5 ms·
As someone who's actively vocalized his support for Trump in the past, both here[1] and in my meat space life, I'm ecstatic with the results of this election.
by koolba 10y ago
As someone who's actively vocalized his support for Trump in the past, both here[1] and in my meat space life, I'm ecstatic with the results of this election.
Not just the POTUS, but the trifecta of the house and senate as well. That's as loud of a mandate as can be expected from a strongly divided country. On top of all that, with the SCOTUS picks that are expected in the next few years, this election is going to be felt for many years to come.
I just hope that as we move forward with the transition to the new government, both sides can leave behind the incessant name calling and hate that's plagued this election. It's done, it's over, and the people have spoken. Now let's move forward on the direction that's been chosen and go about discussing it constructively.
[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12728645 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12728645
- _fizz_buzz_ 10y ago> That's as loud of a mandate as can be expected from a strongly divided country Is not winning the popular vote really a strong mandate? http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/09/501393501/shades-of-2000-clinton-surpasses-trump-in-popular-vote-tally http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/11/09/501393501/...
- yahyaheee 10y agoSeems like the people have spoken
- applecore 10y agoPoliticians know the electoral college decides the election. If the candidates had been campaigning for the popular vote, presumably Trump would campaign harder for more votes in large states like California and New York.
- _fizz_buzz_ 10y agoPossible. But so would've Clinton.
- webXL 10y agoClinton couldn't gain as much support because she already has most of the likely voters, and a lot of Republicans think, why bother, she's a lock for the electoral votes.
- _fizz_buzz_ 10y agoWhatever, with no data to back up your claim this is just hot air. Maybe she would've gotten more support from people that now decided to vote third party or didn't bother to vote at all. You can basically rationalize every outcome outcome if you don't have to rely on data.
- mch82 10y agoIt's about the people, not the politicians. The fact that campaign strategy matters more than campaign platform is a huge weakness in the current system.
- ng12 10y agoIt's like that by design. Representative democracy is intended to limit the ability of the majority to shoehorn the minority -- in this case the coastal population centers vs. the rest of the country.
- benchaney 10y ago>Representative democracy is intended to limit the ability of the majority to shoehorn the minority That is a benefit of certain aspects of our political system, but not the electoral college. The electoral college only serves to introduce bizarre volatility into the elections.
- pc86 10y agoThis is a nice sound bite (kind of), but doesn't bear out the actual facts. The EC was designed specifically to ensure that States (in the big-S, Constitutional meaning) decide the President, not the people.
- belorn 10y agoWas discussing this earlier, how many countries are actually ruled by popular vote? The recent Iceland election brings in mind, where the six constituencies makes a vote in Reykjavík count less than any other vote. The reason for that is if they didn't, citizens of Reykjavík would have a majority on their own in any national election. Similar, Sweden have a similar system where a vote from the small island of Gotland has 50% more impact compared to any other vote. The reason for that is that otherwise the island would only have 2 politicians in the parliament and the Swedish government wanted to have one more party representing the island than just the two major parties (which, based on those rules, means that the top 3 parties in Gotland is more or less guarantied one seat each).
- mylesm 10y agoI don't think any citizen's vote should count more than another just because they're part of a minority, geographic or otherwise. Imagine the uproar that would ensue if a politician suggested that a racial, ethnic, or religious minority group would have their votes count for more.
- belorn 10y agoI am more split on the issue. geographical votes result that problems and needs in one area don't get overlook because of population statistics. In the worst case this could lead to countries splitting up into smaller parts, just so that each area which its own special problems and needs can govern themselves. To take a practical example, the European parliament. Seats are allocated to each state according to population using degressive proportionality, which mean that Luxembourgish voters have roughly 10x more influence per voter than citizens of the six large countries. The alternative would be that Luxembourgish have practically no vote, since their population would be too small to even get a single seat, meaning their vote would have 0 influence. Which one is more fair?
