3 ms·
But humans already make those judgements, and when they make errors, it's tragic too. If a psychologist erroneously decides that you're a menace to yourself and
by golergka 10y ago
But humans already make those judgements, and when they make errors, it's tragic too. If a psychologist erroneously decides that you're a menace to yourself and should be institutionalized, would it make you feel better that it was a human that made this decision? Even if AI would make the same error with a much lower probability?
- oelmekki 10y agoThis is a good point. I guess the difference here will be "how much do we trust human judgement?" and "how much do we trust AI predictions?". If AIs make 10% less errors than humans but we have 50% more trust in them, that's a problem. Eugenics were not a problem because science was wrong, but because people blindly trusted it to apply where it should not. There are a lot of things to consider, here, those are exciting times for thinking.
- kec 10y agoThe concern isn't the lack of humanity, it's technology allowing for massive scale. The potential damage of a buggy machine learning classifier is much higher than that of an unskilled psychologist.
- tomjen3 10y agoI can't speak for OP, but that is one reason I want to end all involuntary treatments. Getting locked up in a psych facility is a nightmare to me. But you can at least sue a doctor and get his license revoked. It is much harder to sue an algorithm.
- golergka 10y ago> I want to end all involuntary treatments Are you sure you have thought through all implications? I mean, getting locked up sounds pretty scary, but there are a lot of other scary stories that can happen if you really ban the whole concept of involuntary treatments.