5 ms·
Gravitons always struck me as a goofy half-baked concoction (even though we've supposedly observed them now), and so did dark matter. Emergent gravity theories
by hammock 10y ago
Gravitons always struck me as a goofy half-baked concoction (even though we've supposedly observed them now), and so did dark matter. Emergent gravity theories are very interesting.
- wbhart 10y agoObserving gravitational waves is not really the same as observing individual gravitons. It's unlikely we can observe gravitons with any equipment we can actually build.
- hammock 10y agoYou are right, we have detected gravitational waves not gravitons. Thanks for clarifying
- wanda 10y ago> even though we've supposedly observed [gravitons] now Source? Or are you saying that the existence of gravitational waves constitute a proof of the existence of gravitons, due to wave/particle duality? I'm not a physicist, but all I thought we had detected were gravitational waves.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> the existence of gravitational waves constitute a proof of the existence of gravitons, due to wave/particle duality I always thought this is the case. But IANAP either. Could anyone with actual knowledge chime in?
- ars 10y agoNo, a gravitational wave has mass (carries mass is more accurate), but a graviton does not. They are not two aspects of the same thing.
- empath75 10y agoIn a quantum field theory, a wave implies a force carrying particle, does it not?
- ars 10y agoYes, but the particle can be virtual, not actual.
- codethief 10y agoSince QFT usually involves perturbation theory of a free field, whether or not particles are virtual (= intermediate products of interactions) is beside the point.
- codethief 10y agoTo be precise, particles (with precise momentum) are certain modes or excitations of a quantum field which is often governed by something like a wave equation. However, not all quantum fields (and their associated particles) are force carriers. These are usually just the gauge bosons. In any case, though, noone has managed to quantize gravity yet (i.e. describe gravity as a quantum field theory with gravitons as force carriers), so we've detected just gravitational waves but no gravitons.
- raattgift 10y agoWell, we've quantized gravitation extremely well - it's just perturbative quantum gravity, of which there are a couple flavours. In weak gravity it makes predictions identical to General Relativity, but is taken to be an effective field theory (in the Charles Wilson sense of "effective) in that we do not know how to deal with Feynman diagrams with more than a loop or two of gravitons, which only happens in strong gravity. In these theories, gravitons are quantizations of the weak-field perturbations. The non-renormalizability by power-set counting of gravity because it is a long-range force is a good result of perturbatively quantized gravity. Who knows if there is a workable way of renormalization by other methods? Not me. Since we don't get strong gravity except close to a black hole singularity or in the extremely early universe, it's unfair and premature to say that the EFT approach has been unsuccessful.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoGravitons are simply quanta of gravitational waves. They arise in the same way as photons in electromagnetism. There's nothing goofy about them.
- theptip 10y agoGoofy in what way? All other known forces are carried by particles, so why not gravity?
- raattgift 10y agoGravitons appear in several different families of theory. We have not observed any of them; the interaction cross-section is so small (because gravity is so weak) that we have no hope of observing a single graviton, or failing to observe an expected one, any time soon. Gravitational waves have spin 2 symmetry and are massless. A straightforward quantization of a gravitational wave leads to gravitons as a spin 2 massless gauge boson. Conversely, in almost any gauge theory that admits a massless spin 2 particle, that particle mediates a force almost exactly like gravitation, and is amenable to analysis under the Paramaterized Post-Newtonian Formalism. Indeed, when gravity is weak, such theories essentially exactly reproduce General Relativity. It's only in strong gravity that non-negligible differences appear, and in this case strong gravity is when the quantum uncertainty in curvature distorts distances in ways that can't be worked around e.g by a change of basis or system of coordinates. Alternatively, gravity is strong when you have multiple loops of gravitons in a Feynman diagram. So in the type of quantization above, the problem is that the momentum carried by an individual graviton is much much much much smaller than that carried by an individual low frequency photon. For example, a near-infrared photon has a momentum-energy on the order of about 1 eV/c^2, a 100 MHz photon has an energy on the order of 10^-7 eV/c^2, and a graviton will be less than 10^-22 eV/c^2 (LIGO collab., https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.03837 https://arxiv.org/abs/1602.03837, about six paragraphs before section VIII). In other words, even the extremely weak signals LIGO's detected represent waves comprising huuuuuuge numbers of gravitons. But each graviton is so weak (or equilvalent long-wavelengthed) that we have no hope of detecting it individually. Think of how much fun you would have trying to isolate with your fingers an individual molecule of water in a surfers-beware ocean wave -- that'd be easier than isolating a graviton from a presently-detectable GW.
- auntienomen 10y agoGravitons are basically unavoidable. They may not be fundamental particles, but they'll always show up in the long-wavelength approximation of any theory of quantum gravity that extends general relativity.