3 ms·
>> I am NOT a bad guy!... I just want to remain in full control of my OWN hardware... >Yeah, they don't want to respect that. Honest question: if you were res
by sangnoir 10y ago
>> I am NOT a bad guy!... I just want to remain in full control of my OWN hardware...
>Yeah, they don't want to respect that.
Honest question: if you were responsible for platform security, how would you tell apart the bad guys from the legitimate owner asserting control over their hardware? My imagination might be failing me, but I can't see a scenario where making it easy for the owner to get root doesn't also make it easier for malicious third parties to subversively add rootkits.
The only workable solution I could think of is to sell factory-rooted models for the advanced users and a locked-down version for everyone else, but I suspect the market is not large enough to support an additional SKU.
edit: fastboot oem unlock is also fairly reasonable compromise, when available, but I don't think many users would know what a unlocked padlock icon when booting means in any case, and would happily use the device
- realusername 10y agoIt could just be like any Linux distribution where you have a root user you can 'su' with?
- schiffern 10y ago>The only workable solution I could think of is to sell factory-rooted models for the advanced users and a locked-down version for everyone else How about Google's hardware "dev switch?" Originally they hid it inside the Kensington lock, but now it's purely a software switch. https://www.chromium.org/chromium-os/developer-information-for-chrome-os-devices/samsung-sandy-bridge#TOC-Entering https://www.chromium.org/chromium-os/developer-information-f... When the switch is on it also displays a scary warning for 30 seconds when the computer boots that "this software cannot be trusted."
- wrkwrkmorewrk 10y agoThe article's "Conclusion" section clearly describes a way; one that Google used in its Chromebooks, the HW switch for "developer mode".