4 ms·
I am (somewhat deliberately, since this thread was initially about Brexit + Trump being part of a more general trend) conflating what Trump said about immigrati
by nostrademons 10y ago
I am (somewhat deliberately, since this thread was initially about Brexit + Trump being part of a more general trend) conflating what Trump said about immigration with what his supporters have said about immigration. Trump's proposal was about illegal immigration. I actually think that as president he's going to be a lot more moderate than many on the left fear.
I'm also pretty sure that there are supporters of his that actually want to send all immigrants back to where they came from. "America for Americans", right? And most of the hypotheticals in this thread are about what happens if that wing of the party gets its way and pushes through rather extremist legislation.
- Goladus 10y agoI'm also pretty sure that there are supporters of his that actually want to send all immigrants back to where they came from. They want to protect their culture and values from the effects of mass immigration from people with very different heritage and values who are discouraged from assimilating and encouraged to join in the culture of grievance and victimhood preached by the progressive left. Repatriate everyone is definitely the most extreme position I have seen. A moratorium on all immigration is the next most extreme. Then there's the White Nationalist contingent, they are OK with immigration so long as it is from Europe but not anywhere else. Regardless, there's a general sense that the inflow of illegals must be stopped before any plan for amnesty should be allowed on the table and that the prevailing dogma that the entire world has a fundamental human right to immigrate to the US needs to be rejected completely.
- cheiVia0 10y agoIsn't America made up almost entirely of immigrants?
- nostrademons 10y agoGo back far enough, sure. Most people go back to one or two generations after when their ancestors first came to America to set the bar for who's an immigrant. It's like Ann Coulter's tweet last night where she said nobody should be able to vote unless all 4 of their grandparents were born in America - and then had to put her foot in her mouth when people pointed out that this would disqualify Donald Trump.
- domfletcher 10y agoThe dangerous thing is not about policy or specific proposals but who is empowered. Ann Coulter will be treated as a serious policy voice now because she stood with Trump. See Brexit with Farage, Boris et al.
- zo1 10y agoThat's like saying isn't the world made up mostly of Africans? Since it's said that we're all descended from individuals that lived in Africa before anywhere else. So yeah, as the other poster mentioned, "if you go back far enough". If you go back far enough, we're all relatives, too. But that doesn't necessarily have meaning by itself. It's the individuals that choose to, or choose not to, apply meaning from such a technicality.
- TheMiller 10y agoIt's no more of a "technicality" than the fact that some people happened to be born within the somewhat arbitrary borders of a particular nation, through no effort of their own, and thus happen to be considered citizens of that nation.
- wolfgke 10y ago> Isn't America made up almost entirely of immigrants? Even lots of illegal immigrants. :-)
- SixSigma 10y agoLike, you know, almost everywhere except some bits of Africa
- rmc 10y ago> I actually think that as president he's going to be a lot more moderate than many on the left fear. Just like how he was much more moderate once he got the nominatim and didn't have to appeal to just the republican base?
- pshposh 10y agoIt's interesting how people can project what Trump will do. Pivot is not something he will do.
- nutspanther 10y agoCriticizes people for projecting what Trump will do, then projects what Trump will do...
- pshposh 10y agoIt's more a reflection on how he has operated so far. Also, his own son has stated pivoting is not what Trump will do. What you see is what you get.
- brewdad 10y agoMy fear with Trump lies exactly in the unknown. He hasn't given very many policy specifics. Traditional Republicans are likely to step in to fill that vacuum. Will Trump push back and force policy to the center, or will he allow Congress to do as they please so long as he comes out with the credit? Hard to say at this point.
- losvedir 10y ago> conflating what Trump said about immigration with what his supporters have said about immigration Please find me a single example of this. I haven't heard a single republican ever complain about legal immigration.
- Goladus 10y agoHere are four examples: John Derbyshire (http://www.unz.com/jderbyshire/orlando-paris-yorkshire-and-donald-trumps-unanswerable-questions-about-immigration/ http://www.unz.com/jderbyshire/orlando-paris-yorkshire-and-d...) Steve Sailer (http://www.unz.com/isteve/will-the-zeroth-amendment-trump-the-first-amendment/ http://www.unz.com/isteve/will-the-zeroth-amendment-trump-th...) Ann Coulter (author of Adios, America: The Left's Plan to Turn Our Country into a Third World Hellhole) Pat Buchanan (http://buchanan.org/blog/immigration-time-out-163 http://buchanan.org/blog/immigration-time-out-163)
- JshWright 10y agoAs long as the person immigrating has the right color skin and prays to the right god.
- Goladus 10y agoAs long as the person immigrating has the right color skin and prays to the right god More accurately: comes from a compatible culture and shows an interest and willingness to assimilate.
- shawndumas 10y agoI think that what people are trying to explain is that that kind of shaming, accusatory, intentional, mischaracterization of the 'right' is what caused us to now have Trump as our president. You are alienating them. The kind of people that I know that actually voted for Trump could not care less about the color/religion of a person so long as they had a basic desire to assimilate. In other words; come to America to become an American not to make America like place you left. Now we have an obligation to understand these Trump voters as generously as possible; or we can berate, belittle, and battle-harden them and get another Trump (or worse) in 8 years.
- arcticbull 10y agoRepealing NAFTA gets rid of the bulk of your legal Canadians and Mexicans on TN status, which is I'd imagine how the bulk of them are there given the low cost, ease and lack of caps of the program.
- randomguy23 10y agoI would say that this (US portion) crowd has been hit negatively by immigration: H1B ring any bells? Can anyone other than CEOs hoping for cheap labor argue that scaling back H1B would be a bad thing?