4 ms·
>No plan was made because the people in a position to make one didn't want to and assumed victory. No plan was made by long-term Brexit supporters either. Wher
by foldr 10y ago
>No plan was made because the people in a position to make one didn't want to and assumed victory.
No plan was made by long-term Brexit supporters either. Where is Nigel Farage's plan? What useful suggestions has Boris Johnson made?
>And even if I did I would try to recognise that I share a country with such folk and have a duty to take their views into account.
We did take their views into account, as I said. The Conservative government bent over backwards to accommodate them.
The strategy you're proposing (engagement) was tried and has failed. It only had the effect of making Brexit seem more reasonable than it really was. Now we are in a position where the electorate have done something insane, and yet are in a position to demand that we take their insane views seriously.
- Nursie 10y agoWhy is any plan Farage might have come up with of the slightest interest? Are you suffering from the misapprehension that the referendum was an election for the leave campaign? Boris? Who knows. I'm not really defending Brexit here. My argument is that something along these lines was inevitable due to decades of ignoring people. The conservative government wanted to put a lid back on this and make it go away, their strategy was to show it up for what they assumed was the obviously stupid, minority viewpoint it was. They failed, but they were just the latest in a line of governments suffering from the smugness identified in the article.
- Nursie 10y agoOnce again - please don't think I'm defending the outcomes. The attitude that anyone disagreeing with you is insane is the problem. The fact you call leaving a political union 'insane' is part of the problem. And if the views on restricting migration hadn't been dismissed as insane for years, we might not be here.
- foldr 10y agoBut what if a large number of people actually have done something insane? You seem to refuse to accept this as a possibility. To my mind, the view that migration should be severely restricted never was dismissed. The present Conservative government agreed, and imposed all kinds of overly draconian restrictions. (I ended up paying several thousand pounds to get my Canadian husband a visa to live here.) Now the idea that immigration should be even further restricted is mainstream, even though it is mad. I'm interested in any plans that Farage might have made because it would be evidence that someone on the Leave side of the issue perhaps has a clue.
- Nursie 10y agoYet net migration figures stayed around 350k, which showed that either the politicians were not really engaging or were ineffective. I also don't see how you can call the idea of restricting that "mad". Genuinely I don't. I understand you can disagree, I understand you can disagree with the premises it's based on. But how is it "mad"? Your insistence on only dealing with the conservative government is also puzzling when we're talking about something that goes far further back.
- foldr 10y ago>Yet net migration figures stayed around 350k, which showed that either the politicians were not really engaging or were ineffective. Which, consulting Wikipedia’s list of countries by net migration, puts us below (amongst many others) Norway, Spain, Australia, Canada, Sweden, Switzerland, Italy, Ireland and Portugal. So it’s not exactly an unreasonably large number of immigrants we’re talking about here. (Especially when you consider that our net migration figures are bogus, since international students are wrongly included in them. Around 135,000 non-EU students entered the UK in 2014, for example.) >I also don't see how you can call the idea of restricting that "mad". Genuinely I don't. I understand you can disagree, I understand you can disagree with the premises it's based on. But how is it "mad"? We have an aging population and an economy that was just coming out of a recession. It’s not difficult to see why we need more immigrants. They’re young and net contributors to the economy. The idea that we could make things any better by shutting everyone out is, simply, mad. Perhaps in the short term some unemployed British people could switch from being unemployed to doing very badly paid, very menial jobs that are currently being done by Polish people. The net cost to the economy would most likely be far greater than the cost of simply increasing their benefits, though. >Your insistence on only dealing with the conservative government is also puzzling when we're talking about something that goes far further back. I don’t think I am insisting on that (?) I’m not quite sure what you mean.
- Nursie 10y agoThe British people considered it unreasonably large, for whatever reasons. They considered it important enough that after years of being ignored millions voted for UKIP or the Tories. Again I'm not here to argue merits. What you have there is more justifications for ignoring the views of large sections of the electorate. The rest of your argument is purely economic, as if that is or should be everything to everyone. And some of those points are arguable. I don't think that warrants calling people who disagree "mad". >> I don’t think I am insisting on that (?) I’m not quite sure what you mean. Oh just that I've been trying to make the point that politicians have been at this for decades and you bring up the conservatives as having tried to engage. I don't think they really did, and by the time they did it was too late. Engagement should have been there from Blair onward.
- aninhumer 10y ago>The strategy you're proposing (engagement) was tried and has failed. What was tried wasn't engagement, it was an attempt to suppress the issue by holding what they expected to be a doomed referendum, so they could use the result as an excuse to ignore the issue. True engagement would mean acknowledging people's concerns, and explaining their true causes and how you're going to address them.
- foldr 10y agoHow are you going to address the concerns of people who are opposed to all immigration from non-white and/or non-English-speaking countries? The Conservatives had already restricted immigration to a greater degree than is sensible.
- zigzigzag 10y agoThey did actually make suggestions, despite not campaigning to form a government. For example, an Australian style immigration system, striking a trade deal with the EU, continued cooperation in defense issues and so on. You just ignored them. Unfortunately it's rather hard to make plans about leaving the EU because the EU itself is in a catatonic state of denial. Their glorious leader banned even writing things down about the possibility of exit before the referendum, and afterwards announced they would still refuse to discuss it until Article 50 is invoked. This total denial of reality and absolute refusal to discuss it, is then used by people like Martin Schulz and yourself to claim Leave had no plan! Yes, Leave has a plan! It's called "get the hell out of this madhouse as quickly as possible". That's it!
- foldr 10y agoYou can blame it all on the EU if you like. We're still fucked. There's no way the EU will give us a good deal, and it turns out that no-one had any kind of realistic negotiating strategy. (Remember all that delusional nonsense from the Leavers about how Germany would have to give us a good deal because the country is run by its car industry? Oops...)
- zigzigzag 10y agoNo? Correct me if I'm wrong, but the US is now run by a guy who thinks the EU sucks, that Brexit was great, and whose best buddy in Europe is Nigel Farage. And is it not the case that the most popular politicians in other core countries are all anti-EU? Let's see how this plays out.
- foldr 10y agoAh I see, so their plan was for Trump to win the presidency and for the entire EU to collapse before we make a deal. Sure, let's see how that plays out. Third time lucky?
- zigzigzag 10y ago"Let's get out before the EU implodes" was actually a campaigning point, though not one that affected my own decision much. I would be surprised if the EU collapses. But then again, almost everyone was taken by surprise when the USSR disintegrated, and the conventional wisdom was that neither Brexit nor Trump could happen. So we'll see. Suffice it to say that there are structural weaknesses there. Regardless, sometimes you have to leave a social group if that group is becoming self-destructive, even if it hurts in the short run.