2 ms·
If a program isn't evil, then it does only things that shouldn't require permission. Example: include the OS version and RAM amount in the http request to the u
by alkonaut 10y ago
If a program isn't evil, then it does only things that shouldn't require permission. Example: include the OS version and RAM amount in the http request to the upgrade server that is done on every startup.
Any info ever collected by no-permissions-asked telemetry must be such that it doesn't matter who has the information or what they do with it.
If it isn't information of that kind then of course a program should ask permission. But that in my view isn't "telemetry" then. If it collects anything even remotely user-identifying or personal then it's in my definition not telemetry and should never be done without permission (if at all).
If a program really is malicious, then it doesn't matter if it asks for permission because why would that wouldn't respect the users wish anyway?
My argument wasn't pro/against telemetry, it was that asking permission doesn't change anything. Permission isn't what tells malicious programs from others. A benign program doesn't do things that needs permission to begin with.
- nitrogen 10y agoOne problem is that several seemingly innocuous pieces of data can be combined to create a unique ID. See the Panopticlick for an example.
- alkonaut 10y agoYeah, if someone e.g. gets my complete hw fingerprint, I'm identifiable. But it's no worse than I'm already uniquely id'd by visiting pretty much any website today. I don't like it, but I also don't see a point in being outraged when my music player does it but not when my favorite website does it.
- EasyTiger_ 10y agoYou seem very willing to just dish your data over to everyone - can I install some software on your computer, too?
- alkonaut 10y agoWell if you make a piece of useful software I'll install it (I'd rather install it myself). I'm not very generous with my data at all - but I'd rather trust my firewall to protect my data, than a dialog that asks me if I'm OK with sharing it. That was my point.