4 ms·
On the road with the 13-inch MacBook Pro
- crazygringo 10y agoI bought the same model last weekend, and am very happy with it. Of course, it replaced my old 13" MacBook Air, not a Pro. I was worried about the keyboard but have grown to love it (I couldn't stand the MacBook one, but this is much better). And the P3 Retina display is gorgeous. The colors and brightness are truly stunning, and the audio is surprisingly clear and "present". Still, I miss MagSafe. It was metallic and elegant and had the perfect little charging light. This plug is white and plastic and cheap-looking and no light... it's a shame. I mean, I get standardizing on USB-C only for peripherals, but I don't get it for power. You've always got to carry the power brick anyways, so the connector doesn't have to be standard -- or do we expect that someday USB-C charging cables will be so ubiquitous you don't need to take it with you?
- exergy 10y ago> but I don't get it for power. Spot on. The move towards USB-C is for the better since it's one port to do it all, but charging via USB-C seems going backwards. I wonder how much of a technical challenge it would have been to let users do it both ways.
- werdna123 10y ago"or do we expect that someday USB-C charging cables will be so ubiquitous you don't need to take it with you?" That one.
- Osmium 10y ago> I mean, I get standardizing on USB-C only for peripherals, but I don't get it for power. * A dedicated power port takes up space; now you can use it for data too. * If a USB-C cable breaks, it's a lot cheaper to replace than an entire power brick. * There are ports on both sides of the laptop, so you can now charge from either side – this reduces cable strain. * And, as you say, it's a standard. As USB-C cords become ubiquitous, you'll be able to charge anywhere (or from a battery pack even). It seems like a good decision all told, though I'll miss MagSafe too.
- pyrophane 10y agoGriffin is already selling a usb-c cable with a MagSafe type feature: https://griffintechnology.com/us/products/cables/usb-c-cables/breaksafe-magnetic-usb-c-power-cable https://griffintechnology.com/us/products/cables/usb-c-cable...
- wineisfine 10y agoThat's great from Griffin, kudos to them for doing this. And shame on Apple for dropping the ball. It's too bad we'll never know what would have happened under Jobs. What annoys me is that for example Lenovo has 30 notebook models... so how much effort would it have been for Apple to release a laptop that accommodates real professional users a little bit, with, say: a 5th laptop option?
- grzm 10y agoI don't think it's a question of effort: it's a decision on the part of Apple to keep a minimal product line.
- derefr 10y agoApple's assumption (which is probably backed up by usage studies) seems to be that "real professional users" use their laptops portably, and use lots of weird ports, but almost never at the same time. So the laptop itself can be lighter to encourage that portability, while the ports can live on a dock at a desk (e.g. the Cinema Display, an older iMac, or that multi-port USB-C dongle that will probably just hang permanently off all the cables it's been joined to.) For those exceptions to the "almost" never—mostly IT people doing field support—they make a litany of adapters. Adapters make sense for this use-case: the target type of user already carries many in a "toolbox", and this is just adding on a few more. And don't forget the Mac Pro. Apple's own internal "real professional users" are, as far as I know, more likely to use a Mac Pro at their desks and then a MacBook for mobile portability—but they won't bother to try to do work with the MacBook that'd be better done on the Mac Pro. Which includes plugging strange peripherals into it.
- oopsies49 10y agoBy using a USB-C connector for power, you add a free port whenever you're not charging.
- colechristensen 10y ago>do we expect that someday USB-C charging cables will be so ubiquitous you don't need to take it with you? Yes. I don't have a new MacBook but I have a USB C phone, and the prospect of not having to have different chargers (and the ability to get another one without paying ~$90) is super attractive. I'm not sure if iPhone will ever move past Lightning, but I can imagine everything else low voltage moving to USB-C.
- baddox 10y agoFor phones I can certainly see it happening. It's already pretty easy to go out and assume that somewhere you'll be able to find either a micro-USB or Lightning cable which covers virtually all smartphones, and you can charge them quickly enough on virtually any USB port or charger. But for laptops, I don't think 50+ watt chargers are going to be ubiquitous, regardless of the charging cable. You're still going to need to carry the actual charger.