- mylesm 10y agoI agree with you about the European parliament example, but speaking of the U.S. situation specifically, we already have a bicameral legislature with disproportionate representation for lower population states in one of its houses. We also have federal courts to step in when any laws are stepping on the rights of minority populations. You've also touched on one of the longest-running debates in American politics: should we treat states as independent and semi-autonomous or allow the federal government to dictate policy direction for the nation. You can probably tell what side I'm on. People still claim that the American civil war was about the South defending "states' rights" when I, and many others, feel that it was about defending the rights of many people actually in those states. That might be a little off topic. Anyway it's an interesting debate, but it's just hard to see how a candidate for national office can win more votes across the country and come out the loser.
- noobiemcfoob 10y agoI can't fathom you interpreting the result as a "loud mandate." The presidential race has been extremely tight with ~200,000 separating the two. Is that a clear mandate? No, it is a clear indication of the divisions in our country.
- oarsinsync 10y ago>> Not just the POTUS, but the trifecta of the house and senate as well. That's as loud of a mandate as can be expected from a strongly divided country > I can't fathom you interpreting the result as a "loud mandate." The presidential race has been extremely tight with ~200,000 separating the two. Is that a clear mandate? > No, it is a clear indication of the divisions in our country. Yes, the country is divided. A single party taking all three major government divisions is as loud a mandate as you can expect in a strongly divided country.
- mch82 10y ago> ...as loud a mandate as you can expect in a strongly divided country Only true if the way voting happened didn't disenfranchise voters. Yet we know that the way voting happened, with gerrymandering and discriminatory rules in some states, did disenfranchise voters.
- plussed_reader 10y agoSo you agree, the system is rigged? Because I see the candidate that clamored loudest about the system being rigged won.
- mch82 10y agoCheck it out: http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/10/26/us/elections/voter-id-laws.html http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/10/26/us/elections/voter-id-l... And a more recent article that reviews how the election went: https://www.thenation.com/article/the-gops-attack-on-voting-rights-was-the-most-under-covered-story-of-2016/ https://www.thenation.com/article/the-gops-attack-on-voting-... Look at who Trump is appointing, who his policies will hurt, and tell me who you think the system is rigged for? Can you find any articles about white, Republican voters unable to vote? I'm going to keep trying and will post back if I can.
- nohate 10y agoHow do you reconcile your desire to leave behind hate when you cast a vote for a candidate who's core positions were one of hate? If Trump does not continue a platform of hate, how would you not view that as a slap in the face as a supporter? He promised you hate, you said "Yes, I'll take one of those", and now say don't do that? You can not have it both ways, your vote is one for hate whether you bury your head in the sand about that point or not.
- nthcolumn 10y agoAfter his BS speech did you see him going down the line of people, kissing each woman on the left cheek, every one except the last one that is. She was about to pucker up and had to awkward kiss the guy next to her instead. Not racist? Yeah right. C'mon man she was at least a 7!
- nthcolumn 10y agoDownmod all you want - did you see it or not? What's your explanation?
- jernfrost 10y agoExactly give the man back what he has sown! He has catered to hatred and divisiveness. That is what he should get back.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>He promised you hate Can you point to where he actively promoted or promised "hate"? >You can not have it both ways, your vote is one for hate You assume those with whom you disagree are below you morally. This mentality is why Trump is president.
- mikeash 10y agoHe called for a ban on Muslim immigrants, said illegal Mexican immigrants are criminals and rapists, and suggested that his supporters should assassinate his opponent. That's just off the top of my head.
- pavlov 10y agoWhat are the milestones and key metrics for the "direction that has been chosen"? In four years, if the rural mine workers are still out of work and iPads are still made in China, will you concede that the experiment failed? I can't see Trump doing that. Deflecting blame has been a theme of his career. Therefore I'm frightened that he's going to need new scapegoats for his lack of achievements pretty soon... And considering the rhetoric he's used, there just is no telling who he might pick to receive the blame.
- SketchySeaBeast 10y agoThat's what I'm wondering about this whole thing - by what metrics can we test MAGA? I'm beginning to feel like this is Obama 2.0 when it comes to a revolution - in 4 to 8 years we will look back and go "huh, pretty much business as normal". I'm not worried about a random scapegoat, but I do just see this fizzling, and the anger and division being there again in 4 years time.
