6 ms·
The lack of any substantial quantity of residential development other than large single-family detached homes on large lots in cities like Santa Clara, Palo Alt
by jacobolus 10y ago
The lack of any substantial quantity of residential development other than large single-family detached homes on large lots in cities like Santa Clara, Palo Alto, Mountain View, Cupertino, etc. is absolutely destroying the Bay Area. It forces people to commute from further away, increasing traffic, sprawl, and radically distorting the housing market. We don’t need to turn these towns into Hong Kong or Tokyo, but just build a few blocks radius of 4–6 story mixed-use low-rise apartment buildings around each transit stop, with relaxed parking requirements.
The response of the cities, which is basically to put their fingers in their ears and shout "La la la la we can’t hear you” is a farce. They keep pretending that they can keep indefinitely building office space without anywhere for the workers to live, while maintaining the same small town feel from when these suburbs were first built over the top of agricultural land in the middle of the last century.
- jdavis703 10y agoPeople aren't concerned their cute neighborhood is going to look like Hong Kong. They're concerned they won't see the rapid appreciaton of their assets and don't make forcing the negative effects on anyone else. It makes me think you should be able to vote in both the place you live and work. I pay taxes to Palo Alto and spend the majority of my waking hours there, yet have no say in what rules and regulations the government makes (or doesn't) while I'm there.
- jacobolus 10y agoIn the short term at least, I would expect re-zoning some low density residential neighborhoods to medium density mixed-use zones would substantially increase property values for those areas, because developers would want to buy out single family houses and replace them with larger buildings. From listening to anti-development folks, most of their arguments seem to be vague concerns about “neighborhood character” etc., rather than property values.
- mahyarm 10y agoSome segments know they can't be naked about their greed, so they use vague emotional terms. They usually mention it in offhand sentences. The built in incentives make sure they naturally arise wherever you go.
- DannyBee 10y ago"From listening to anti-development folks, most of their arguments seem to be vague concerns about “neighborhood character” etc., rather than property values." I guess of the hundreds of thousands of people in multiple cities, counties, etc, who have voted for various types of development measures for many years (30+), literally none of them have any valid points that are worth discussing, and any concern about neighborhood character, etc, any of these folks make is really about property values. Sure seems likely there is only one true and right side on this!
- jacobolus 10y agoWhat you’re claiming I think is exactly the opposite of what I wrote. I take people at their word that they’re concerned about neighborhood character. I never said such concerns were invalid or that there was only one right side. Sorry if the word “vague” comes across as dismissive. My primary point was that these cities are happy to add huge amounts of office space but are not willing to build housing at the same pace, and this is upending the housing market in the whole region and leading to massive problems with traffic and sprawl. Do you disagree?
- pmiller2 10y ago> It makes me think you should be able to vote in both the place you live and work. Oh, man, would I love to give SF a piece of my mind on my lunch hour on Tuesday. ;)
- DannyBee 10y ago"People aren't concerned their cute neighborhood is going to look like Hong Kong. They're concerned they won't see the rapid appreciation of their assets " You assert this as if it's true for all people. But it's really really not. I actually do not want to live in an urban area. I am worried my cute neighborhood will turn into hong kong. As the article says, we are going from suburban to urban with nothing in between. I don't actually give a crap about rapid appreciation of my home or anything else like that. People who actually can afford multi-million dollar houses can usually can afford to diversify, and with such low mortgage rates, it pretty much makes no sense to tie large amounts of equity in a home and hope for rapid appreciation. It's a very risky investment strategy. When most of the area was orchards, and some of the first development restrictions were passed, it was not about property values. I also don't think acting like yours is the only acceptable viewpoint, and nobody else could possibly have a valid concern, is going to get any of these issues solved. So, rather than just blindly assert what everyone's concerns and views are, and dismiss them out of hand, maybe you should try to have a well-reasoned discussion? (and FWIW, i'm actually not anti-development, i'm anti-people who don't actually want to have a reasoned discussion about things, and instead, just want to assert whatever view they've come up with. I'm honestly surprised at the arrogance in this thread).
- muninn_ 10y agoGood comment and perspective. I don't live in the Bay Area, but I actually hope that the problem gets worse and that non-development continues. It can/does keep some engineers here in areas like where I live. The primary issue the Bay Area has is that, as you mentioned, there is no in-between. It's either skyscrapers or gigantic houses with expansive yards. What the area actually needs is more mixed-use development neighborhoods.
- eitally 10y agoBy "gigantic" I'm sure you really mean is the 1200-1800sqft tract ranches from the 1940s-60s that consume the majority of the developed suburban land, right, because there are almost 0 gigantic houses in the region compared to literally every other major metro in the country. And that's one of the problems: too many people stretched their budgets to buy crappy $1m houses, they can't really afford to do it again, and prop 13 (plus impending rising mortgage rates) actively disincentivize anyone from selling after they manage to get into this market, no matter what their house is like.
- IndianAstronaut 10y agoThis might actually be a major cause of wealth inequality we are experiencing right now. http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2015/03/wealth-inequality http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2015/03/wealth-i...
- kspaans 10y agoI wonder how many people would accept a compromise of this: they vote to reduce building and density, but at the same time agree that their asset appreciation will go mostly to the city (via cap gains or land value taxes), rather than themselves. (Obviously this goes against Prop 13, but I still wonder how many people would be willing to admit that they want space rather than money.)
- twblalock 10y ago> The lack of any substantial quantity of residential development other than large single-family detached homes on large lots in cities like Santa Clara, Palo Alto, Mountain View, Cupertino, etc. is absolutely destroying the Bay Area. My Caltrain commute takes me from Santa Clara to Redwood City every day. I see quite a few new apartment buildings nearing completion along the line from Santa Clara through Sunnyvale, and again in Redwood City. Driving around Santa Clara and Sunnyvale, I can see even more. Most of them are between three and five stories tall. A lot of new construction is going into multi-unit housing around here, in some cities but not others.
