5 ms·
Magic is probably my fav board game, too bad that you have to put in so much time and money to have fun and the value of cards deprecates so quickly. I tried He
by adamnemecek 10y ago
Magic is probably my fav board game, too bad that you have to put in so much time and money to have fun and the value of cards deprecates so quickly. I tried Hearthstone to scratch that itch but that game is just gutted MtG.
- dbg31415 10y agoWhat's a reasonable price to spend? You would probably spend you $15 to go see a two hour movie... I bet you can get away with spending under $7.50 per hour on M:tG. But it is a very expensive game if you buy all the cards and only play it once. I still have cards from the 90s, I don't think I've bought anything in 20 years. Still fun game to play on board game night with friends.
- adamnemecek 10y agoThe thing is that $15 is peanuts in the MtG world unless you are playing draft.
- nickik 10y agoEasy. You can spend 50-100$ on a more or less competitive Modern or Standard Deck and have fun with it for years.
- mrob 10y agoYou can see actual competitive decks here: https://www.mtggoldfish.com/metagame/standard#paper https://www.mtggoldfish.com/metagame/standard#paper https://www.mtggoldfish.com/metagame/modern#paper https://www.mtggoldfish.com/metagame/modern#paper You occasionally get Standard decks in your price range making top 8, but almost never in Modern. It's really stretching it to call the budget Modern decks "competitive".
- empthought 10y agoThe bar being set was to "have fun with it," not "to finish top 8 in sanctioned tournaments..."
- Kexoth 10y agoMtG is my favorite game too, but honestly to be competitive with your decks, on a yearly basis you need to spend a lot more money than watching all the blockbusters for that year twice :)
- dsil 10y agofyi, your cards from the 90s might be worth thousands of dollars.
- gnicholas 10y agoI have a bunch of cards from the 90s but haven't played in decades. What's a good way to figure out which ones are valuable? I had a few beta cards, but mostly the series after that (name escapes me). Also, where's a good place to sell? Online or in-person?
- bikamonki 10y agoYou'll make more money if you take the time to sell them one by one (or 4x sets if you have them). Selling your collection in bulk will make you lose 30-40% but it's less time consuming. Ebay is the place since trading sites will pay you wholesale prices (they have to make a profit retailing your cards).
- dbg31415 10y agoSo I shouldn't shuffle them? Ha, I don't play with the Alpha stuff as much anymore, most of the cards I play with ate Unlimited and the expansions around that time. I have a Shivan Dragon signed by Richard Garfield that he told me not to take out of my deck so I still play with that. He told me the value of these cards were in how much I enjoy them... I do have a deck made entirely out of black border Nether Shadows that someone gave me as a joke during a tour of the WotC office years and years ago... most of them are Alphas.
- zeroer 10y ago> You would probably spend you $15 to go see a two hour movie I wouldn't. > spending under $7.50 per hour That's absurdly expensive.
- brianwawok 10y agoIs it? Flying a plane is $500 an hour. Golfing a good course is $100 an hour. Waterskiing can be $50 an hour. Skiing is $20?? An hour. Recreation is serious stuff in the US.
- zeroer 10y agoFlying a plane isn't $500/hr unless you're flying first class, and it's not exactly what I would call entertainment or recreation. I wouldn't do the rest of it, anyways.
- Symbiote 10y agoThe average price of a movie ticket is $8. The average price of the popcorn is also $8. (Lots of citations with a Google search.)
- zeroer 10y agoYea, I would not see a movie in theaters, and I haven't for years.
- klodolph 10y agoSealed league. Get a group of people, everyone buys 10 packs for $26, you get to open six of them and you play. Every two weeks you open another pack. Ends up taking 10 weeks and nobody spends more than $26, maybe a little more if you buy card sleeves, iPhone apps to track life, or whatever. What makes it fun is that you're playing against people with the same size card pool as you. Draft is cheaper ($7.80) but it's over and done in a few hours.
- kernel_sanders 10y agoThis is how I got in to MtG, and can confirm that its super fun. If you're lucky enough to find a group of friends that will participate, don't let the opportunity pass you by.
- _raoulcousins 10y agoThanks for making me think about this. Every time I play my favorite deck I spend $5-10 for entry for a local tournament, which lasts about 4 hours. Adding in the cost of the deck, I'd need to play it for over 200 hours before it becomes cheaper than $7.50 an hour.