- pc86 10y ago> In four years, if the rural mine workers are still out of work and iPads are still made in China, will you concede that the experiment failed? That's like saying that because people still have to pay for insurance in the US that Obamacare failed and he's a failed President and should feel bad about himself.
- pavlov 10y agoObamacare failed and he's a failed President and should feel bad about himself Isn't that exactly what Republicans were saying? Trump wants to repeal Obamacare first and then replace it with something "much better, believe me". In good and bad, ACA was a big part of Obama's legacy. What are the yardsticks that should be applied to the Trump presidency? How many coal mines will be back in business and turning a profit? By what date will Apple be forced to bring back manufacturing into USA? When will American airports and roads become the best in the world? Those are a few of his most clearly defined goals, like healthcare reform was Obama's.
- Asdfbla 10y agoSeems extremely disingenuous that Trump supporters of all people would criticize hate and name calling when Trump's campaign was run on those issues, but I guess it's always easier to strike a conciliatory tone when you've won.
- TheGirondin 10y agoThe entire collective campaign strategy of Democrats has been to name call, demonize, and fear monger. Don't even try to pretend it was them.
- 1_2__3 10y agoSo calling your opponent "Crooked <name>" and repeatedly referring to them by what is effectively a slur was a... Democrat strategy?
- pc86 10y agoI'm not a Trump supporter by any stretch but mother of god if "crooked" which is literally just an adjective and is pretty appropriate when applied to Hillary Clinton is now considered a slur all these angry white people might just be on to something.
- Ajedi32 10y agoNo, but calling your opponent's supporters "deplorables" and repeatedly insinuating that they're all bigoted, sexist, racists was.
- oh_sigh 10y agoSee that Trump and Trump supporters largely limited their name calling to Hillary, whereas Hillary and Hillary supporters largely blasted on Trump as well as his supporters.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoAccusing people of racism and sexism isn't name calling.
- rndmio 10y agoGiven that the campaign was so divisive and acrimonious, what makes you think the losing side is just going to say 'ok' and get on board? If they think he's going to be as bad as they say surely they should do everything to frustrate him? Same as the Republicans did to Obama. It's naive to think that just because the vote is in that it's over, look at the UK and Brexit.
- ones_and_zeros 10y agoCan you explain to me what direction the country voted to move in? I'm really really trying to understand but all I see for the Trump voters is more economic pain under Trumps policies and I think will ultimately lead to more division as they dig their heels in as more time passes where they don't see the change they want. Trump supporters were sold the idea that illegal immigrants, legal immigrants, non-white people, muslims and gay people were a threat to the country and their livelihood. Removing these "threats" as Donald Trump has proposed will only benefit those at the top. So where does that leave us? Putting the screws to the perceived threats even more?
- matthewmacleod 10y agoNow let's move forward on the direction that's been chosen I guess one of the bigger problems is that it's utterly unclear what direction has been chosen. I think it's fair to say—do correct me if you think I'm wrong—that most of the policies that were advocated by Trump prior to the election will not be put into practice. There are a few reasons for that – many of them are practically unworkable, or contradictory, or will be objectively harmful. It seems that the actual policies that will take effect will be markedly different from those of the campaign. This is similar to Brexit in the UK, which was a campaign fought in a similar way – quite a few half-truths with no clear idea of what policy was being voted for. To me, this seems like a dangerous situation. Practically speaking, it is unlikely that Trump with 'make America great again' by solving all of the problems that his supporters face – not because he's a liar, but because that's an astonishingly difficult task to achieve. What happens in a couple of years when relatively limited progress has been made? Trump has no political barriers within the US, so who will be blamed for his inability to deliver on his promises? I worry that such a situation is a breeding ground for nationalism of the worst kind.
- ep103 10y agoThis was a rejection of the political establishment, rejection of neo-liberal economics, and a rejection of both the neo-conservative and (to a lesser degree) the libertarian wings of the republican party.
- mylesm 10y agoSerious question (and I think the source of the confusion as to what direction has been chosen): if all those philosophies have been rejected, what exactly are we left with? What was being advocated?
