7 ms·
Internet Pioneers Slam $750,000 Settlement for the 'Man Who Invented Email'
- alooackbar 10y agoBut he did invent email.
- grzm 10y agoAside: Is there a HN script out there that creates an account and posts a comment in one action?
- hiou 10y agoSorry, had to downvote this as you have to be trolling.
- njloof 10y agoNo, no, it's true: he did invent email. He just didn't do it first.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ohstopitu 10y agobut "invent" is defined as "create or design (something that has not existed before); be the originator of."
- sqeaky 10y agoIf you have to play with the semantics of the words this much the argument is invalid.
- hueving 10y agoYou mean if you have to use the definition of the word?
- sqeaky 10y agoThat many downvotes is unfortunate... But words are not these neat bundles of data like JSON or XML. They mean different things to different people. Once mud has been thrown on an argument and everything is see because of the murky grey areas pulling out a dictionary won't help. The other side will just pull out one with a definition that meets their needs.
- teddyh 10y agoThe most you could say is that he re-invented it independently. But plain “invented” is simply not true.
- warkdarrior 10y ago"To invent" means "to create or design something that has not existed before". Obviously not true in this case.
- imron 10y agoHe invented an electronic messaging system that he called email. But what he created is distinct and in no way related or had influence on the design or implementation of email we use today. The history of email is documented in RFCs that date back to when this supposed 'inventor' was a toddler.
- brazzledazzle 10y agoI think it would be more accurate to say that he invented the first private/internal email-based collaboration systems a la Microsoft Exchange. Which is actually a pretty decent claim to fame that I'd certainly be happy with.
- scosman 10y agoInteresting that Gizmodo was a gawker property and this is them essentially re-publishing the claims, immediately after setting a defamation lawsuit.
- brazzledazzle 10y agoThis one appears to have been written more carefully.
- nols 10y agoEvery little bit helps recoup that settlement
- danso 10y agoThis is disturbing on a First Amendment level: you can't insult someone when he makes a claim that puts him in the public spotlight, and when such a claim is highly disputable with facts? On a tech level, this is just shameful. Neither Thiel or Ayyadurai will say if Thiel paid for this lawsuit, that it's just a coincidence that he hired the same lawyer at around the same time when Thiel hired him for the Hogan case. After Tomlinson died, Ayyadurai immediately went on the offensive and blogged, "Correction: The Inventor of Email is Still Alive" http://fortune.com/2016/03/07/who-really-invented-email/ http://fortune.com/2016/03/07/who-really-invented-email/ Edit: a more in depth story here from 2012 when the debate first broke out; MIT apparently highly disagreed with Ayyadurai's version of history and cut off ties with him http://www.bostonmagazine.com/2012/05/shiva-ayyaduri-email-us-postal-service/ http://www.bostonmagazine.com/2012/05/shiva-ayyaduri-email-u...
- grzm 10y agoI haven't followed the whole Gawker/Thiel/Hogan spectacle very closely. As for Charles J. Harder representing Hogan, Ayyudurai, and Terrill, if there's an attorney that's known for a particular specialty, it would make sense to seek them out if you'd like to bring a similar case. So, while it may not be coincidence that he's representing all three, it doesn't necessarily mean that that two or more of them are being funded by Thiel. Doesn't rule it out, either. Edit to add qualification: It isn't/wasn't my intent to turn this into a Thiel/Gawker thing like the many we've had on HN over the past weeks. It was only to float the idea that it isn't necessarily all that odd for the same lawyer to be involved in similar lawsuits. Nor to gaslight (a term that I've recently learned after reading enough comments here on HN). Like I said, I'm really ignorant about all of this and should have done more research to see what's actually been said. No more from me on this.
- huac 10y agoThiel announced that he was funding multiple lawsuits against Gawker. There's more than a penumbra of evidence in this case.
