5 ms·
our brain is a 20W meat computer. i'd say that believing it can't be reproduced is quite mystical indeed. it's a matter of time; it'll be a 20MW factory-sized s
by baq 10y ago
our brain is a 20W meat computer. i'd say that believing it can't be reproduced is quite mystical indeed. it's a matter of time; it'll be a 20MW factory-sized supercomputer at first, but it'll be done. not saying it'll happen in this decade, or the next, but this century must be it, assuming humanity makes it to 2100s.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoSo, I don't get this. The fact that the brain uses very little power and yet manages to solve really hard problems means that whatever it's doing is very efficient. The fact that ANNs need terrabytes of data and petaflops of processing power and still can only show rudimentary aptitude in mechanical tasks means they're not very efficient at all. Not that anyone ever called ANNs "efficient" (I'm not talking about backprop- but about iterating through covariance matrices). But if they were as efficient as the brain, they'd now be way, way smarter than us. We know from undergraduate Comp Sci that there are problems that can simply not be solved, except with efficient algorithms. The fact that the brain is doing something terribly efficient is a big hint that whatever it's doing requires it to be that (because evolution hand waving hand waving). ANNs are nothing like that - they're practically brute force. So how then can anyone expect that we're going to solve the hard problems the brain can, with ANNs?
- ak4g 10y agoThis is just an outdated view of the state-of-the-art. It's understandable, given that it's outdated by maybe six months, iff you're willing to go with preprints. https://arxiv.org/abs/1605.06065 https://arxiv.org/abs/1605.06065 A hobbyist looking for something plug-and-play will still generally want lots of data; the cutting edge is not exactly "curl|bash"-able. But the papers coming out this year have been dispatching what I thought would be entire areas of study in a dozen pages, one after another after another. Not only do I think it's a "when" and not an "if", I think the timelines people throw around date to "ancient" times - meaning, a few years ago. Given where were are right now, what we should be asking is whether "decades" should be plural.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"This is just an outdated view of the state-of-the-art. It's understandable, given that it's outdated by maybe six months, iff you're willing to go with preprints." That's an understandable, but probably incorrect, view that comes from focusing on claims in state-of-the-art publications too much without the wider context of history & brain function. The problem parent is referring to also includes the general, "common sense" that we build up over time with extreme diversity of experiences that is developed despite tons of curveballs & able to create them ourselves. New knowledge is incorporated into that framework pretty smoothly. An early attempt to duplicate that was Cyc project's database of common sense. There's maybe just five or six total per Minsky with most AI researchers not thinking it's important. Those last words told me to be pessimistic already. Whereas, the only computer capable of doing what they are trying to do uses a diverse set of subsystems specialized to do their jobs well. A significant amount of it seems dedicated to establishing common sense tying all experiences together. The architecture is capable of long-term planning, reacting to stuff, and even doing nothing when that makes sense. It teaches itself these things based on sensory input. It does it all in real-time with what appears to be a mix of analog and digital-like circuits in tiny amount of space and energy. And despite this, it still takes over a decade of diverse, training data to become effective enough to do stuff like design & publish ANN schemes. :) There's hardly anything like the brain being done in ANN research that I've seen. The cutting-edge stuff that's made HN is pale imitation with small subset of capabilities trying to make one thing do it all. The pre-print you posted is also rudimentary compared to what I described above. Interestingly, the brain also makes use of feedback designs where most I see shared here (like in the late 90's) was feed-forward as if trying to avoid exploring the most effective technique that already solved the problem. Like the linked paper did. They just all seem to be going in fundamentally wrong directions. Such directions will lead to nice, local maxima but miss the global maxima by a long shot. Might as well backtrack while they're ahead if they want the real thing.
- ak4g 10y agoSorry - should have quoted the specific thing I was calling out-of-date, which was from a few comments up-thread: > Brains (read: humans) can learn from very few examples and in very little time. [...] Those are all things that ANNs have proven quite incapable of doing, as has any other technology you might want to think of.
- wyager 10y ago> So how then can anyone expect that we're going to solve the hard problems the brain can, with ANNs? Because RNNs can approximate any self-referential circuit with reasonable efficiency. Just like the brain does with neurons.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoSure. And all multi-layer networks with three or more layers can approximate any function with arbitrary accuracy... given sufficient many inputs. Where "sufficient many" translates as "for real problems, just too many".
- wyager 10y agoNote that I said "with reasonable efficiency", not "with some huge number of inputs". That's because we don't need to represent any function; we need to represent the class of functions that can be efficiently represented in a human brain as well, which is pretty much the same. Note that we can also implement any boolean component with only a few neurons in an NN, and using an RNN gives us working memory as well, so we can implement any sort of digital processor with reasonable efficiency in an RNN (where "reasonable efficiency" means "a linear multiple of the number of components in the original circuit").
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> That's because we don't need to represent any function; we need to represent the class of functions that can be efficiently represented in a human brain as well, which is pretty much the same. The problem is that to learn a function from examples you need the right kind of examples, and for human cognitive faculties it's very hard to get that. For instance, take text- text is a staple in machine-learning models of language... but it is not language. It's a bunch of symbols that are only intelligible in the context of an already existing language faculty. In other words, text means nothing unless you already understand language, which is why although we can learn pretty good models of text, we haven't made much progress in learning models of language. Computers can generate or recognise language pretty damn well- but when it comes to understanding it... Well, we haven't even convincingly defined that task, let alone being able to train anything, RNN or whatever, to perform it. You can see similar issues with speech or image processing, where btw RNNs have performed much better than with language. So, just because RNNs can learn functions in principle it doesn't mean that we can really reproduce human behaviour in practice.
- oldmanjay 10y agoDid you forget that the brain has evolved over billions of years to reach the capability it has?
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI agree it can be reproduced over time. I encourage that they do everything they can to do that. It's worth a Manhattan project just because of all the side benefits it will probably lead to. We now have computation and storage for it, too. One ANN scheme even printed neurons in analog form on an entire wafer then packed the whole thing without cutting it. Because brain-like architectures let you do such things. :) Now for the problem: that's not what most of them are doing. Instead, they're intentionally avoiding how the brain does reasoning and asynchronous/analog implementation to devise weaker techniques built on synchronous, digital implementations in tinier spaces. They try to make up for this weakness by throwing massive amounts of computation at it but it's already clear the algorithms themselves are what has to change. Ideally, we'd start experimenting with every version of the brains own algorithms and structures for specific types of activities in brain structures we're pretty sure perform such activities. We might accidentally discover the right stuff for certain problems. Tie them together over time. That's not what they're doing though. So, they will have to independently invent an entirely new scheme that matches the brain's capabilities with techniques mostly opposite of what it relied on for those capabilities. Looks like a loosing proposition to me. They might achieve it but I'd rather the money clone the brain or it's architectural style.