4 ms·
The future is not touch. The future is mobile. Mobile is constrained to using touch interfaces, or even more precisely, mobile is constrained to using touch int
by jerf 10y ago
The future is not touch. The future is mobile. Mobile is constrained to using touch interfaces, or even more precisely, mobile is constrained to using touch interface on the active screen (as opposed to the touch interface of a trackpad or something). Mobile did not choose this, it was forced on it because there is no other choice. There's no room to put any other input devices on the phone itself, and nobody is going to carry around extra mice or something. (We could barely get some people to use styluses that fit in the device itself.)
It's weird to hear people waxing poetic about touch nowadays, because now that we've all been using touch interfaces for several years, we all should be realizing that they aren't necessarily that awesome. We've all by now used a map app that, as nice as the touch interface was, just didn't quite gel in terms of whether we were zooming, panning, twisting, or trying to select a single location. We should all be able to observe that the act of using a touch interface also means that we must block the line-of-sight to that same interface, meaning both that the touch thing we are interacting with can't feed back in the most natural place to do so, and that touch interfaces must be very large to accommodate the lack of precision. We must all have dealt with the accidental dialing brought on by the touch interface that can't distinguish between fingers and buttocks, or the stray emails we deleted in the act of simply picking up our phone, or the accidental order placed when we tried to clean a drop of water or a speck of dust off the screen. And I don't care how good you are with that touch keyboard, you'd be better on something that could have custom-built haptic feedback, and ideally, haptic feedback you can "feel" without triggering inputs, too. Touch screens are still the best solution for mobile, but they are clearly not "all that".
From this point of view, where mobile is the future but touch just happens to be along for that ride, bodging touch on to a laptop isn't that impressive and there's no reason to believe it's the wave of the future. I've actually got "touch" on my laptop, in the form of my trackpad, and for a 2D slab, I get rather a lot of distinct inputs out of it. Remember that everything I can use that for comfortably is one more opportunity that I don't need a "touchbar" for. (That's been my real criticism of the touchbar; it's not necessarily intrinsically a bad idea or fundamentally useless, it's that the list of things for which it is the best solution is rather short. And I'm not saying it's empty... just short. In particular, it's much shorter than the list of things that it could be used for, but for which it's not the best solution.)
Further, despite not particularly wanting it the laptop I'm typing this on has a full touchscreen. Mostly I remember this when I go to clean the screen of some bit of dust and my mouse cursor starts jumping around. I don't need it for much. Even when acquiring a button on the screen, the touchpad is faster than removing my hand from the keyboard and clicking. My touchpad already has several useful gestures, draining away the marginal utility of other touch interfaces. It's not that useful, even though it's sitting right in front of me. Now, it's not a 2-in-1, where I can at least see the use case, but, neither is the new Mac, right? It's just not that useful. Not useless, but not very useful.
It's not touch that's the future, it's mobile. The still-not-yet-mature-but-still-inevitable "mobile phone that docks to a desktop and provides its guts" will be a hybrid device, and the "touchiness" is irrelevant.
(Actually, now that I think of it this way, the Nintendo Switch may be the closest thing to a successful implementation of that I've seen in a while. Perhaps if that succeeds, it'll open the doors to computer versions of that idea.)
- jacobolus 10y agoOn the surface your argument is about hardware, but the real story here is software. The reason your touchscreen on a laptop is mostly useless is because there’s no software designed to require both keyboard and touchscreen interaction. (Also because it’s sort of awkward and tiring to use a touchscreen which is propped up vertically in front of you, and requires moving your hands way off the keyboard, but let’s leave that aside for now.) If you just take software written for a desktop PC from 1995, and slap a bunch of new input devices on the side, the new inputs are going to end up being useless sideshows. I would love to have a desktop computer with a large upright screen in front of me and my hands on a split two-handed clicky–full-travel–switch keyboard with a 7–10 inch multitouch touchscreen in the middle which could be used for both pointer movement and direct interaction with on screen UI controls. But it would only be awesome if a large number of other people had exactly the same interface, and software authors spent several years writing software specifically intended to run on it. This is my big fear with Apple’s new touchbar thing. Since it will only be on a fraction of customer machines, it can’t be relied on to exist and can therefore only be used as a secondary (redundant) input method, used to make certain actions more convenient. This is the same reason that Steve Jobs wanted to take arrow keys off the original Macintosh. He feared that if they could fall back on keyboard input, software authors wouldn’t bother adopting the mouse.
- douche 10y agoWe had slide-out keyboards in phones once, and they were glorious. Going to all-touch is a regression, and should be seen as such. Otherwise, I agree completely. I hate the phenomenon of touchscreen laptops. A.) I never use it intentionally, and usually go disable it in the OS or BIOS. B.) It's more expensive than a dumb screen.
- nkurz 10y agoMobile is constrained to using touch interfaces Currently, but do you think this is the end game? Why not voice, gesture, eye tracking, or some as yet unachievable brain interface? The seemingly insurmountable defects you point out (lack of feedback without activation, hand obscuring the screen) would seem to imply that touch is never going to be the best universal interface. My touchpad already has several useful gestures, draining away the marginal utility of other touch interfaces. I'm surprised that I haven't seen built-in touchpads that integrate a screen, maybe modal between the displayed screen in miniature, a zoom of the cursor, and a menu space. Might it make more sense to integrate a display into the existing touch interface rather than adding a new (hard to reach) one? On the other hand, I've been surprised that my friends who use tablet interfaces for graphics work don't find the integrated screen approach (http://www.wacom.com/en-us/products/pen-displays http://www.wacom.com/en-us/products/pen-displays) to be compelling.