3 ms·
On the surface your argument is about hardware, but the real story here is software. The reason your touchscreen on a laptop is mostly useless is because there
by jacobolus 10y ago
On the surface your argument is about hardware, but the real story here is software.
The reason your touchscreen on a laptop is mostly useless is because there’s no software designed to require both keyboard and touchscreen interaction. (Also because it’s sort of awkward and tiring to use a touchscreen which is propped up vertically in front of you, and requires moving your hands way off the keyboard, but let’s leave that aside for now.)
If you just take software written for a desktop PC from 1995, and slap a bunch of new input devices on the side, the new inputs are going to end up being useless sideshows.
I would love to have a desktop computer with a large upright screen in front of me and my hands on a split two-handed clicky–full-travel–switch keyboard with a 7–10 inch multitouch touchscreen in the middle which could be used for both pointer movement and direct interaction with on screen UI controls. But it would only be awesome if a large number of other people had exactly the same interface, and software authors spent several years writing software specifically intended to run on it.
This is my big fear with Apple’s new touchbar thing. Since it will only be on a fraction of customer machines, it can’t be relied on to exist and can therefore only be used as a secondary (redundant) input method, used to make certain actions more convenient.
This is the same reason that Steve Jobs wanted to take arrow keys off the original Macintosh. He feared that if they could fall back on keyboard input, software authors wouldn’t bother adopting the mouse.