4 ms·
Copied from my comment on an earlier submission on this: I don't see how the watermarking they talk about is going to succeed in preventing forgeries. If they
by schoen 10y ago
Copied from my comment on an earlier submission on this:
I don't see how the watermarking they talk about is going to succeed in preventing forgeries.
If they're planning to watermark unedited recordings, you have a huge false positive problem because there are billions of hours of legitimate but unwatermarked audio recordings, and will probably continue to be. You can also get false negatives by tampering with a watermark-capable device to get it to watermark something that wasn't recorded from analog. Or you can rerecord edited audio from an analog source and simply claim that your "genuine" recording is slightly noisy.
If they're planning to watermark edited recordings, someone else can implement the same kind of technology but without the watermarking.
- dictum 10y agoI doubt their watermarking can survive the analog hole and multiple reencodes.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoI doubt that much audio quality can survive that, either.
- rasz_pl 10y agoas AnimalMuppet said under me it will survive analog hole quite well, but degrade quality. Look up Cinavia. Its so bad you can actually hear distortions.