4 ms·
A million downloads, commercial deployments by 3rd parties, and basically no contributions coming in. The status quo of the open-source model. They should start
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
A million downloads, commercial deployments by 3rd parties, and basically no contributions coming in. The status quo of the open-source model. They should start selling it to companies to finance their own work on it. Or encourage others interested in static analysis to do the same.
- pjmlp 10y agoThis is what kind of changed my view on FOSS as a way to make a living. In all the companies I have worked through my career thus far, not a single one has contributed back in any form to the pile of FOSS libraries that they were using.
- jknoepfler 10y agoAs with insistence on code quality, useful and careful testing, infrastructure automation, and good design and review practices, I think the culture of giving back has to come from developers who care about their professional ethos. My team at EvilCorp contributes fixes to several open-source libraries. The reason this happens, though, is that two of our stronger devs said "the correct thing to do is to take the time to get these fixes into mainline," which they did. The answer to the question of "why" we do it isn't "because it increases our team velocity," but because we're software engineers, and that's what good software engineers do whenever possible.
- pjmlp 10y ago> I think the culture of giving back has to come from developers who care about their professional ethos. On my case that would be the path to be fired. In none of the companies I worked for, doing that would work without going though legal and all the necessary layers to green light it.
- pm215 10y agoYou definitely can't skip the step of getting managerial and legal signoff (and no sensible open source project wants a patch that the developer doesn't have the right and authorisation from the employer to contribute). But in better companies it is possible to make that case and get the agreement.
- pmontra 10y agoDid they make any changes to those libraries? I'm also using tons of open source from github but I almost never make any changes. I do report bugs and sometimes I add workarounds to the bug report, mostly for code I'm comfortable to inspect and modify. That's almost only Ruby, JS, Python, nothing that needs more than an editor and a browser reload: I have no time for that and I'll just look for another library.
- pjmlp 10y agoYes, some of them kept vendoring specific versions with private patches.
- wtbob 10y agoMany don't, but some do. Mine, for example, does. It's actually really cool to be able to contribute back.
- onli 10y agoThe status quo if you are a defunct project without any means to properly accept contributions or even just mention a new release on the homepage maybe. There are many example where open source as a model works, but you can't expect that it will magically solve all problems. Especially if you as a project are not even able to get the basics right. How is that supposed to foster contributions to the project?
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"The status quo if you are a defunct project " Most successful projects in FOSS with many downloads get virtually no contributions or financial support back. Even the largest ones have an enormous user to contributor ratio with almost all benefits going to the users. Therefore, it's the status quo for open-source in general. Those getting tons of contributions and development without a company behind them are extremely rare. I had a great article on this before my crashed HD deleted newer bookmarks. It was a woman that surveyed many popular projects to ask about their status. Most complained they were barely getting by, the developer(s) stretched thin, tons of requests without accompanying payment/support, and mostly no contributors. I'd like a link to that article if any readers know which one I'm talking about.
- whitef0x 10y agoThe article I think you are talking about is this one https://medium.com/@nayafia/how-i-stumbled-upon-the-internet-s-biggest-blind-spot-b9aa23618c58 https://medium.com/@nayafia/how-i-stumbled-upon-the-internet... by Nadia Eghbal. She never ended up finding a solution to the problem and instead ended up joining GitHub as a opensource developer advocate (or something similar to that).
- nickpsecurity 10y agoYeah that's it. Thanks. Unusually thorough survey in terms of categories and paying attention to stuff other than Red Hat and Linux. ;)
- junkster78 10y agoActually there have been PRs. At the moment there are 15 PRs sitting on FindBugs' Github page: https://github.com/findbugsproject/findbugs/pulls https://github.com/findbugsproject/findbugs/pulls 5 of them are over a year old. Most of them had no review by the development team, and many of those that did, got stuck on Bill, for instance, trying to get Travis enabled: https://github.com/findbugsproject/findbugs/pull/48#issuecomment-141879719 https://github.com/findbugsproject/findbugs/pull/48#issuecom... There is no incentive to contribute to a project in such poor shape. SonarQube abandoned FindBugs mainly because it was low on activity: "FindBugs project activity: The activity on the project is quite low and thus the value coming out of it does not come fast enough to satisfy our users." http://www.sonarqube.org/sonarqube-java-analyzer-the-only-rule-engine-you-need/ http://www.sonarqube.org/sonarqube-java-analyzer-the-only-ru...
- nickpsecurity 10y agoDoes the license not allow forking it with group of people more interested in accepting contributions? It has a bunch of users. If my theory is wrong, it should've forked with a lot of updates by now.
- junkster78 10y agoYes, it's allowed ('though the name is trademarked). However, forking is usually harmful (effort spread thin, divergent APIs, plugins, integration with other tools such as Maven, Gradle, ...). On that very email chain, once the sitution was stated and as Bill kept on ignoring everyone as he did over the last year and a half, the community hard forked FindBugs and started aligning behind https://github.com/spotbugs/spotbugs https://github.com/spotbugs/spotbugs Bill's reappearance is now puzzling. To abandon the fork to go back to FindBugs would require major leadership changes, as confidence on Bill has been shattered. Keeping the fork leaves the project on the same point people tried to avoid in the first place.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIn this case, sounds like the source lost interest, a fork didnt have enough to accomplish anything, and now a good project is toast. Despite it being OSS with significant adoption. Sounds like quite a few precautionary tales in this one.