3 ms·
Dubai is a much worse place than California for the Hyperloop for two reasons: 1. Dubai and Abu Dhabi is only 100 miles. That's not nearly enough to make the
by lisper 10y ago
Dubai is a much worse place than California for the Hyperloop for two reasons:
1. Dubai and Abu Dhabi is only 100 miles. That's not nearly enough to make the Hyperloop economically attractive even if it were to work (which it won't, see point #2). Regular high-speed rail can make this trip in 30 minutes. It's just not worth paying N times as much for some value of N>>1 to shave 18 minutes off of that. 300 miles (like San Francisco to LA) is about the minimum distance for the hyperloop to compete with conventional high speed rail even under ideal circumstances.
2. Dubai has bigger thermal swings than California, so the thermal expansion problem -- which is still unsolved -- will be that much worse in Dubai.
- sharpercoder 10y agoI the thermal expansion problem is solved in Dubai, it also means that it can be solved on many more places. From a prototypal standpoint, it's a pretty good place.
- lisper 10y agoIt is far from clear that the thermal expansion problem can be solved at all. AFAICT no one has ever proposed a solution that is even remotely close to being viable.
- ash 10y agoCould you please show why very-low-speed, low-precision linear bearing to "allow longitudinal slip" of the tube past the pillars, is not "even remotely close to being viable". It's an honest question. I know very little about bearings, but I have yet to find a serious discussion about it anywhere.
- lisper 10y agohttp://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloop/ http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloop/
- ash 10y agoWhy do you keep posting this article? It can't be a critique of the free "longitudinal slip" linear bearings proposal, because the author assumed the tube is rigidly attached to the pillars. (And it is not.)
- benjaminva 10y ago1. From a sane point of view, this argument makes sense but the UAE don't have a money problem and prestige/aura of modern technology is weighted much heavier than economical reasoning. It would be a huge attraction and a big reputation boost - they could again argue that UAE is where the future is built, not the USA. 2. It is hot down there but from what I have experienced, the thermal swings are lower than on a normal Central European or American day. This means in October 35 C during the day, 30 C at night.
- lisper 10y agoThe hyperloop's thermal problems are not the result of day-to-day swings, they are the result of overall swings. This is because the entire track has to be a single length of welded steel tubing. The thermal expansion at the ends is just ridiculous -- hundreds of meters. It doesn't matter if this happens over the course of a day or over the course of a year, it's still going to be a show-stopper.
- cup 10y agoIf the thing is built underground thermal swings wont matter. Furthermore, there is definitely a large market for people that want to get between AD and Dubai in as short as possible a time. Sure, high speed rail would be great but people would be willing to pay extra to shave off 12 minutes.
- lisper 10y ago> If the thing is built underground That would make it the longest subway in the world by a factor of 3. Not going to happen.
- ash 10y agoI agree with your point #1, but your point #2 makes very little sense. Yes, thermal expansion problem solution from the original Hyperloop paper [1] is yet to be proven to work in practice. For one, nobody has built long enough straight tube for the thermal expansion problem to matter. However, I don't see how the difference in thermal swings between California and Dubai matters. The proposed solution probability of success or failure should be the same no matter what are the thermal swings. We are talking about (maybe?) 300 meters vs 500 meters per day of expansion for the same tube length. And Dubai - Abu Dhabi route length is much shorter than SF - LA, as you've correctly noticed. [1]: "The tube will be supported by pillars which constrain the tube in the vertical direction but allow longitudinal slip for thermal expansion <…> Specially designed slip joints at stations will be able to take any tube length variance due to thermal expansion."(http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha.pdf, page 28, section 4.2.3)
- lisper 10y ago> I don't see how the difference in thermal swings between California and Dubai matters. It doesn't really. But whatever thermal expansion problems you have in California you will have them worse in Dubai. > Specially designed slip joints at stations will be able to take any tube length variance due to thermal expansion See: http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloop/ http://www.leancrew.com/all-this/2013/08/hyperloop/ for a detailed explanation of why this is not an adequate solution.
- ash 10y agoYes, I'm aware of this post. Unfortunately, its author failed to discuss the solution from the Hyperloop paper. The author incorrectly assumed the tube is attached rigidly to the pillars and then proceeded to criticise this wrong assumption.
- lisper 10y agoYou need to go back and re-read this paper more carefully. The author does discuss exactly the proposal in the paper. He even quotes it: "But the real problem isn’t with the slip joints at the ends; it’s with the pillar supports along the way. Musk thinks the dampers, “tucked away inside each pylon,” need to accommodate only “the small length changes between pylons.” Wrong." In other words, the original hyperloop white paper assumes that the movement at each pylon is small, and that the only large-scale movement is at the ends. But this is wrong. There is large-scale movement throughout the system. The thermal expansion motion reaches a maximum at the ends, but it doesn't magically go away as soon as you leave the station. If the tube at the station is moving 100m then the tube near the station is moving 100 meters minus epsilon.