4 ms·
On November 6, 2000, during his final pre-election stump speech, Bush explained his history of political triumph thusly: "They misunderesimated me." What an id
by jessaustin 10y ago
On November 6, 2000, during his final pre-election stump speech, Bush explained his history of political triumph thusly: "They misunderesimated me."
What an idiot. American liberals made fun of him for that one for years.
It is worth considering that he didn't misspeak.
He did, however, deliberately cultivate the confusion. He understood the smug style.
W's was perhaps a more subtle dominating response to the Smug, but at this point we can't say it was different than Trump's. Both of them went to school with the Smug. They know what it represents both to itself and to the majority of the nation. Neither of them buy into it themselves, unlike e.g. Romney.
Democrats lose when the Republican candidate has an authentic and rhetorically effective response to the Smug. Now that it's happened twice, at least some Republicans will remember it the next time around. Democrats will either do the hard work of excising this from their ideology and communication, or they will lose in the same way again.
- cafard 10y agoYou aren't wrong, or not all wrong. However, you must consider a) that Nader made a very large difference in 2000, and b) that Trump got to run against Hillary Clinton. She is intelligent and able, but she has been a handy target for conservative media for twenty years now, and a good deal of that stuck with voters. "Both of them went to school with the Smug"; well, yes, and some would find it curious that our populists come from Yale and Penn.
- jessaustin 10y agoJohnson seems to have gotten more votes than Nader; Johnson and Stein together definitely did so. In many of the "battleground" states, Trump's margin is totally swamped by third-party numbers. The observations you've made about Clinton aren't news to anyone. The fact she was nominated anyway, with her only primary opposition coming from outside the party, after the DNC had let it be known to all potential opponents that the fix was well and truly in, is symptomatic of the Smug. The insiders couldn't imagine the average voter rejecting the candidate chosen by the insiders. Maybe they still can't imagine it, only now it has happened. They're stuck in a loop, and for the next iteration the Republicans will know just what to do. Hint: it won't be another Romney.
- cafard 10y agoI upvoted you. However, I think that Clinton was seen as the safe candidate: she had name recognition, she didn't scare Wall Street. That is not wholly the same as being the candidate of Smug. I trust that the Democratic Party will understand that it has run out of ideas. Will the Republicans know what to do? It strikes me as quite possible that Trump's qualities could be those of a one-term president.
- jessaustin 10y agoWas that "didn't scare Wall Street" or was it "had accepted tens of millions of dollars from Wall Street"? If Wall Street gets final vet, the Democrat party has changed from the days of FDR. (OT: will they or any of the other Clinton Family Foundation donors ask for refunds?) The inability to see how conflicts of interest look from outside is a Smugness that has afflicted Democrats and Republicans both. Trump could definitely be a one-termer. I could see him getting bored and letting Pence take over, or deciding to campaign for someone else in his cabinet, or even figuring out something so terrible that it will finally make evangelicals vote against him. Or, he could be like Reagan and W, just let his people handle everything, and sail on to a second term.
- cafard 10y agoIndeed the Democratic Party has changed since the days of FDR. It is amusing to consider that FDR thought that a realignment of the parties might be beneficial, with the Republicans picking up the conservative (often southern) Democrats and the Democrats picking up the more liberal (often northeastern) Republicans. How'd that work out? And of course you are completely correct on the inability to perceive conflicts of interest--where they are or where they just might be.
- bobwaycott 10y agoPedantic nit: it's the Democratic Party. Its members are Democrats.
- LanceH 10y agoI would say her selection was a political payoff from insiders first. Second it was to put a woman out there for the smug base to go crazy voting for her.
- mikeash 10y agoI think Democrats just need to nominate better candidates. Al Gore was so boring that his Secret Service nickname was "Al Gore." (A joke, but one he told himself.) Clinton was a terrible candidate who only had a chance because she was running against another terrible candidate. (And to clarify, I think Clinton was a decent candidate in terms of her policies and her ability to do the job. But she was a terrible candidate in terms of her potential to win. The widespread dislike of her among the electorate may have been unfair, but that doesn't mean it wasn't real.) Or perhaps nominating bad candidates is just a consequence of the "smug"? Maybe that's what pushes Democrats to think that it's OK if a candidate is boring or unpopular as long as they have good ideas.
- curun1r 10y agoThe Democrats had a good candidate and they were scared he wasn't centrist enough. If there's a lesson from this election, it's that when a candidate inspires a populist movement, the parties should just let it play out instead of trying to stop it in favor of an establishment candidate. Both parties tried to stop it, but only the Democrats succeeded. The general election was their punishment. Bernie would have beaten Trump. The crucial "rust belt" states that Clinton lost were states where Bernie beat her too. They're states that want to vote Democratic but felt that the Democrat didn't care about their struggles. His platform was completely targeted at helping the lower- and middle-class. Oh, and he probably has no idea what an email server is, let alone how to run his own.
- linkregister 10y agoThe major argument against Sanders was that his platform was unrealistic. Remembering the disappointment that President Obama stoked when he was unable to execute much of his platform, many Democratic electors said they wanted the candidate that had a more modest platform that could be realistically achieved. In hindsight, sure, you are right. It's hard to know what do in the moment.
- curun1r 10y agoEven if you concede that Sanders' platform was unrealistic, he would have been running against a candidate that wants to build a wall costing somewhere north of 11-figures, get Mexico to pay for it, negotiate better trade deals through sheer force of will and deport millions of illegal immigrants. It's clear the electorate didn't take reality into consideration when casting their votes.