- danso 10y agoThe case for the connection is indeed circumstantial. Waiting 4 years, until 2016, could be explained by the fact that Gawker vs. Hogan was in the news and so maybe Ayyadurai thought that whoever was lawyering that case would be good for him too. I wonder if he'll get around to forcing Gawker to put up a meta tag that will force the erasure of the original Gawker stories from the Internet Archive [0], which are used to footnote his extensive Wikipedia page (which Wikipedia editors initially thought should be deleted for being an obvious vanity page, but then kept it to serve as a counterpoint against his claims [1] [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20120306204240/http://gizmodo.com/5888702/corruption-lies-and-death-threats-the-crazy-story-of-the-man-who-pretended-to-invent-email https://web.archive.org/web/20120306204240/http://gizmodo.co... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Shiva_Ayyadurai https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletio...
- jbuzbee 10y agoMore coverage here: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20161103/11502935958/heres-truth-shiva-ayyadurai-didnt-invent-email.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20161103/11502935958/heres...
- sulam 10y agoI love how carefully this article reports on statements made in other publications without making any statements itself. Some lawyer made a good amount of money reading drafts of this thing, to make sure they can't be sued!
- mcguire 10y ago"Univision, which purchased most of Gawker Media’s assets (including this site) out of bankruptcy in September, deleted two Gizmodo posts concerning Ayyadurai..." The new owners want the whole mess behind them.
- classycoder 10y agostreet shiters claim to invent Email, while he was a toddler. Who invented the email in 1971? This is why Ray Tomlinson is credited with inventing email in 1972. Like many of the Internet inventors, Tomlinson worked for Bolt Beranek and Newman as an ARPANET contractor. He picked the @ symbol from the computer keyboard to denote sending messages from one computer to another.
- thick18cm 10y agoDoes anybody know, does Peter Thiel get any of the "credit" for helping this to happen, i.e. since it's the same attorney, was it part of his same funding effort? If so, it would be somewhat hilarious--"Thiel supports claim that email was invented in 1982"--but more seriously points up more clearly that big money supporting lawsuits for revenge is not always as "civic minded" as the clear privacy issues of the Bollea case.
- wyldfire 10y ago> he named it “email”; he obtained the first U.S. copyright to that invention, and the world’s modern system of electronic mail was born. Wow! This struck me at first as an embarrassing error from a journalist or publicist. "copyright ... invention." But it's from Ayyadurai's attorney, so it's likely deviously clever instead of bumblingly stupid. Read the words and parse them out: "the first US Copyright to that invention." Well, ok, sure you can call copyrights inventions. Legally they often refer to them as such. But unlike patents, copyrights need not be novel. The attorney calling it "the first ... invention" is likely worded so as to intentionally confuse people who don't distinguish between copyrights, patents, trademarks and the like. Let's say everyone on my block comes up with a design for "autonomous meshes of robot lawnmowers." If we each develop prototypes in series after having seen the others' works, perhaps they are not derived works and the designs deserve their own copyrights. But wouldn't it be silly for each of us to independently claim the title "inventor of autonomous mesh-robot-lawnmowers"? Often when ordinary people use that term they would assume it to be based on novelty and thus should be a mutually exclusive title per invention.
- blazespin 10y agoI dunno, I think the settlment is right. I'm sure someone before Tomlinson invented a way to talk to someone else over electronic communication. Like, you know, the telegram? From what I can tell, Ayyadurai actually invented "email". Makes perfect sense to me. Look at all the techies downvoting, because Tomlinson is such a genius for thinking that someone might want to use internet to communicate with each other. The reality is we call it email. That's something to brag about.
- totalZero 10y agoHe didn't invent email. He built something and named it "EMAIL" after email already existed. Then he marketed himself as the inventor of email and married Fran Drescher.
- Terr_ 10y agoIMO even the article title perpetuates the problem -- quotation marks notwithstanding -- because it still pushes the phrase out there. Why not "Man who claims he invented email"?
- sthkr 10y agoAnything to hurt Nick Denton and shutdown Gawker is awesome no matter how absurd the case.