3 ms·
So...now we have to start all over? I know I sound like a complete d--k, but my laptop from 2012 has eight cores that each run over 3 billion cycles a second.
by paulddraper 10y ago
So...now we have to start all over?
I know I sound like a complete d--k, but my laptop from 2012 has eight cores that each run over 3 billion cycles a second. How do < 2000 comments make your servers more than blink? I'm guessing you have more than one server?
I get frustrated by sites not accepting HN's "hug of death". An now HN can't even stand its own hug...
Anyway, thanks for getting things running again! You guys are awesome!
- Artoemius 10y agoIt's Trump's hug of death this time.
- paulddraper 10y agoTrump's hugs have been quite newsworthy http://www.usmagazine.com/celebrity-news/news/donald-trump-awkwardly-hugs-melania-ivanka-expert-weighs-in-w430543 http://www.usmagazine.com/celebrity-news/news/donald-trump-a... Apparently he's bad at them.
- dang 10y agoWe don't have more than one server and HN proper (not counting caches) runs on a single core. Believe me, we hate slow software at least as much as you do and have put a lot of effort into addressing this. HN is a lot faster than it used to be on median load. It still falls short on excessive load. We'll get there!
- ihuman 10y agoHN is still made in arc, right? Does arc support threads? Racket does, so I would assume arc does.
- dang 10y agoRacket has green threads, which gives us non-blocking IO but that's about it. There's another concurrency mechanism that uses OS threads but Arc doesn't rely on it, and from the little I looked at, I don't think it would work with the HN software's design.
- samth 10y agoThere are two parallelism approaches in Racket, both of which provide OS threads. The most useful one for web servers is called 'places', and is somewhat like Erlang -- you can only communicate immutable serializable data between different places, as well as OS resources like file handles. I know other people have used places to scale web applications, but I haven't looked at how HN's design would be affected. If you have questions about using this, please feel free to email me about it.
- paulddraper 10y ago> We don't have more than one server and HN proper (not counting caches) runs on a single core. Well, then. That is rather impressive. (Though I suggest adding a processor/server. Probably small compared to your existing Cloudflare costs.)
- oneeyedpigeon 10y agoClearly, it depends on the architecture used. From what dang says, it seems like HN renders every single page view dynamically if you are logged in. I guess that has something to do with the voting mechanism; I would have thought that could be handled client-side instead. Either way, it's not just down to the number of comments on a thread, as you imply, clearly the number of requests for that page plays a part. I'm guessing HN has been getting a huge amount of traffic, probably way more than your laptop could serve dynamic pages at.
- paulddraper 10y ago> I would have thought that could be handled client-side instead It could be, but that would add a JavaScript dependency that HN currently doesn't have.
- oneeyedpigeon 10y agoTrue. But it could be a 'progressive dependency' - i.e. you could still do everything you can now without javascript, it would just be used to hide the voting buttons/links/whatever else is dynamic.
- mino 10y agoI've enjoyed HN for years with great benefit, entirely for free, so thanks a million! I have great respect for you guys. Said so... 2k comments, uncached render for logged in users and no pagination are a very low bar in 2016, especially for a YCombinator website. edit: saw dang's comment below and wanted to make sure this doesn't come through as harsh :)