4 ms·
As sibling comments note, it's not a crime to provide material rewards (probably including cash) to vote, so long as it's not for voting a specific way (e.g. sh
by SilasX 10y ago
As sibling comments note, it's not a crime to provide material rewards (probably including cash) to vote, so long as it's not for voting a specific way (e.g. show me a trump ballot and you get a free coffee). EDIT: see response thread, that's illegal too but IMHO doesn't affect the point.
I still see it as a loophole for getting money into politics: if a maybe-voting demographic that leans toward party X also shops at Y, then Y's reward for voting is going to differentially help party X.
E.g. since Starbucks patrons probably lean Democrat, Starbucks's free-coffee-for-voting probably does have "disparate impact" favoring Democrats, even if the free coffee is not conditional on who you voted for.
Then you can go one step removed: if rich billionaires want the Democrat to win, they can approach similar establishments and offer to pay for the cost of their "free X for voting". Boom, a money vector that will survive a Citizen's United reversal.
Then what? Do you require such efforts to bankroll similar offers at coffee places with opposite demographics? Or prohibit any rewards for voting?
- maxerickson 10y agoThe way I read the statute I linked, paying someone to vote is illegal. But Lyft isn't paying people to vote, they are making it cheaper to gain proximity to the polling place. If they made the discount conditional on voting, it would be illegal.
- SilasX 10y agoAh okay I had remembered Starbucks doing this promotion but it seems they pulled it back due to election laws: http://blogs.wsj.com/washwire/2008/11/03/starbucks-offers-free-coffee-to-voters-on-election-day/ http://blogs.wsj.com/washwire/2008/11/03/starbucks-offers-fr... It's kind of a distinction without a difference though: like in the Lyft case, you can give a material reward for going 90% of the way to a vote, and the influence on the election is the same.
- maxerickson 10y agoIt's kind of a distinction without a difference though I disagree. Whether the offer is conditional is a simple and effective test to catch all the problematic cases, it just happens to erroneously catch free coffee if you have a sticker. So the difference is that one of the activities falls on the wrong side of the test.
- SilasX 10y agoI meant it made no difference with respect to influencing election outcomes because of how you can make close-enough legal offers, not that the law is hard to apply as written.
- koolba 10y agoSo can I go to a predominately XYZ neighborhood[1] and offer "Free Stuff - Just show your 'I voted sticker!'"? [1]: Democrat, Republican, etc.
- paulddraper 10y agoAbsolutely. Lots of places offer free stuff if you have the sticker: http://www.thepennyhoarder.com/election-day-freebies-i-voted-sticker/ http://www.thepennyhoarder.com/election-day-freebies-i-voted... Anyone can do that in whatever location they like.