5 ms·
Trust open technologies you understand, not politicians. How many people really understand these technologies? For anyone who lacks either the time or the know
by chongli 10y ago
Trust open technologies you understand, not politicians.
How many people really understand these technologies? For anyone who lacks either the time or the know-how to audit the source code: what do you suggest? If it's not "find the time and educate yourself" then does your statement not revert to:
"Trust these technology experts instead of these politicians."?
To which I'd respond: Why? Why is a technology expert more trustworthy than a politician?
- MrLeap 10y agoWell, a technology expert is - in aggregate - more trustworthy than a politician because their incentives align with yours. This isn't to say that every technology expert can be trusted. The hope is that many eyes looking at the problem helps move the needle. Politics might as well be the science of deception. My pithy opinion is that nearly everyone is more trustworthy than a politician.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoWell, a technology expert is - in aggregate - more trustworthy than a politician because their incentives align with yours. This is ... myopic. Do you think ransomeware is written by politicians? All malicious software is written by technology experts. Is not that I trust politicians, far from it: we know they're all lying crooked thieves. But you think "technology experts are more trustworthy."
- MrLeap 10y agoIf you think ransomware affects the aggregate that much, i'd call that hyperopic.
- fulafel 10y agoTechnology experts will be more often working against your interests than politicians, because politicians will usually have some public interest motive and voter accountability, technology experts often work for "ad tech" and spooks.
- AlexandrB 10y agoI'm not sure why this was downvoted, but it's right on. Government didn't give us Facebook's or Google's pervasive data collection Facebook/Google's "technology experts" did.
- closeparen 10y agoA technology expert is - in aggregate - working for a company that derives its revenue from user data in some way.
- hbt 10y agoHere are your choices: * educate yourself and grow your self reliance to understand & use these technologies and look for your interests * delegate the work to experts, trust authorities and hope they have your best interest * isolate yourself from technology and pay the economic/social price. Your Freedom takes work. You can't delegate it. There will always be a conflict between individual freedom and social safety.
- eikenberry 10y ago> To which I'd respond: Why? Why is a technology expert more trustworthy than a politician? Is that a rhetorical question?
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoWhat is this supposed to mean? The term "technology expert" also encompasses all the Black Hats Hackers and criminals - both opportunistic criminals and organised crime. The people who write ransomware are technology experts.
- cloudjacker 10y ago> The people who write ransomware are technology experts. protip: the white hat and black hat programmers are the same people.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoI'm not sure what you mean why this. I'm just a dumb metal-fabricator and machine operator, so you'll have to excuse me if I don't understand the nuances of programming lingo.
- cloudjacker 10y agoOkay, the "criminal hackers writing harmful software" are the same people making a living writing benign software.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoYou haven't really written anything different here. I was hoping you'd elaborate further on what you mean by this, rather than restating the same thing in only-slightly-different words. I'll have a stab at it. Are you implying that the people who wrote the software for the internet banking website and phone app I use are the same ones who wrote CryptoLocker? Surely there's some sort of gradient though, right? Like is Facebook malicious software (I tend to think so and I don't use it) or is it benign?
- CamperBob2 10y agoTo which I'd respond: Why? Why is a technology expert more trustworthy than a politician? Because you can challenge them to defend their position, and evaluate their answers objectively. Try that at a political rally, or even at an organized debate.