- jdavis703 10y agoThat's true, but those places aren't employment hotbeds. We need housing by the jobs. It should be easy to walk or bike to work. Caltrain is overloaded as it stands already.
- ZanyProgrammer 10y agoElectrification with a much more frequent schedule and shorter trips will help alleviate that.
- chetanahuja 10y agoSanta Clara, Sunnyvale, Mountain View, Redwood city etc. are employment hotbeds. Lots and lots of companies, especially startups but also more established firms, are based in these areas
- tajen 10y agoThere's one more reason why we need housing by the jobs. Global warming. As long as people live >20 minutes from work, there will be many reasons to take the car, and own a car. In Sydney, most of my colleagues didn't own a car. Cars mean parking lots, hence lower density, hence long distances to travel, hence cars are required. America won't reduce their dependency on carbon emissions as long as everything relies on cars.
- 10y ago
- warlox 10y agoCupertino is the worst of these, as there isn't any mass transit there besides VTA buses.
- Spooky23 10y agoYou blame the homeowners, but the root cause is the industry fetishization of the Bay Area. The United States is one of the largest nations on earth. If the Bay Area is full, businesses can and should go somewhere else! That why the valley and LA exist in their present form anyway -- dealing with the drama associated with NYC, Mass, etc was a drag.
- pascalxus 10y agoSadly, the political climate isn't going to change anytime soon. Politicians are bragging about how they're going to keep things the same, in their voting pamphlets - this should tell you something about the vast majority of voters. It's time we accepted this and moved on. Let's all leave the bay area, to another tech hub that has space for expansion. If everyone did that, companies would eventually have to follow suit, unless they wanted to pay even higher salaries. Sacramento, anyone?
- scharfstevenm 10y agoActually there are movements in these cities to stop building so much commercial office space, simply because there is no land on which to build housing to offset the office, or schools to accommodate the students from the new housing, or roads on which to accommodate the vehicles, or funds with which to build mass transit. You also have corrupt school boards whose employees profit handsomely from the boards just putting portables onto existing school sites rather than re-opening leased out school sites. The solution requires a systems approach of higher development fees, corporate funding of transit, higher fuel taxes, a change in property and parcel tax assessment, real EIRs, and eliminating the ability of developers to bypass city planning departments by abusing the initiative process. Unfortunately, the people benefiting from not solving these issues have all the money with which to influence legislators to do nothing. Oil companies, vehicle manufacturers, large apartment complex owners, and commercial property owners. The proposed MTC/ABAG merger seems to be going nowhere. Not sure if that would have helped or not, but it was worth a try. http://www.mtcabagmergerstudy.com/ http://www.mtcabagmergerstudy.com/
- scharfstevenm 10y agoIt’s not sufficient to just build massive amounts of high-density housing in a never-ending race to keep up with more commercial office space. You have to think about where you’re going to put new schools, new parks, new retail, and new transportation, both road expansion and mass transit. Naturally, developers are in it only to maximize their short term profit so they make all sorts of promises that they don’t fulfill, and are able to get away with it because these smaller cities lack the legal expertise to craft bullet-proof agreements. In Palo Alto, Sand Hill Property is being fined a measly $1000 per day for failing to provide the legally mandated grocery store at Edgewood Plaza. Palo Alto’s response: writing the developer a letter—Peter Pau must be terribly scared—not. In Cupertino, when there was a temporary dip in school-age children, the two school districts rushed out and sold or leased schools. They’ve been gradually taking back the leased-out properties, though there are still two elementary schools and one high school that need to be reclaimed. But the sold-off properties became housing, with a small park. When the housing stock finally began to turn over number of school-age children skyrocketed they were in serious trouble. Insufficient money to build new permanent classroom buildings, roads that were never intended to handle the amount of traffic, auditoriums, gymnasiums, cafeterias, playgrounds, and fields that were inadequate. The beneficiaries of this short-sightedness were developers and the manufacturers of portable classrooms. Then high-density housing began to be constructed on former commercial property and school enrollment skyrocketed again, and more portables were added. No money for permanent buildings, though a few were finally built. Every summer you see trucks hauling more portables to the schools. "What did one portable say to the other portable? See you on the playground." Developer fees are set artificially low by state law, laws which the developers lobbied for. Proposition 13 loopholes ensure that commercial property is not reassessed when sold. Parcel taxes are assessed per parcel, not per housing unit, so there is a big incentive to build rental housing, not for-sale housing, which screws over the schools and any other parcel tax beneficiary. The root cause needs to be addressed. It’s money in politics where developers get laws passed that benefit themselves at the expense of residents. So there’s no money for mass transit, schools, parks, roads, etc.. Prop 13, the third rail of California politics desperately needs to be changed so it applies solely to owner-occupied residential housing, and not to commercial property or rental housing. In Cupertino you can see some older condo complexes that are more than 50% rental properties now. The owners pay miniscule property taxes, and rent the units out to families with two or three children. $2000 in yearly property taxes doesn’t pay for even ¼ of one child’s public school expenses, yet the owner is raking in $3500-4000 a month in rent. If you look at major cities throughout the world, they build transit systems that allow residents to commute quickly from outlying areas. The LIRR and PATH in the NYC area. Tokyo, Beijing, Shanghai, Seoul, Munich, Frankfurt, Paris, etc.. BART did this, but they stopped too soon. It needs to go through Livermore and continue out to Tracy and Stockton, as well as going north to Santa Rosa. CalTrain needs to continue to Salinas. But in the U.S. we are unwilling to fund mass transit through higher vehicle fees and fuel taxes.