7 ms·
Any time I have to ride the Caltrain I play a game of "spot places you could fit an apartment block". It's stunning how many Caltrain stations are surrounded by
by simonw 10y ago
Any time I have to ride the Caltrain I play a game of "spot places you could fit an apartment block". It's stunning how many Caltrain stations are surrounded by empty land, parking lots or single story buildings. Public transport hubs should have housing near them!
- CodeWriter23 10y agoIn Los Angeles many transit stops are well developed with residential and retail nearby. The result has been the property values near the stations is so high that people who use public transit as their primary mode of transit can't afford to live there, and the bulk of people who do live there typically drive and use transit occasionally.
- dba7dba 10y agoIt's not just the property value of the neighborhood that's absurdly high. The rent/cost of the units in the newly built dense housing buildings is absurdly high too. I mean living in LA, who would want to pay ton of money for a box of living space with no yard, and yet share subway with the less desirables (not my view of course). And the public transportation systems in LA doesn't really have the reach either.
- melling 10y agoSimple solution to both problems: build a lot more mass transit.
- Tempest1981 10y agoHow much will that cost? Measure B will help a bit, but brings our sales tax to 9%. Property tax is limited by prop 13. Should developers kick in more? Is 10-12% sales tax ok?
- melling 10y agoIt's going to cost a lot more than 50 years ago when it should have done. Stupidity has a price. Of course, the problem could just be ignored for another 50. Maybe people will simply leave LA.
- scharfstevenm 10y agoMeasure B is mainly roads, with little for transit. Does anyone trust VTA to manage mass transit development? Funds for transit should come from fuel taxes, vehicle license fees, and development fees. Sales tax increases are very regressive and a terrible way to pay for transit. But that's always what the Silicon Valley Non-Leadership Group favors because it avoids their members having to ante up for the transportation problems they create. Glad the NYT article author at least quoted me correctly. He was going to characterize me as "anti-growth," which is completely false. Growth is just fine as long as it's sustainable growth with transportation, housing, and school impact taken into consideration. But developers don't want to take a systems view and look at the long-term impact of their projects.
- Spooky23 10y agoGood luck raising the billions in taxes required.
- CodeWriter23 10y agoLA Transit has a "last 5 miles" problem. Many people live 5 or more miles from the stop. The local bus can add 30-40 minutes for what should be a 10 minute car ride. The park and ride lots are always full before 6:30AM, and account for 200 riders at the smaller lots and maybe 1000 at the larger ones. Parking is expensive to build too. Add to that, poor choices to build at grade reduce the effectiveness of light rail. In Pasadena the Gold Line crossing was put at grade across a major artery; should have continued underground for just another mile. This creates a daily traffic jam that lasts for about 2-3 hours. And then through Highland Park, the rail is at grade through a residential street, making it go 5 MPH and it has to obey traffic signals at the same priority as cars. The end result is a 35 minute commute time Downtown for a trip that takes 20 minutes in no traffic, 35 in typical rush hour traffic and maybe 45-50 worst case. People choose to drive instead just to save time...including my best friend who lives two blocks from a Gold Line stop.
- scharfstevenm 10y agoWow, why didn't anyone think of that before?! Seriously, look at some transit maps: 1920 Silicon Valley: http://www.sociecity.com//wp-content/uploads/silicon-valey-streetcar-rail-lines-1920.jpg http://www.sociecity.com//wp-content/uploads/silicon-valey-s... 2012 Silicon Valley: http://www.sociecity.com//wp-content/uploads/silicon-valey-streetcar-rail-lines-2012.jpg http://www.sociecity.com//wp-content/uploads/silicon-valey-s... And these were for-profit, privately run lines in most cases. A good article at http://sociecity.com/rethink/death-and-life-of-american-streetcar http://sociecity.com/rethink/death-and-life-of-american-stre....
- closeparen 10y agoYes, but it should take some pressure off less dense housing. Unless it replaces parking, in which case less dense housing gets WAY cheaper but also much less useful.
- scharfstevenm 10y agoIs anyone naive enough to believe that newly build dense housing is going to bring down the cost of housing? It doesn't work that way. One of the biggest contributors to high housing cost in San Francisco is rent control. It benefits some tenants, but it results in more and more rental housing being turned into TIC buildings under the Ellis Act. My wife's family had a four unit apartment building in SF and they had to sell it because with rent control, and de-facto vacancy control, it was a money-losing proposition since there was no way they could maintain the building and pay the mortgage with the rents they were getting. My wife may have married me for the free handyman services I provided to them. I'm sure that the new owner did a TIC conversion. In a way it's good that more people become owners rather than renters, but it does not increase the supply of housing or lower the cost. There are also a lot of houses in San Francisco with empty in-law units because the homeowners are scared to rent them out because of all the laws on rental housing, even in the cases where the in-law unit is not covered by rent control. So we're in the odd situation of having a housing shortage with tens of thousands of unoccupied housing units.
