7 ms·
By comparison, there's $956 quintillion of platinum in the earth's crust, and similar amounts of other precious metals. 5 ug/kg (incidence of platinum in crust
by bryanlarsen 10y ago
By comparison, there's $956 quintillion of platinum in the earth's crust, and similar amounts of other precious metals.
5 ug/kg (incidence of platinum in crust) x 6x10^24 kg (crust size) x 32 USD/g (price of platinum)
Asteroid mining is crazy silly. We're not supply limited for any element on earth, we're demand limited. If the price of platinum rose substantially, so would supply.
It doesn't matter how much of anything is available in space, the only thing that matters is cost. Can it be extracted and brought back to earth for a cost less than the current price on earth? AFAICT, we're not even close to that for anything.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoAdditionally, the production cost of most rare metals is very highly correlated with the cost of energy. It seems likely that space mining may have to compete with metals produced at a price an order of magnitude cheaper than the current price because cheap solar energy appears to be coming.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoSolar power is going to be way, way cheaper in space than even the most optimistic ground-based solar technologies. For instance, it'd be practical to build a multi-kilometer diameter mirror out of thin plastic, and just melt the entire asteroid and distill off what you wanted. To expand a bit: a mirror for a solar furnace on Earth has to be strong enough to hold itself up against the force of gravity and handle wind and precipitation loading. A mirror in space doesn't. It can be one molecule of plastic thick, with a few atoms of thickness of aluminum as a coating. Plus you don't have to worry about cleaning off dust, bird poop, and whatnot. You're going to need some station-keeping so a large, flimsy mirror doesn't drift with the solar wind, but even the purest asteroid is going to have some slag that will make dandy propellant.
- zdkl 10y agoThere's much less high speed objects to puncture the mirror on earth. I think the environment up there is more hostile than you describe
- Turing_Machine 10y agoI think you're vastly overestimating the density of such objects. Space is really pretty empty. Also, small holes won't hurt the mirror to any significant degree.
- zdkl 10y agoI'm more worried about kinetic energy than density in this scenario, but younre certainly right that this is low frequency anyway
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- andrewflnr 10y agoDo you have references about this solar mirror refining idea? It sounds fascinating.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoI'm almost sure the concept was discussed in Gerard K. O'Neill's 1976 book The High Frontier: Human Colonies in Space, but my copy is in storage at the moment so I can't verify that. The idea has been around for at least that long.
- Pica_soO 10y agoYour mirror is going to evaporate gas from the asteroid and push it around out of focus?
- Turing_Machine 10y agoAs I said, you're going to need some station-keeping ability.
- jfoutz 10y agoBut we're using a lot of the crust. No one will be mining under Atlanta. There are plenty of places we aren't using, but the crust is also thick. A mile down sounds really deep, much less 20 miles. I mostly agree with you, but it might wind up easier to nab an asteroid than dig a mile under the ocean.
- bryanlarsen 10y ago"But we're using a lot of the crust." 39% of the surface area is used by agriculture, and 3% by urban areas. That excludes oceans & Antartica. Including those, the number drops to less than 10%. Mining takes up less than 0.05% of the surface area of the earth. I think we're good.
- jfoutz 10y agoBecause it's easy. Digging a hole even a mile deep is hard. It might be worth it, but again, it might be easier to just grab an asteroid.
- echelon 10y agoIs Atlanta rich in rare earth minerals or something, or are you just using a random city as an example? I'm aware of various granite mines around the city (such as where they filmed Walking Dead and Stranger Things), but I wouldn't have imagined Georgia to have disproportionately more minerals than other states in the Southeast.
- zitterbewegung 10y agoYou really wouldnt' want to bring it back to the Earth's surface. You would keep in in orbit and make a satellite(s) out of it.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoLow Earth Orbit is still fairly close to earth, cost wise. (yay SpaceX). A gram of platinum in LEO is only about 20% more expensive than a gram of platinum on Earth. It's the stuff that's cheap but bulky like iron, water & rocket fuel ectrolyzed from water that you'll want to mine in space for use in space. Platinum and other rare metals will simply be waste products that are profitable to ship back to Earth. edit: my original comment used "titanium" instead of "platinum", which made it nonsensical, since titanium isn't a rare metal.
- p1mrx 10y agoIt looks like titanium costs $4/kg [1], and a SpaceX LEO launch is $2719/kg [2]. I'm not sure how much Ti is in "ferro titanium", but even if it's only 10%, the numbers aren't even close. Am I doing this wrong? [1] http://www.infomine.com/investment/metal-prices/ferro-titanium/ http://www.infomine.com/investment/metal-prices/ferro-titani... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9#Launch_prices https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falcon_9#Launch_prices
- bryanlarsen 10y agoNope, it's all me. Platinum is $32/g. Titanium is $4/kg. Mixing the two up results in nonsense.
- Gracana 10y ago> A gram of titanium in LEO is only about 20% more expensive than a gram of titanium on Earth. Can you elaborate on that? I can't parse that statement in a way that would make it seem correct, so... What exactly do you mean?
- 10y ago
- Lxr 10y agoYep, like mining anything asking how much is down there without reference to the cost of extraction is useless. Gold mines exist all over the world with large known deposits but feasibility comes down to whether it's worth it to extract based on current prices.
- IndianAstronaut 10y agoThe whole idea behind investment in asteroid mining is to get capital infrastructure in place to make it cost competitive. In the past we traveled thousands of miles in boats and caravans to get raw materials that were not easily available locally. Sure, you could grow cloves in France, but investing in and establishing routes to south Asia ended up being an investment that made availability of the cloves easier.
- adlpz 10y agoThe earth crust is estimated to be in the order of 10^19 kg. The 6x10^24 figure you mention is the mass of the whole earth. So your calculation if off by 5 orders of magnitude.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoThat's what Wolfram Alpha told me, sorry. But my $956 quintillion number is about as relevant as the article's $700 quintillion number. Even 5 orders of magnitude off, we're still not supply limited. The only number that matters is the $32/gram number.
- syllogism 10y agoThat's not usually a good attitude to take when you're told you're 5 orders of magnitude off.
- IndianAstronaut 10y agoGetting it out of the crust means digging very deep. Asteroids will have higher purity and minerals available on the surface.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoModern platinum mining is mostly done from surface alluvial deposits.
- Beltiras 10y agoEven if it's present in the crust there's the question of how easy or hard it is to convert into usable bars/wire/films. The first asteroid mining operations will focus on asteroids where you can get huge chunks of ore.