6 ms·
> The people I look for are those that take strong stands but are willing and able to adjust and even quickly reverse those stances. Sometimes called "strong o
by twic 10y ago
> The people I look for are those that take strong stands but are willing and able to adjust and even quickly reverse those stances.
Sometimes called "strong opinions, weakly held".
I find this principle to be incoherent - if you understand something well enough to have a strong opinion, you understand it well enough to hold that opinion strongly. Holding strong opinions on things you don't understand that well seems unhelpful.
- steveklabnik 10y agoOne aspect you're missing here is time; just because something is true today doesn't make it true tomorrow.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- oxide 10y agoWe all know arguing against a strongly held opinion usually results in the person with the strong opinion digging their heels in even deeper. At that point, things like reason kind of go by the wayside and don't have much effect. As a poor example, my mother has fully bought into a snake-oil scheme where they sell you concentrated hydrogen peroxide as a cure-all. She won't hear a word against it, she always brings the conversation back to "OTC hydrogen peroxide has stabilizers in it." Asking "what is a stabilizer" gets no response. The truth is, she doesn't know what a stabilizer is, but it's plausible enough to her that they could be "bad" that she's willing to buy the rest of the farm, along with the cow. How can you argue against that kind of strongly held opinion? When the other party won't listen because of how strongly held the opinion is, you might as well talk to a wall.
- Animats 10y agoHow concentrated? Concentrated hydrogen peroxide (> 90%) is a rocket fuel. Above 8% is considered somewhat hazardous. Above 28%, hazmat precautions (corrosive, burns skin). Above 35%, unstable. Above 50%, even large industrial users usually don't go.[1] [1] http://www.h2o2.com/technical-library/default.aspx?pid=76& http://www.h2o2.com/technical-library/default.aspx?pid=76&
- oxide 10y agoI'm not sure, I believe it's 35% or more. She once mentioned that "it's not the legit stuff unless you have to sign a hazardous materials sheet" or something to that affect.
- dredmorbius 10y agoOdds are good that the supplier's lying on both the benefits and qualities (concentration). A fake MSDS/hazmat sheet would be par for the course.
- Mathnerd314 10y agoThe end result of knowing a lot about a topic is often that you can't make very strong statements about it; they always end up being something like "you're kind of right because XYZ, but also kind of wrong because XYZ". So the ideal situation is more like "weak opinions, strong actions". Let's take the example of where someone yells "Duck!". Most likely, you weren't paying attention and you have no clue why they would yell such a thing. There is a high chance that it's some kind of prank. But, I argue, you should still duck anyway, because the potential benefits (not getting a concussion) outweigh the risks (looking stupid). Similarly, if you are running a startup, you should prepared to pivot at the first sign of customer mismatch, but meanwhile the majority of work will be in one direction, and you should work on it passionately.
- macawfish 10y agoI think another way of thinking about this is "being open minded". Life is full of seemingly contradictory truths and perspectives, facets and angles.
- adrusi 10y agoYou don't need to understand something well to be justified in having a strong opinion about it. Your belief should be based on the evidence you have, even if that means a small amount that leads you to an extreme conclusion. Otherwise you will have a bias toward the median belief, and there's no reason to expect, in general, that a median belief is any better than an extreme one. The strength of your evidence should only affect the level of attachment that you have to your belief.
- ball_of_lint 10y agoIf you don't understand something well, then any opinion you might claim to have on it is not actually on it, but rather on what you currently understand it to be. In that case, why not just say that you simply don't know enough to have an informed opinion?
- thwarted 10y agoIn that case, why not just say that you simply don't know enough to have an informed opinion? Up against a dishonest debater, this is exploitable to lessen your influence, even if your position is relatively stronger, against (unsubstantiated) claims of being an expert. "ball_of_lint claims to be uninformed and doesn't have an opinion. That's okay, listen to me, I'm an expert"
- Too 10y agoSo you'd rather win one debate at the cost of loosing reputation for years? If someone strongly claims they know something and I later find out that they were wrong, I simply can't trust that person ever again.
- thwarted 10y agoIf someone strongly claims they know something and I later find out that they were wrong, I simply can't trust that person ever again. I'm glad you're a critical enough thinker to do that (although it's unfortunate that you don't account for honest conviction or that person obtaining further understanding such that they change their position; after all, not all strong claims revealed to be wrong are meant to deceive). Not everyone is that kind of critical thinker, especially up against a savvy, dishonest debater/character/charlatan. Some people just keep shouting "I know the answer" or "Believe me!" to every question or issue and they end up with a following.
- TheBobinator 10y agoThere are people for whom Ego and social status are more important than life itself. They, like you, and the OP who stated effectively "I can't converse with people who have strongly held opinions", are usually people with such little confidence that the only thing they have going for them is the hope that a nice suit and not rocking the boat will get them through life comfortably. There are people who are there to accomplish an objective such as completing a project or achieving a goal. Those people will present strong opinions to each other, and often will call each other names and hack things out. But, at the end of the day, they are motivated to explore the other sides opinion in order to discourage it and that fosters the growth of character that can admit they are wrong. They learn which discussions are important as a group, which cause the group to go in a completely insane tangent that will accomplish nothing, and which discussions don't matter; 90% of the debates you have don't mean a thing and often whether you're using one method or another is pointless so long as the work gets done to spec. People who debate on ego and their own inflated sense of importance do not present discreet arguments, and are incapable of having a discussion about achieving a goal or completing an objective. Forgive my vitriol, but after seeing those people flush untold millions down the drain and hurt people and families countless times, they belong flipping burgers or in a mass grave. If your job gets to the point, or is going in the direction of such catastrophe that you might as well not be there, it's time to have a "course correction" discussion with your boss. You don't have to walk in with your resignation letter in your pocket, but a simple "X is really stupid, here's why". Don't blame people, don't make assumptions, just point out the situation, how you got here, and where you think things should go. I've never, ever been fired for this. I have been fired for not having those conversations, however. Additionally, there's a sexist truth here, which is men are made to make women into their purpose for being, and women are made to follow them, this is how nature works. The kinds of corporate environments where strong opinions are eschewed or actively discouraged are usually those with lots of grown women and boys parading as men. Those environments exist usually as cargo cults for established enterprises such as utilities or governments. The work performed does not further society or the enterprise in any meaningful way and in order to compensate for that, management builds an ego farm of gullible, easily manipulated people that will do as they are told unquestioningly. It's like having a harem. Those environments tend towards managerial abuse, and end up going down like the Hindenburg. If you find yourself in that kind of environment, decide on your exit strategy early.
- amag 10y agoOften I find the opposite, a better understanding of something means that you have to very clearly understand both its pros and its cons. So by understanding something you dislike well, you need to appreciate its pros, which will lead to a weaker negative opinion about it. Conversely, understanding something you like well, means you need to come to terms with its cons as well, which should lead to moderation as well.