- mgiannopoulos 10y agoBut you will easily be able to buy (if in need of a replacement) a non-Apple charger at a much lower price.
- bergie 10y agoAt least the USB-C MacBook (not pro) happily charges from phone chargers, battery packs, etc. Sure, it is slower than the charger that came with the device, but if you only charge overnight, it doesn't matter much
- combatentropy 10y agoThere's talk of USB replacing household electrical outlets, or at least heavily accompanying them. http://gizmodo.com/why-usb-ports-could-be-the-power-outlets-of-the-very-n-1450713482 http://gizmodo.com/why-usb-ports-could-be-the-power-outlets-...
- guelo 10y agoOn the power charging thing, the 15" draws 85W and the 13" 60W, I believe this is at 20V, so we're talking over 4A, the USB-C charging cable they come with is rated for 5A. My point is that most phone chargers will give you less than 1A, that means they would charge one of these laptops very slowly, maybe not even providing enough power to keep the laptop running if the battery is low. You're still going to want to bring the laptop charging brick wherever you go.
- ghostly_s 10y ago>Still, I miss MagSafe. It was metallic and elegant and had the perfect little charging light. This plug is white and plastic and cheap-looking and no light... it's a shame. I think part of this transition is Apple subtly suggesting that people don't need to have their laptops plugged in as a default any longer. The Magsafe is so easy to attach, most people I know have one in their usual work spot and just snap it on every time they sit down there, even if it's just for 10 minutes to check email. The comparative inconvenience of the USB connector means they will likely be a little more intentional about plugging it in...but the incredible battery life of these devices now means you really don't need to. There's no need to snake a power cable to your table at the coffee shop when your laptop gets 10+ hours of battery life. You don't even need to plug it in on your desk at home, or working in your bed, on the couch...if you're just plugging it in on a side table when you close it up for the night now, the whole tripping hazard becomes a pretty moot point. Edit: ah, I see jakobegger has beat me to this comment below ;)
- adl 10y agoSo removing MagSafe is a feature? Laptops have diferent power profiles when they are plugged in than on battery. Again, this: "You don't need to plug in your laptop all the time" works for the regular MacBook, but we are talking about the 'Pro' line here, MagSafe should be standard.
- grzm 10y agoI don't read him as arguing that removing MagSafe is a feature. Just that the tradeoff is more understandable now given battery life than it would have been earlier. It's definitely fair to disagree with the tradeoff. I'm pretty ambivalent about it, myself. I'd like to see something like the Griffin BreakSafe supplied by Apple.
- oneeyedpigeon 10y agoThere's a trivial test to check whether your theory is correct or not: plug a new Macbook Pro, with a closed lid, into an external monitor but don't plug it into power. Current models require power to display on an external monitor with the lid closed; if the new model doesn't, it would all but confirm your theory.
- woah 10y agoI forgot my power brick the other day, and used co-worker's USB-C phone charger. Someday has arrived.
- Arnt 10y agoI've stopped carrying a charger since I got a >10hour laptop, Not planned, it just happened. There are USB chargers everywhere already provided you have an A-C cable, they just aren't fast.
- hanief 10y agoYes. I bought the same model to replace my mid-2011 Macbook Air. Coming from an ancient one, this Macbook Pro is a reveleation. Your experience echo mine. I love the new keyboard very much, no problem typing on it. It even has a pleasing sound when i am typing on them. It invokes ASMR. It doesn't feel too heavy, I can bring it around on one hand just fine. The build quality is amazing. Performance is good. From fully charged I can use it all day without charging. I am very much satisfied.
- rayiner 10y agoBeing able to use USB-C battery packs is a huge benefit.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Esau 10y agoI have to agree with your comment in regard to MagSafe. I have a 2013 Macbook Air and I still find the power connector to be one of my favorite things about it.
- wineisfine 10y agoThere is very little information in this post. The only question I had after reading this was: how does one become become a blogger that gets a Macbook Pro from Apple to review?
- pyrophane 10y agoJason Snell was previously an editor at MacWorld, and has been writing about Apple for a long time.
- webwielder2 10y agoOne path is to be a former editor-in-chief of Macworld magazine.
