3 ms·
Launch aborts are not an options for any tumbling vehicle. A launch abort from a spinning/tumbling rocket would see the capsule fired strait into the ground.
by sandworm101 10y ago
Launch aborts are not an options for any tumbling vehicle. A launch abort from a spinning/tumbling rocket would see the capsule fired strait into the ground. Any out of control vehicle is pretty much a lost cause.
Shuttle's abort modes, including the bailouts, were premised on the craft being under control. Given the forces involves, if it wasn't under control it probably was about to disintegrate. But the same is true of spaceX-style capsule launches. Whether parachutes would correct a tumbling capsule, or rip it in half, is an open question. They both need to initiate abort procedures at least a millisecond before the craft departs into uncontrolled flight.
(And aborts can be triggered automatically, or by someone on the ground.)
- XorNot 10y agoLaunch abort though can be fired well in advance of a rocket tumbling though. There's a pretty narrow recoverable angle throughout the launch, the rocket is lost well before the crew can't be saved.
- ceejayoz 10y agoSpinning's entirely possible to survive. The Saturn missions tested it (and it was a really good test - something went wrong and the rocket actually went out of control) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AqeJzItldSQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AqeJzItldSQ A tumble should be fairly trivial to detect and fire only when the capsule's in its upwards pointing portion of the tumble. Plus, you'd only be firing into the ground if you're pretty early in the launch - the Dragon launch abort only sent it up a kilometer or so. Finally, the launch abort is pretty sensitive - deviating not far off the right direction should trigger it, before a full-on tumble.