “racist and/or xenophobic” in anticipation of this kind of pedantry, but I guess I needn’t have bothered. The current climate is such that even Polish people aren’t considered sufficiently Anglo-Saxon to be entitled to live here!