9 ms·
Beware, iPhone Users: Fake Retail Apps Are Surging Before Holidays
- threeseed 10y agoPretty extraordinary that Apple is letting these through. And some are blatantly flouting the rules e.g. putting Nike.com as their support website.
- ungzd 10y agoCommon situation for any closed app store — Google Play has the same fraud apps and most of Chrome App Store extensions are malware.
- ferbivore 10y agoNeither of those has a review process, though. You just pay a few dollars and can upload whatever you want. Apple's stores do, which is why seeing this many fraud apps is surprising.
- CameronBanga 10y agoNot true, every app on Google Play goes through review. I'm not sure about Chrome store, but I presume it may also likely see review for every app.
- weaksauce 10y agoGoogle play does not review each app unless it's done after the fact. You pay a fee and upload your binary and then it's available. My understanding is that they have a permissive model that relies on users flagging the bad stuff and then they pull it from the store after the fact.
- ferbivore 10y agoYou're most likely right. I was under the impression that they just did a basic anti-malware scan on your app, but that seems to have changed back in 2015. Oddly enough, this doesn't seem to be mentioned anywhere in the Google help pages or Android docs. This blog post [1] is the closest thing to an official confirmation I managed to find. [1]: https://android-developers.blogspot.com/2015/03/creating-better-user-experiences-on.html https://android-developers.blogspot.com/2015/03/creating-bet...
- Cagrosso 10y agoFunny, Apple made a fuss earlier this year that they were cracking down on "My First App" type applications, but they let shoddy, fraudulent, poorly translated applications through no problem...
- beedogs 10y agoMoney talks. It's evident at this point that Apple doesn't really care about the end-user experience anymore.
- grzm 10y agoCan you firm this up a bit? If money talks, why would Apple want to keep crappy apps in the App Store? These apps aren't going to make much at all in the short run for Apple, and in the long run will turn off users. Do you think Apple isn't going to do something about these? Or is it more that they haven't been proactive enough? Something else?
- beedogs 10y agoVetting apps costs money. Why bother? The end-user app rating system will sort it out eventually.
- mattnewton 10y agoAlternate explaination: verifying this many apps and all their updates/changes is really hard to keep up with.
- ksk 10y agoHow is it an alternate explanation? If you hire only one janitor it takes longer to clean the premises. Its not really an explanation when you're sitting on piles of cash.
- 10y ago
- gnicholas 10y agoHaving dealt with the iOS approval process several times, it is interesting to see that the system has this weak spot. The approval process is known for its stringency (especially compared to the Play Store), but clearly there are some vulnerabilities lurking.
- flashman 10y agoWell, there is an element of confirmation bias. We don't know whether the successful apps represent one-hundredth or two-thirds of the submitted apps. But earlier this year Apple did say it was trying to decrease approval times,[1] maybe quality control took a hit. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-05-12/apple-shortens-app-review-times-in-push-to-boost-service-sales https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-05-12/apple-sho...
- coldcode 10y agoFor example do a search for 1010!, generally you will find dozens of identical (maybe a slight different icon) apps all with a person's name as the company. I think they are all the same codebase and run by some kind of white label company. I have no idea how anyone makes money off of so many dupes.
- Waterluvian 10y agoWouldn't this be incredibly easy to discover? If number of published apps divided by account age is greater than threshold, raise review red flag when user attempts to publish new app.
- ksk 10y agoWell you could just cheaply purchase tiny companies who wrote like one app in 2010 and never made any money on it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 0x0 10y agoLink only shows "Log in - New York Times" and a login form, flagged.
- thecatspaw 10y agoshows up fine for me. I use ublock origin and privacy badger, which is probably why
- mysterypie 10y agoWhat possible utility do people get by using a "retail app" rather than the web? Wouldn't the store's website and/or normal shopping websites (Amazon, etc.) have everything that the Foot Locker app has? Have people been trained or deluded to "always get the app" when it's not necessary?
- yoz-y 10y agoDepends on the app. For some sellers I prefer apps on mobile because their mobile web experience is shitty or inexistent. An app with good caching is preferable to a web app that spends half of the time re-fetching assets. My biggest problem with web-apps is that you can select parts of the chrome half of the time.
- emmanvazz 10y agoI mean the successful branded apps provide better convienence than a mobile site, makes transactions faster or provide functionality (loyalty program) over the mobile site. Like the you can argue there is no need for a Domino's or Amazon app because you can do almost all the functionality via their mobile site but their apps have millions of downloads. Brands can just leverage every inch of performance and convince via native apps. Also at the end of the day the end users are the ones that decide how beneficial these apps for them and if they keep them installed on their phone.
- chrisseaton 10y agoWhen I'm around my house rather than at my desk and I realise I need to buy something I get my phone out and order it using the Amazon app. For example I could be in the garage, out of engine oil, phone out, scan the barcode on the old one using the camera, oil turns up on my doorstep first thing the next morning, sometimes only ten hours later if I do it in time. Takes literally ten seconds tops. Not so strange is it? See how it saves time and hassle compared to the laptop? Also some people use phones and iPads as their primary or only computer. I would guess especially less wealthy or technically literate people. And the apps are often much more accessible than the websites on those devices.
- 10y ago
- ungzd 10y ago> or even lock the phone until the user pays a ransom How is it possible?
- eric_h 10y agoYeah, I'm disappointed that they dropped that line in there with zero explanation. My understanding is that this should be impossible, as it could likely only be accomplished by calling private APIs. Calling a private API gets an app submission rejected automatically (it's caught by a computer, not a human).
- ksk 10y ago>Calling a private API gets an app submission rejected automatically (it's caught by a computer, not a human). Its rather arbitrary. In a lot of cases it doesn't because the checker is poorly coded. For e.g. if a selector name inside your OWN code clashes with that of a private API (which is not published or even something you should know) it causes the submission to fail. And then people just resubmit and it gets magically approved. People have also reported that it is possible to bypass the checker either using some dynamic runtime trick or figuring out a way to silence private API calls when the app detects its being looked at. (Usual cat and mouse game) http://openradar.appspot.com/28252227 http://openradar.appspot.com/28252227
- eric_h 10y agoThanks, I didn't realize that it was relatively easy to bypass. I did know it primarily relied on string matching, but always thought the solution was to rename your methods when you hit a conflict with Apple's private APIs