8 ms·
I’d wager close to 80.percent of kids taking foreign languages in high school do so because they have to. Funny. I'd wager that percentile is true for high sc
by Groxx 17y ago
I’d wager close to 80.percent of kids taking foreign languages in high school do so because they have to.
Funny. I'd wager that percentile is true for high school as a whole. People rarely do what's good for them (long term) on their own.
Personally, I think we should be exposing kids to languages much earlier, because they're more capable of learning them and it sets up your brain for not-everything's-one-language pathways, making picking up other ones easier in the future.
- billybob 17y ago"it sets up your brain for not-everything's-one-language pathways" Yep. Also, you get a good feel for difficult vs easy sentences. I only speak English and Spanish, but if someone from Russian or Korea or Bangladesh with minimal English skills showed up to a party, I'd have a much easier time choosing phrases he could understand than folks who didn't know a second language would. This is partly seeing what it's like to be a beginner in a language, and partly from negotiating around the things you don't know as you learn. If you don't know how to say "it's in the trunk," you say "it's in the back part of the car where you put things, that you open with a key." And the other person will say, "oh, the trunk!" I suspect that this "ability to rephrase" also helps me explain technical things to non-technical people.
- maw 17y agoIt's true that most people are in school because they have to be, but in what other subject are standards and expectations so low? Most of my Spanish classes had a nudge nudge wink wink aspect to them: the teacher didn't expect us to learn much and we didn't either. But that was definitely not the case in all the other subjects I did. Maybe other school systems were different, but I've never gotten that impression. When schools (and universities) moot the idea of phasing out foreign language instruction, I think that's more than a little sad, but in a world of limited resources to be spread across instruction of many subjects and limited genuine interest, it may well be the best choice pragmatically.