- geoffpado 10y agoThe blogger in question, Jason Snell, used to be editorial director of Macworld, an extremely popular Mac magazine going back long before Apple's current successful period: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jason_Snell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jason_Snell
- jakobegger 10y agoJason Snell is the former Editor of Macworld; Six Colors is the project he started after the print version shut down.
- nathancahill 10y agoJason Snell used to be the editor of MacWorld.
- cherry_su 10y agoFor what it's worth, the 13-inch MacBook Pro with 2 Thunderbolt 3 ports (this one) gets a hair over 16 hours of battery life in Ars' Wifi Browsing Test. Unfortunately, this benchmark did not contain a measurement for the 13" MacBook Air, its spiritual predecessor. The old 13" Pro got 14 hours. http://arstechnica.com/apple/2016/11/review-cheapest-2016-macbook-pro-is-good-but-its-missing-all-the-cool-stuff/4/ http://arstechnica.com/apple/2016/11/review-cheapest-2016-ma...
- pyrophane 10y ago> I find the lack of response in the keys unpleasant, but I can still type at full speed and accuracy when I use it. I'm not worried about losing speed, I'm worried about developing hand and wrist pain over time, which seems, at least for me, to be an issue with using low travel keyboards. Maybe I just need to learn to type with a lighter touch.
- grzm 10y agoI've been fortunate enough not to have any type of chronic RSI pain associated with typing. Am I reading you correctly that your pain is due to striking the keys and slamming into the keyboard when the key bottoms out?
- kctess5 10y agoThat has been my experience. I have noticed that my mechanical keyboard is much gentler and less likely to induce RSI relate pain because I almost never have hard impacts due to bottoming the keys out. On my MacBook (2013 15" rMBP) it's a different story.
- rayiner 10y ago> Maybe I just need to learn to type with a lighter touch. This. Typing fast doesn't require you to beat the keys into submission.
- godzillabrennus 10y agoIt seems appropriate given the reviews to start calling these new machines the MacBook Pro Air as it seems that it's Apples goal to increase prices and reduce functionality to fit into a smaller frame.
- lexicality 10y agoMacbook Prair?
- roryisok 10y ago> trains zipping through the Irish countryside. Calling bullshit on his performance claims. None of our trains ever "zip" here.
- Keyframe 10y agoIf they had somehow packed what was in 15" model into a 13" model, then it would be a great machine. This, it's not appealing to me the way it is.
- Ultra_64 10y agoThose are the most elongated escape keys I've ever seen!
- akamaka 10y agoThis is a questionable review, bordering on dishonest. It makes no mention that the new machines provide almost no performance improvement over last year's models, despite the significant price hike: http://www.digitaltrends.com/apple/apples-newest-macbook-pro-slightly-faster-previous-models/ http://www.digitaltrends.com/apple/apples-newest-macbook-pro... Edit: If the folks downvoting me would like to dispute the benchmarks, please feel free to contribute some new data to the conversation.
- kayoone 10y agoSSD and GPU are quite a bit faster, the CPU isn't, but it got more power efficient and is more of an Intel problem at the moment as they are focusing on that.
- akamaka 10y agoThere are already PC laptops shipping with a newer generation chip 15W chip than the one in the low end Macbook Pro, so I consider this more of an Apple problem.
- grzm 10y agoI get the impression from the review that the reviewer is reporting his experience with using the MacBook under real-world conditions. He's not performing benchmarks. Whether or not there's a performance improvement wouldn't really need to be included in that, would it? Indeed, he specifically mentions that he didn't have the opportunity to perform speed tests: "Being on the road, I haven’t been able to do methodical speed or battery tests, but I can say that the battery life on this laptop seems to be a lot more than on the MacBook Air. It also handled some more intense work—editing multi-track audio in Logic Pro and removing noise from audio with iZotope RX 5—with aplomb. Some of that may be the result of the faster SSD in this model, but some of it is at least the responsibility of the processor." Do you get the impression that he's trying to hide something? Do you have other criticisms besides this point?
- akamaka 10y ago
- kayoone 10y agoHe is listing the size of the new MBP vs the 13" Macbook Air as a pro, but in fact even the previous MBP had a slightly smaller footprint than the 13" Air, this is even smaller though. The Air is in fact a pretty large 13" laptop in terms of footprint.