- ep103 10y agorejecting neoconservatism, and libertarianism, leaves you with traditional conservatism and cultural conservatism, or religious conservatism. On the social side, things like abortion, (anti) gay rights, etc. On the legal / economic side, actual pro-small business type changes, think 1950s republican. As for rejecting neo-liberal economics, there are tons of options. Without throwing out ideologies, though, I think the most likely things we'd see in America would be: Well, if bernie was elected I'd say things like trying to reform college tuition costs, expanding medicare, ensuring the stability of social security, new worker protections and federally promoted retraining of laid off / out of work workers, etc. guaranteed paid family leave, etc. From the conservative viewpoint, the people would probably want more focus on closing immigration loopholes used by businesses to avoid hiring domestically (h1bv, j1bv reform), actively enforcing punishments for employers utilizing illegal immigrants, retooling international trade agreements to favor small businesses and local producers as opposed to larger corporate interests, tax subsidies and encouragements for businesses that produce locally, etc.
- gnaritas 10y agoThere is no mandate here, and there will be no coming together; she's going to win the popular vote, dems win more votes in the house yet because of the electoral college and gerrymandering republicans carry the win. Nothing has happened here but a clear signal of how badly the system is broken when the will of the majority loses to a hateful minority due to a fucked up system.
- odonnellryan 10y agoI wouldn't be too concerned, but I'm really bent out of shape of any idea of repealing gay rights or abortion decisions.
- mch82 10y agoWhat change are you hoping to see?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- username3 10y agoWhat about the people that voted for someone else? If popular vote mattered, more people in uncontested states would vote.
- pc86 10y agoThe popular vote does matter, to allocate the Electors for each state. Popular vote was never intended to elect the POTUS.
- jernfrost 10y agoDon't think that is possible. If I was a democrat today I'd do like the Republicans have been doing the last 8 years and do my outmost to make the Trump Presidency be a major failure. The way the republicans have played this game is so dirty, that you can't expect people to forgive. We can not reward such a divisive character like Donald Trump with his racism, xenophobia, mysogny, insults and bullying with a successful presidency. Honestly I think the democrats should do the best the sabotage him and make sure everything he does fails. It should teach them a lesson that there is no reward in playing dirty and confrontational. If we reward this behavior it will only get worse. It is sad to say, but for the long term benefit of America it is probably better if it gets run to the ground over these four years. Then America will be spared for such leaders in the future.
- buckbova 10y ago> It is sad to say, but for the long term benefit of America it is probably better if it gets run to the ground over these four years. Then America will be spared for such leaders in the future. I heard this EXACT phrase said about Obama 8 years ago! We always get what we deserve. Hope, change, make america great again. > If I was a democrat today I'd do like the Republicans have been doing the last 8 years and do my outmost to make the Trump Presidency be a major failure. Good luck with that. GOP now has majorities and will probably pick up more in 2018. So be it.
- TAForObvReasons 10y agoDems started with a majority in both houses back in 2009-2010. Still didn't stop the GOP from filibustering and pulling out all the stops. This is a real test of the spine of the democratic party. Will they pull the same stunts the GOP did back then? Who knows
- buckbova 10y agoNew rules since then. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filibuster_in_the_United_States_Senate#Changes_in_2013 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filibuster_in_the_United_State... > The new rules remove the requirement of 60 votes in order to begin debate on legislation and allow the minority two amendments to measures that reach the Senate floor, a change implemented as a standing order that expires at the end of the current term. In the new rules, the amount of time to debate following a motion to proceed has been reduced from 30 hours to four. Additionally, a filibuster on the motion to proceed will be blocked if a petition is signed by eight members of the minority, including the minority leader.
- st3v3r 10y agoHow can you expect the millions of marginalized people to just "sit back and move in the direction that has been chosen" when that direction is one that believes they should not exist?
- oarsinsync 10y agoThe same way as people do every 4 years when one side doesn't get their way. This is the system we've collectively chosen. This is how it works. The alternative is even more extreme.
- gaur 10y ago> both sides can leave behind the incessant name calling and hate that's plagued this election Trump ran his campaign on incessant name calling and hate. If you voted for him, that means you're OK with letting the incessant name calling and hate continue.