- kspaans 10y agoHow long had the tenants been in those apartments? I'm just curious how costs rose faster than rents, since property taxes are pretty low. Was the high cost of labour for maintenance a big part of it?
- scharfstevenm 10y agoMaintenance and repairs were a lot when they had to pay someone to do everything. Then when I entered the family, suddenly I could repair appliances, replace plumbing fixtures, replace outlets and switches, install lighting, it never ends. Many trips to San Francisco from Silicon Valley for repairs. I think if they could have raised the rents when tenants changed, and have been allowed 3-4% annual increases, instead of 2% or less, then it would have been sustainable. But tenants passed on the apartments to friends and relatives, and the rent was delivered in cash to our house. A lot of apartment building owners in San Francisco aren't wealthy, and own just one small building. The lesson that was learned is that it's a really bad idea to own rental property in a city with such confiscatory rent control. And this rent control only on older properties ends up driving up prices on non-rent controlled properties because it constricts the market-rate supply.
- capkutay 10y agoI know what you mean. That Bayshore stop is baffling: http://ww4.hdnux.com/photos/47/72/11/10461791/3/920x920.jpg http://ww4.hdnux.com/photos/47/72/11/10461791/3/920x920.jpg Sure, it's near a waste processing plant. But the fact that the area around it is just a square mile of shrubs and dirt is ridiculous. They could probably fit 2000 homes there right by the train station, 15 minutes from San Francisco, 10 minutes from the airport, 10 minutes from Milbrae BART. Other vastly under-built areas like Belmont also raise questions. However, Hillsdale and Redwood City have done a good job building dense housing right around their respective stations.
- inferiorhuman 10y agoThe Bayshore station isn't really baffling. It's an ex-Southern Pacific railyard and requires significan cleanup. The city of Brisbane (where the station is) wants to build an industrial park, pretty much everyone else wants that development to include housing. It's been in the news quite a bit.
- paulsutter 10y agoIt is truly baffling that there is any debate or delay. The obvious answer is to build high density housing and offices there. Low density suburban anything would be a tragedy.
- Spooky23 10y agoNot really. Rail yards are usually a real shitshow in terms of toxic contamination and nasty stuff. One site near my home just had a casino built on it, which will require active ventilation of wells sunk in the ground for years to prevent toxic gas buildup.
- Zach_the_Lizard 10y agoQuite a few neighborhoods are built on or being built on them. The two that come to mind in recent years are the new Hudson Yards neighborhood in NYC (being built on the West Side Yard) and Potomac Yards (built where those rail yards were) in Alexandria, VA right outside DC. A number of Manhattan neighborhoods are built on former rail yards. On mobile but I believe there is even a wikipedia page on it. If the demand is high enough developers would love to clean it up. SF prices are at that level.
- fezz 10y agoThats how LA grew outward. http://la.curbed.com/2014/9/26/10042216/los-angeles-is-still-governed-by-longgone-streetcar-routes http://la.curbed.com/2014/9/26/10042216/los-angeles-is-still... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetcar_suburb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetcar_suburb
- toast0 10y agoIf the caltrain station nearest my house wasn't surrounded by a parking lot, it would be impractical for me to use caltrain.
- jseliger 10y agoUber / Lyft / cycling, people.
- Zach_the_Lizard 10y agoConversely, it would be easier for potentially hundreds or thousands of others, plus it would likely increase ridership and result in a more sustainable future for Caltrain. And it would also be better for the environment and economy.
- closeparen 10y ago>hundreds or thousands of others Apartments are quite a bit bigger than parking spaces. Fewer people can live in a given amount of space than can park in it, unless we're talking dorm-room sized apartments.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoWhen I lived in SV my experience with Caltrain was "packed to bursting all the time".
- tsycho 10y agoHave you tried living near a Caltrain station? I have, and IMHO the noise from the trains (they blow their horns when entering the station) is very annoying, and harder to ignore/get used to since it's discrete, unlike continuous white noise from highways. Also, given the overall large area served by a single Caltrain station, parking lots next to them is arguably better and more egalitarian since people can drive in, and take the train more easily. The Park N ride concept is also not just a Bay Area thing, I believe it's quite successful in New Jersey and New York for people commuting to Manhattan to work. I think you might be comparing to the subway systems in places like Manhattan or Barcelona or Paris, but the population and station density of those places is very different.
