5 ms·
“It’s not free trade, it’s stupid trade,” Donald Trump has said during his presidential campaign — a slogan that contradicts every tenet of mainstream econo
by michaelt 10y ago
“It’s not free trade, it’s stupid trade,” Donald Trump
has said during his presidential campaign — a slogan
that contradicts every tenet of mainstream economics, as
well as a quarter of a millennium of accumulated
economic data. [...] if you live in a one-industry town
and the main workplace has closed, you are unlikely to
agree with the professional consensus instead of your
own lived reality of loss and decline.
I'm going to be honest: When it comes to economics, I've read several popular books, and I know what consensus to parrot to sound well informed (Free trade is a net benefit! Ricardian comparative advantage!) but the truth is I don't really /understand/ any of that. Not enough to honestly claim I'm convinced by it.
I'm basically going with what the experts seem to say. If I was living in the Soviet Union I'm sure I'd be parroting the views of a different set of experts and saying completely different things with exactly the same conviction.
- maxerickson 10y agoI worked for a while with someone who grew up in soviet Poland. When the store had pickles and mustard and nothing else, they got the idea that maybe something was up.
- conanbatt 10y agoI like Milton Friedman's explanation or ideas behind supporting free trade. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zk3ruapRQZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zk3ruapRQZk Of course, reality and practicality can change the implementation or feasibility of an idea, but the mere concept of restricted trade being more economically efficient is non-sensical to me. As an example, if restricting trade were positive, would you say that it would be a good policy to restrict trade between states in the US? And then withing cities? I like one of MF's arguments that restricted trade is what you do to your enemies in war, or to yourself in peace. What does happen is that the profits of such movement are globalized, so even though at world-level its more efficient, there could be locals that dont profit from it. Free trade increases economic efficiency, but it represents different people, and it doesnt distribute that wealth in a controlled manner. Bear in mind that world-wide poverty has decreased at an unprecedented pace and theres little doubt that it was globalization that catalyzed that. I also relate this to what Varoufakis speaks about with Greece and Germany: Greece will never have trade surplus because it's not a productive country like Germany, and reducing taxes and salaries don't necesarily fix the problem: but Germany investing in Greece in products and services that serve Germans can compensate the deficit and maintain economic efficiencies. That is, what I think the failed promise of free trade is that the gains of globalization did not benefit a huge part of the population, but if some of that did then the situation would stabilize.
- RyanZAG 10y ago> but the mere concept of restricted trade being more economically efficient is non-sensical to me. If everyone is free trade, and nobody tries to cheat, then free trade is better for everyone. However, when you add in state actors, taxation, arbitrage, high speed trading, and many other real world issues, then non-free trade can be more efficient if it distributes economic output better. This is really simple if you stop and look at the individual pieces: if you have free trade, but your trading partner uses the money they get from taxation to subsidize weak parts of their economy that you would normally have an advantage in, then you're going to lose that advantage when businesses in that area go bankrupt as they can no longer compete. Your trading partner can then move the subsidy to other businesses and repeat the process until they have destroyed all of your local business. Free trade doesn't work if others are cheating and you're doing nothing to stop them. There are many other cases besides subsidies where free trade can be easily abused by actors in your own country as well - such as moving their tax debt to other countries while continuing to operate in your country. Free trade is a two way street that has to be managed to prevent selfish actions. Not to say that free trade isn't still the best option, but you have to make sure both partners in the free trade agreement are working to the benefit of both partners. EDIT: Ah, I'm from South Africa so I forgot it's the USA election and this website is liberal, which means you'll all lose your regular sense and downvote this post because it appears to support Trump or something. Carry on then, I'll be back in a few weeks when you guys have calmed down!
- crdoconnor 10y ago>If everyone is free trade, and nobody tries to cheat, then free trade is better for everyone. ...is precisely the justification the British made for exporting food from Ireland during the potato famine. Well, they didn't exactly claim it was better for everybody but they claimed that it was a good pretext for letting the Irish starve while Ireland exported food.
- snrplfth 10y agoExcept that those exports of high-price-per-calorie food (meats, dairy, wheat) were what paid for large imports of low-price-per-calorie food (rye, corn). If they'd shut down exports, those imports would not have come and the famine would have been worse.
- dave_sullivan 10y agoI think economics is really information theory + history. Information theory is where its most important principles come from: competitive advantage, supply and demand, gains of trade, reversion to mean, diminishing returns, etc. History is the other half of economics: using information theory, psychology, and unreliable data, explain why and how a given scenario unfolded. If you don't have a strong grasp of either of those but read Atlas Shrugged and call yourself an economist, you might be Paul Ryan.
- sprafa 10y agoYou should look at Jonathan Goldsmith's appearance on Charlie Rose. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wwmOkaKh3-s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wwmOkaKh3-s Free Trade is not always good, and he correctly predicts that the global movement of capital will disrupt the current agreement between capital and labor that served the West so well. Donald Trump is wrong on many issues, but this is not one of them as far as I can tell. There a religiosity to the argument that free trade is "always good", even though high performing Asian economies are somewhat protective. Economics at its current understanding is almost like a religion of capitalism. It has little to do with actual economic behaviour and has very little predictive power. That's why we keep having crises. Look into the work of anthropologists and behavioural economists to see the reality of how humans actually behave and what that means for "classical economics". Basically, most of it is bunk, all the way down to Adam Smith. One of the best references I've read on this so far is "Debt the first 5000 years" "How Asia Works" On behavioural economics, there's studies coming out all the time. The evidence is piling up that little of what economists have said makes sense. They've deducted general guidelines that sort of work at the macro scale, but their fundamentals are mostly wrong.
- icebraining 10y agoIsn't the "Asian miracle" barely thirty years old, and already showing problems (e.g. Japanese stagnation)? Sounds a bit early to proclaim them as undeniable examples of the superiority of protectionism.
- sprafa 10y agoHm. The japanese miracle is a bit separate from the rest of the Asian miracle. It was artificially engineered by America to establish a counter to Chinese/USSR/North Korean growing influence in the region, through a sort of Asian Marshall Plan. Essentially America airplaned cash in to stop Communism. I'm increasingly growing into the opinion that capitalism fails to engineer any new "real" growth after physical needs are met for the majority of the population and this is true of any developed economy. Developed economies by nature stagnate. And when you look into post-physical-needs-are-met growth you mostly see financial services that might not be any net-benefit to society. Again I am still studying the topic so not sure. But it's the impression I get. If you look at Japanese society it's clearly hit that stage. Physical needs, basic human needs for food and shelter, have been met. Therefore capitalism has for the most part stopped functioning. Most developed economies reach that stage. The issue is we're not satisfied and we keep asking for more and more "growth", even though capitalism might not be able to deliver it. It might've worked before, but without physical needs capitalism stops functioning effectively, maybe at all. I've written about it here: http://www.rafaelkino.com/essays/capitalismisfailing.html http://www.rafaelkino.com/essays/capitalismisfailing.html