4 ms·
This seems like one of those marginal results that the experimenter planned to find before starting the experiment that won't replicate. Also, cutting a rope in
by pessimizer 10y ago
This seems like one of those marginal results that the experimenter planned to find before starting the experiment that won't replicate. Also, cutting a rope in half probably won't work, and one man's creative drawings and innovative gifts are another man's silly drawings and stupid gifts.
Did we discover that people are more likely to try to sell solutions that probably won't work if they know that they won't be responsible for actually carrying them out?
- Retra 10y agoI had the same conclusion reading about the alien story part. If I have to write a story about an alien, I'm going to be thinking about what it's motivations and experiences are -- distinctly human things -- but if I have to describe an alien for someone else to write about, I'll have no trouble spewing out a stream of self-contradictory, unrelatable junk. So I'm left wondering why anyone would think the second is more "creative" than the first, given that the first was designed to solve problems and the second to create them. I wouldn't think that's the kind of creativity you'd want to measure and optimize for.
- alexpetralia 10y agoThis is exactly how I felt when reading this! A reasonable hypothesis followed by some weak and vague experiments (how do you measure the creativity of drawings?). I'm sure many would accept the hypothesis alone (given some reasonable-sounding justification) without ever looking to see if the experiments truly validate the hypothesis. What bias is this called again? It's not Texas Sharpshooter is it? Maybe just poor science? Again, this is not to say the effect does not exist (I personally believe it does) - just that the conclusion does not follow from the evidence.
- syllogism 10y agoHad exactly the same reaction! Nobody should be buying an argument on this sort of basis anymore. The business of selling us some truthy conclusion and thin social psych evidence in favour should be dead.