4 ms·
"The Finder's user interface is far superior to that of the "MS-DOS Executive" used in Microsoft's Windows 1.x and 2.x or even the Program Manager / File Manag
by izacus 10y ago
"The Finder's user interface is far superior to that of the "MS-DOS Executive" used in Microsoft's Windows 1.x and 2.x or even the Program Manager / File Manager of Windows 3.x. It wasn't until Windows 95 (11 years later) that Microsoft would even come close to the look and feel of the Finder - then they threw it all away and replaced it with a web browser in Windows 98."
Can someone explain this? What was so much better in Finder that wasn't matched even in Windows 3.1?
- bcheung 10y agoI'm still amazed that the Mac Finder still doesn't let you cut and paste files with Cmd-X, Cmd-V like you can in Windows. That's one thing I miss from Windows. It was so much easier to move files around. Having to have 2 windows open and drag and drop using the mouse is so much more inconvenient than keeping your hand on the keyboard the entire time.
- digi_owl 10y agoMy understanding is that it violates the mental concept of a cut. When you cut in a document, the text gets removed from its original location. A file can't be such removed.
- frandroid 10y agoOr that you can't paste a URL in the filename field of an open-file dialog... That's a really neat Windows feature I was using all the time. Now on OSX I have to right-click on a page/image, save it to my local drive, then go back to the dialog, navigate to the directory where I saved the file, and load that.
- dspig 10y agoYou can drop a file on the OSX open-file dialog to navigate to that location and select the file. That helps a bit.
- abritinthebay 10y agoIt's had that feature for a long time. Copy the file, then "paste" it with the Option key. That performs a move operation. Or, to put in another way: ⌘-C then ⌘-Opt-V
- frandroid 10y agoSigh. Talk about hiding keyboard shortcuts.
- abritinthebay 10y agoNot really... Option is the standard Mac way of modifying a command. In this case the modification is "place these here and remove the originals". It's only "cut" on Windows because it's a leaky abstraction from a document based approach. That makes no sense in a filesystem. It would be extraordinarily strange for Apple to have ported that broken abstraction. The "cut" shortcut works as you'd expect in document-based programs.
- frandroid 10y agoIt might be a standard modifier, but you don't go around every menu pressing and depressing option to see the alternatives. I mean, you can, but to use your metaphor, it's a leaky way of exposing available options. All options should be shown when you click on a menu, without having to press extra keys. "Cut" greys out a file in the Windows File Explorer, showing that it could be cut n' pasted. Cut n' paste is a leaky metaphor for "Move this from here to there" anyway, which is what people want to do 80% of the time when they use this function. People can deal with leaky metaphors that follow the same vector as the original.
- abritinthebay 10y agoEverything you wrote ONLY makes sense because you know how Cut works. It's literally affirming the consequent as applied to UI design and isn't helpful at all.
- yuhong 10y agoFile Manager did not have icons for files. It was basically just a listing of filenames.
- EvanAnderson 10y agoThe MS-DOS Executive was a quasi-graphical shell that shipped in Windows 1.0 (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_shell#MS-DOS_Executive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_shell#MS-DOS_Executive). Windows "Program Manager" was strictly a "launch pad" to start applications and didn't support arbitrary file management. "File Manager" handled file management operations (though if memory serves you could launch applications from it). Finder integrated file management and application launch. Arguably this wasn't integrated in Windows until the Windows 95 Explorer shell came along.
- david-given 10y agoWindows 3.1 didn't have a combined file manager/program launcher. Instead, there were two different apps. There was the program manager: http://toastytech.com/guis/win31progman3.png http://toastytech.com/guis/win31progman3.png Those icons don't represent files; they are 'program items', i.e. launchers. This was the file manager: http://toastytech.com/guis/win31winfile.png http://toastytech.com/guis/win31winfile.png You could launch programs from this, but only if you knew where they were installed and were willing to navigate there and then figure out which cryptically named .exe file it was. And, yes, the windows-in-windows organisation of both applications was a mess. Losing entire subwindows off the side of the program manager because you'd placed them somewhere and then resized the outer window, making them invisible, was totally a thing. The classic Mac, with its combined file manager and program launcher, and its single-file applications (usually), and its human readable filenames, and generally a whole bunch of little subtle usability features such as the way that icons remembered whether they'd been placed manually or had been autoplaced, was enormously better.
- digi_owl 10y agoAh yes, progman. I am unsure if anyone ever ran it other than maximized (only pesky problem was that switching between running programs required a trip to the desktop, or remember to hit alt-tab). As for finding something based on directory location and file name, thats how you had to do it in the underlying DOS anyways so you quickly memorized your most used paths (if you fired up Windows at all).