3 ms·
>Anyone that disagrees with my take on this issue is a moron. It's wrong to think that everyone who disagrees with you on anything is a moron. It's also wrong
by foldr 10y ago
>Anyone that disagrees with my take on this issue is a moron.
It's wrong to think that everyone who disagrees with you on anything is a moron. It's also wrong to deny the existence of morons who occasionally do moronic things.
I mean, we are talking about a group of people who held a referendum, knowing that the vote would be close, and then didn't even have a plan for what to do afterwards. The country is in chaos and the leaders of the Brexit brigade have all sodded off, having absolutely no idea what to do next.
We did consider the opinions of Brexit supporters. Their concerns were taken seriously. The Conservative government went overboard in its attempts to reduce migration and negotiate a more favorable deal with Europe. They really couldn't have done any more without doing something outright ridiculous. But that wasn't enough. So the public insisted that they do something ridiculous.
- Nursie 10y agoA last minute, failed attempt to do something a few months before a referendum that they comfortably and smugly assumed they would win easily. No plan was made because the people in a position to make one didn't want to and assumed victory. All this after AFAICT two decades of ignoring or belittling people for their deeply held views. That doesn't really cut it and so we get the result we got. Personally I neither think the country is in chaos nor do I believe that a vote for Brexit is a mark of idiocy. And even if I did I would try to recognise that I share a country with such folk and have a duty to take their views into account. The catastophising and continued moralistic judgements are another symptom of this poisonous thought pattern. Brexit was the breakpoint, but the preceding decades of smug politics are what got us there.
- foldr 10y ago>No plan was made because the people in a position to make one didn't want to and assumed victory. No plan was made by long-term Brexit supporters either. Where is Nigel Farage's plan? What useful suggestions has Boris Johnson made? >And even if I did I would try to recognise that I share a country with such folk and have a duty to take their views into account. We did take their views into account, as I said. The Conservative government bent over backwards to accommodate them. The strategy you're proposing (engagement) was tried and has failed. It only had the effect of making Brexit seem more reasonable than it really was. Now we are in a position where the electorate have done something insane, and yet are in a position to demand that we take their insane views seriously.
- Nursie 10y agoWhy is any plan Farage might have come up with of the slightest interest? Are you suffering from the misapprehension that the referendum was an election for the leave campaign? Boris? Who knows. I'm not really defending Brexit here. My argument is that something along these lines was inevitable due to decades of ignoring people. The conservative government wanted to put a lid back on this and make it go away, their strategy was to show it up for what they assumed was the obviously stupid, minority viewpoint it was. They failed, but they were just the latest in a line of governments suffering from the smugness identified in the article.
- Nursie 10y agoOnce again - please don't think I'm defending the outcomes. The attitude that anyone disagreeing with you is insane is the problem. The fact you call leaving a political union 'insane' is part of the problem. And if the views on restricting migration hadn't been dismissed as insane for years, we might not be here.
- foldr 10y agoBut what if a large number of people actually have done something insane? You seem to refuse to accept this as a possibility. To my mind, the view that migration should be severely restricted never was dismissed. The present Conservative government agreed, and imposed all kinds of overly draconian restrictions. (I ended up paying several thousand pounds to get my Canadian husband a visa to live here.) Now the idea that immigration should be even further restricted is mainstream, even though it is mad. I'm interested in any plans that Farage might have made because it would be evidence that someone on the Leave side of the issue perhaps has a clue.
- Nursie 10y agoYet net migration figures stayed around 350k, which showed that either the politicians were not really engaging or were ineffective. I also don't see how you can call the idea of restricting that "mad". Genuinely I don't. I understand you can disagree, I understand you can disagree with the premises it's based on. But how is it "mad"? Your insistence on only dealing with the conservative government is also puzzling when we're talking about something that goes far further back.
- aninhumer 10y ago>So the public insisted that they do something ridiculous. The public aren't the ones who decided to have a referendum, the government are. If you're arguing that it was moronic to hold a referendum with no clear plan for one of the possible outcomes, I totally agree, but that's not the public's fault.
- foldr 10y agoI mean that the public insisted that we leave the EU by voting to leave the EU. Just because someone asks a silly question doesn't mean that you have to give a silly answer.
- aninhumer 10y agoPeople voted in the way that best expressed their beliefs given the choice as presented. If they'd voted remain, the government wouldn't have said "Oh I guess that was a poorly defined referendum, let's work out a proper plan and have another." they'd have used it as an excuse to ignore the issue.
- foldr 10y ago>People voted in the way that best expressed their beliefs given the choice as presented. That is true of any election, no? >If they'd voted remain, the government wouldn't have said "Oh I guess that was a poorly defined referendum, let's work out a proper plan and have another." they'd have used it as an excuse to ignore the issue. Quite possibly, but I don't see how that is relevant. We seem to be in agreement?
- aninhumer 10y agoHmm, I thought the "silly question" was the referendum, but maybe you meant that's the silly answer? I thought you were blaming the public, but if you're primarily blaming the politicians then I agree.
- 10y ago