- Zach_the_Lizard 10y agoPark and rides are actually less egalitarian and worse for the system. An apartment close by is much more likely to generate ridership. Walking is the cheapest form of transportation available, so no need to own vehicles that cost thousands off dollars to reach the station. Also, increasing the supply of housing in general means more access. I'd be willing to bet that housing would allow more people per square foot to ride than a parking garage. Cars take up huge amounts of space. Truly tremendous amounts. Move people and goods, not cars.
- closeparen 10y agoWalking is great, but it is staggeringly expensive to live close to useful things, and similarly expensive in time costs to go from a 60mph freeway to a 4mph brisk walk. I don't disagree that cars take up a lot of space, but from my recent assessment when finding a place to live in the Bay Area, car-centric lifestyle is really a lot cheaper unless you're prepared to make enormous sacrifices in what you accept in terms of living space. >I'd be willing to bet that housing would allow more people per square foot to ride than a parking garage A parking lot requires about 300sqft per car. A stacker system should cut that roughly in half, but to be generous with the fixed costs let's say 200sqft. Every person we serve with a modest 600sqft 1-bedroom within walking distance is 2 people who can't get to the train effectively at all. Drivers can live arbitrarily far away, at whatever cost:space:time tradeoff makes sense for them, and still take the train. If all 3 drivers decide they'd like to sell their cars and walk, the price on apartments within walking distance must rise until 2 of them back off. Bulldozing the parking delivers an awesome lifestyle for the one guy who can afford the housing that replaces it, but at great expense to him and greater expense to the other 2 guys, who now can't get to the train effectively at all. This is why park-n-ride is egalitarian and hip urban development is elitist. Even though you're adding housing, you're increasing the cost to be able to get to the station easily (rent > transportation costs by a long shot) and decreasing the number of people who can do it (unless you're suggesting we live in car-sized apartments). If we want to demolish the walking-distance parking, we need to replace it with something approximately as good for as many people at approximately the same cost. Apartments are better, but they fail the other two tests. Self-driving Uber, bike racks, motorcycle/scooter spaces, all of the above, whatever.
- runamok 10y agoThat and all the 1 story homes in severe disrepair along the route...
- IndianAstronaut 10y agoAnother area for growth is multipurpose strip malls. Shops on the first floor, housing on one or two additional floors.
- scharfstevenm 10y agoArgh, that idea is great in dense cities, but in suburban towns this type of mixed use has failed miserably. The customers from the housing aren't nearly enough to sustain the shops. The shops need a lot of foot traffic to survive, or a lot of parking, and neither usually exists, so the shops quickly fail. We have seen this in Cupertino multiple times. There tends to be a lot of lunch time walking and cycling to restaurants by Apple employees, but that is declining as Apple consolidates their far-flung buildings and opens more Caffè Macs with subsidized lunches. At night, those Apple employees leave on buses (or in cars) and the restaurants struggle and eventually close.
- rabboRubble 10y agoAnd a grocery store, ATMs, post office, dry cleaners, coffee shop, etc. Preferably over the track and with the station exiting right into the main entrance areas for the services. You know what you'd have then!?!? You'd have Tokyo urban design :-)
- scharfstevenm 10y agoDo you also look for places where you could fit schools, shopping, parks, etc.? Sensible and sustainable growth needs to avoid tunnel-vision. But cities are so controlled by developers that they rarely want to take a systems view when rezoning land. In Palo Alto, they realized that there is no way they can build enough housing and schools to offset more office space, and that housing, especially rental housing, is impractical financially because of the crazy parcel tax system and Prop 13. In San Jose, they desperately want more commercial and retail because they have have too much housing and not enough businesses, which causes more congestion, as well as financial problems since taxes on housing don't pay for city services. There are two policy changes needed at the state level: 1. Prop 13 should apply ONLY to owner-occupied residential housing. Owners of rental property and owners of commercial property will prevent this from ever happening in our lifetimes. 2. Parcel taxes should be assessed per housing unit, not per parcel. The CAA (California Apartment Association) has fought successfully against this. What's happening now in Cupertino is a developer spending tens of million of dollars on ballot measure that bypasses the CEQA required EIR, so he can build 2 million square feet of Class A office space, and a few hundred luxury apartments. He'll make out like a bandit, and the city will be left to deal with the traffic, pollution, school impact, and future ABAG housing mandates. It's extremely short-sighted, but of course the developer doesn't care. It's the same developer being fined by Palo Alto for failing to fulfill a CBA (Community Benefits Agreement), the same developer responsible for the abandoned Sunnyvale Town Center, the same developer responsible for Mowry Crossing. These little suburban cities don't have the expertise to craft development agreements that can be enforced, and they get screwed every time. Look at Santa Clara and the Levi's stadium fiasco.