- stagger87 10y agoNo it doesn't.
- oh_sigh 10y agoWeird that 99% of the incessant name calling and hate comes from my liberal friends who believe that all Trump supporters are racist xenophobes
- gaur 10y agoReality has a well-known liberal bias.
- oh_sigh 10y agoMy facebook certainly does.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoCalling someone a xenophobe isn't name calling. Calling someone a bitch or a nigger is name calling. The difference is whether the word us a critique of specific behavior, or just a general slur on the person or their identity.
- popmystack 10y ago>Now let's move forward on the direction that's been chosen Which is what, exactly?
- Scirra_Tom 10y agoSo your link doesn't give any reasons. What reasons are you happy about Trump for?
- inthewoods 10y ago"Now let's move forward on the direction that's been chosen and go about discussing it constructively." A few thoughts on this: - First, roughly half (and the majority of the votes) did not agree with this direction. That isn't much of a mandate. - Second, the party that won has repeatedly shown that they don't want to work on compromise, or follow standard procedure such as allowing a sitting President to get a hearing for a nominee for the Supreme Court. As a person that feels that this trifecta will change the country for years to come (as you rightly point out), my hope is that the Dems do exactly to Republicans what they've done for the last 4 years - obstruct in any way possible. I'm tired of one side feeling that they have to play by the rules and the other feeling they can ignore them. And I hope that Ruth Ginsburg serves at least for the first term.
- pc86 10y ago> allowing a sitting President to get a hearing for a nominee for the Supreme Court. Let's talk about George W. Bush's nominees... Politics is politics and to pretend that one side or the other plays them "dirty" and the other side plays them "clean" is naiveté of an astounding level.
- inthewoods 10y agoI'm not naive enough to think that Dems never play dirty, but what's astonishing that you seem to give the Republicans a complete pass with regard to their actual behavior by making a false equivalency: http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/mar/20/harry-reid/harry-reid-says-unlike-gop-senate-democrats-never-/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/mar/...
- plandis 10y agoWhy do you hate national parks Why do you deny climate change? Why do you support molesting women? Why do you think black people need to be stopped and frisked? Why do you hate gay people? Why do you think all Muslims are bad? Why do you think more religion in our government and schools is a good thing? Why do you hate women's reproductive rights? Why do you think we should actively consider using nuclear weapons? Why do you want to allow health care providers to deny coverage to some people essentially signing their death warrant? That's not name calling you voted for the guy and his running mate who think that way. What the fuck? What do you have against my gay friends who just want health care? What have they ever done to you?
- oh_sigh 10y agoWhat do you have to say about the women who voted for Trump. Do they support molesting themselves? What about the black people that voted for Trump? What about the gay people that voted for Trump? What about the Muslim people that voted for Trump?
- erikpukinskis 10y ago> What do you have to say about the women who voted for Trump. Do they support molesting themselves? They are feeling relatively safe from molestation. That good. They like to think it's because they are keeping themselves safe. If it's their doing then they're in control. So it feels good to them to blame women for their assaults and to believe that men like Trump aren't doing anything. It makes the world feel safer. The liberal position, that men like Trump do sexually assault people, and that rape is common, and your friends might do it to you, and you should probably believe rape accusations by default, is much scarier. Many women would rather not believe it if they can avoid it. Women with a LOT of privilege can safely believe it because they can use their prvilege (money etc) to stay safe. Women who are forced to be in unsafe positions can believe it, because they see how common sexual assault is. They are on the front line. Those two groups make up the feminist core. But there are a lot of women who are just trying to put as much distance as possible between themselves and the rape scene, and for them it's a bit of an abstract matter.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoI'm actually happy for you. And I'm scared about some things (mostly health care access and wars due to climate change) but I am also excited to see how some of these conservative policies pan out in practice. I hope it moves the dialog forward. That said, your mandate claim is kind of absurd. More people voted for Romney than Trump. And Obama got almost 10% more votes than Trump did. So it's not nearly "as loud as can be". Turnout was very low.