- rkowalick 10y agoI pretty much refuse to play any format other than booster draft. Flat price, loads of fun, and easy to get into for a brief period of time since you only need to know about the set you are drafting.
- sturmeh 10y agoPauper is cheaper on average, and highly competitive and fun.
- rkowalick 10y agoI just find it hard to think about playing with every set of magic cards. With booster draft, there are only a few hundred cards that you even have to worry about. Another unlisted benefit of draft vs. pauper is that almost any store selling Magic cards will have a weekly draft.
- marcoperaza 10y agoWhy not just print out the cards?
- adamnemecek 10y agoYou can't play tournaments.
- prophesi 10y agoYou could get started with the Pauper format, where you can only use commons. That's actually the only format I play in tournaments. With friends, it's Commander + Modern, since none of us have crazy expensive decks.
- adamnemecek 10y agoThe thing though is that you aren't going to have all that much fun when your deck is full of cards like 3/3 for 3 mana.
- nickik 10y agoI bought a green aggro stompy deck for 30$ in modern. I want win any world championchips but its pretty far away from 3/3 for 3 mana creature. Its fun crushing decks that have cards that are worth 4x my hole deck. You can have fun with magic without spending that much money.
- prophesi 10y agoFor one, if it's a level playing field, then you will have fun with cards like that. Two, over the course of two decades, there are a /lot/ of good cheap common cards so you're doing it wrong if you have a 3-cost 3/3 in there.
- sturmeh 10y agoPauper is one of the most ridiculously overpowered formats, alongside Legacy. (Mainly thanks to synergy and a lack of toolbox answers to everything.) Don't be fooled.
- thiagoharry 10y agoYou can print any card and paste on top of cheap cards, just to play with friends. Its nice to do this with the duel decks for casual fun. If you do this just to play with friends, DMCA never would discover. But of course you can't play tournaments doing this.
- sturmeh 10y agoThe cost and effort of printing duel decks is never going to be less than just buying the product.
- gargarplex 10y agoStartup opportunity? Let people create their own card game, print their decks and have them mailed.
- lelandbatey 10y agoEh, that's only true if you are cash rich and time poor. A booster box with 36 booster packs costs ~$100. At 15 cards per pack, that's 540 cards per box. The latest set has 249 cards, so a box will probably get you close to 2 of each card. But to be guaranteed to have all the cards you want, you may need to buy a second booster box and do some trading/purchasing of individual cards. Total cost is at minimum ~5¢ per card. But I can also just print 6 cards per page from my black and white laser printer at a cost of up to 8¢ per page, or about 1.3¢ per resulting card (plus cutting them out with scissors). And, this doesn't require an upfront payment of $150+. So no, I would not say the cost of just buying the product is lower.
- klodolph 10y agoIt's even worse if you consider rarity. A pack has one slot for rare cards, three slots for uncommon, etc. 1/8 of the time the rare card will be a "mythic rare". The latest set has 53 rares and 15 mythic rares, so the chance of having even one copy of a particular rare card in your box is 1-(1-1/53×7/8)^36 or 45%. For mythic rares the probability is only 1-(1-1/15×1/8)^36 or 26% that you'll even have one copy. Then consider the number of times you'll want a "playset" of a card, which means four copies. The only sane options I can see are: * Play limited formats * Play casual with proxies * Buy individual cards
- nickpsecurity 10y ago" too bad that you have to put in so much time and money to have fun and the value of cards deprecates so quickly." That's exactly why I stopped playing it. It seemed almost rigged against poor people when I was in school. The guys with more money always had better stuff where we had to use cheap tactics to win. :) My recommendation was doing it on computer with people choosing whatever cards they wanted. Eliminates that problem. Not as fun as holding the cards or being in person, though. Smartphones today give us another option where we could play it in person using our smartphones with two views: our cards and the board. Maybe even an extension where someone's tablet or monitor subscribes to the board people are playing on to have a constant, large display. What you think?
- lsiq 10y agoTo some of you who are a bit disenchanted with MtG's cost (and the 90s style online client), as well as Hearthstone's simplicity - I might recommend Hex:Shards of Fate. It's more or less what MtG would be if WoTC were on top of their game. It's far cheaper and you can play in your underwear.