4 ms·
> he named it “email”; he obtained the first U.S. copyright to that invention, and the world’s modern system of electronic mail was born. Wow! This struck me
by wyldfire 10y ago
> he named it “email”; he obtained the first U.S. copyright to that invention, and the world’s modern system of electronic mail was born.
Wow! This struck me at first as an embarrassing error from a journalist or publicist. "copyright ... invention." But it's from Ayyadurai's attorney, so it's likely deviously clever instead of bumblingly stupid. Read the words and parse them out: "the first US Copyright to that invention." Well, ok, sure you can call copyrights inventions. Legally they often refer to them as such. But unlike patents, copyrights need not be novel. The attorney calling it "the first ... invention" is likely worded so as to intentionally confuse people who don't distinguish between copyrights, patents, trademarks and the like.
Let's say everyone on my block comes up with a design for "autonomous meshes of robot lawnmowers." If we each develop prototypes in series after having seen the others' works, perhaps they are not derived works and the designs deserve their own copyrights. But wouldn't it be silly for each of us to independently claim the title "inventor of autonomous mesh-robot-lawnmowers"? Often when ordinary people use that term they would assume it to be based on novelty and thus should be a mutually exclusive title per invention.