6 ms·
Wherefore art thou Macintosh?
- mturmon 10y agoAn article on the MBP hardware evolution with some vision and intellectual substance instead of ankle biting. Well done.
- marricks 10y agoThis piece seemed kind of interesting and then lost me when it just lead to multi-pargraph heavy handed metaphor, > But Apple’s immune system was suppressed. It allowed a disruptor to emerge from within. Apple gave birth to its future by suppressing the reaction to that new seemingly parasitic organism. It took an immense willpower to allow this to happen. It's strange that they're criticizing Apple for successfully making a product, the iPhone, that can take off a lot of your PC work, browse/emails/basic things. Clearly Apple is trying forge a distinctly Macbook Pro path for themselves without diving into phone/tablet territory. Until we have more reviews and impressions from the touch bar out in the wild it's a bit early to write off that effort.
- na85 10y ago>Until we have more reviews and impressions from the touch bar out in the wild it's a bit early to write off that effort. Disagree. There is much we can surmise and deduce from what we already know. It runs the WatchOS, which to me seems like a singularly bone-headed decision. Why on earth would they choose to segregate it from the laptop in such a fashion, and use the OS from one of their worst products, to boot? To me these things clearly indicate bad management or lack of vision at the helm.
- elsurudo 10y agoFrom the user's perspective, it doesn't really matter what OS it runs – it should just be seamless. The decision must have made some sort of sense from a hardware perspective. I haven't developed for WatchOS, but I believe its SDK is a simplified version of Cocoa Touch, so it shouldn't be difficult for current iOS/macOS devs to grasp.
- 0x0 10y agoAs a mac developer you never even see the watchOS nature of the touch bar. It could have been implemented as a raspberry pi running linux for all the mac developer cares, since it's "just" a framebuffer + multitouch input + probably something related to finger prints and secure enclaves. See https://developer.apple.com/reference/appkit/nstouchbar https://developer.apple.com/reference/appkit/nstouchbar
- marricks 10y agoIt's short sighted to say "using something from their worst product is a terrible decision." Reasons why it'd make sense to use that processor * it's their lowest power chip with the capabilities * it's already optimized for touch interactions * it has security enclave built in, which is processor specific * it allows for a secure separation between the touch id & the web cam from the processor The last point especially resonates with me. So many web cams get hacked, and getting a wall between the internet and my webcam sounds like a good thing.
- na85 10y agoA company with as many resources as Apple could have integrated the secure enclave into their motherboard design rather than go for this half-baked solution of just slapping an i Watch into the laptop. So much for Apple's vaunted innovation.
- toasterlovin 10y agoHave you ever considered that a company with world class processor and system on a chip expertise might understand this problem space and it's design trade offs better than you?
- Chyzwar 10y agoHave you ever considered that Apple can make mistake. iWatch analogy is correct, touch bar is the same idea for Mac as iWatch to iPhone. We know that iWatch is flop and there is not much enthusiasms for new Mac.
- grzm 10y ago"We know that iWatch is flop and there is not much enthusiasms for new Mac." What gives you this impression? Looking at the metrics available, it looks like the Apple Watch is doing well, as is the newest MacBook Pro. "Apple Watch revenue totaled $6 billion in its first 12 months of availability."[0] "Apple Inc. sold twice as many Watches as iPhones in each device’s debut year."[1] "And we are proud to tell you that so far our online store has had more orders for the new MacBook Pro than any other pro notebook before." -- Phil Schiller [2] "The new MacBook Pro has only been available for purchase for about six hours, but shipping estimates on the machine have already slipped from two to three weeks to three to four weeks,"[3] This last could be interpreted as Apple having drastically underestimated the stock they needed to have on hand, purposely limited stock so they could make these kinds of quotes, had supply chain issues that prevented them from having the stock they wanted, or didn't want to have large stock on hand, in preference to more JIT delivery. Happy to be corrected if you have other information. [0]: http://bgr.com/2016/04/26/apple-watch-sales-vs-rolex/ http://bgr.com/2016/04/26/apple-watch-sales-vs-rolex/ [1]: http://www.wsj.com/articles/apple-watch-with-sizable-sales-cant-shake-its-critics-1461524901 http://www.wsj.com/articles/apple-watch-with-sizable-sales-c... [2]: http://www.macrumors.com/2016/11/02/phil-schiller-new-macbook-pro-interview/ http://www.macrumors.com/2016/11/02/phil-schiller-new-macboo... [3]: http://www.macrumors.com/2016/10/27/macbook-pro-shipping-estimates-begin-slipping/ http://www.macrumors.com/2016/10/27/macbook-pro-shipping-est...
- webwielder2 10y agoI believe you have misunderstood the author's point. He is not criticizing Apple, but rather analyzing how they are managing disrupting themselves while seeking to find ways of making the disrupted product continue to be relevant.
- hyperpape 10y agoHe's not criticizing: "Apple gave birth to its future by suppressing the reaction to that new seemingly parasitic organism. It took an immense willpower to allow this to happen." (In addition to that quote, I've listened to several podcasts with him, and he's a huge believer in view that big companies have to be willing to sacrifice their existing products to survive).
- kryptiskt 10y agoApple should make the Mac business a separate business unit (they could call it Apple Computer...). Then that unit can concentrate on making the best computers they can do. As it is now, the Macs is secondary in importance for Apple's management, and it also takes their attention away from their core phone business at times. Why not just spin it off? Apple can still own 100% of it, the important part to get a management that is completely focused on that business.
- marcuskaz 10y agoHere's an excellent article and analysis of Apple's Organization structure https://stratechery.com/2016/apples-organizational-crossroads/ https://stratechery.com/2016/apples-organizational-crossroad...
- tempodox 10y agoI'm afraid that's too simplistic to work. There are logical and logistic dependencies between Mac & iDevices. Splitting that up (without removing those dependencies) would only add more complications and points of friction.
- Chyzwar 10y agoBecause it share to much with mobile division. OS kernel, application framework, tools etc and probably much more. What they should do is have better integration, they should have one operating system that would work like Ubuntu convergence. There is plenty potential in iPhone that is untapped.
- maxxxxx 10y agoI think Apple's interest in the Mac is mainly as a platform for iOS development these days. I wonder if there will be a point when they will open up iOS development to other platforms and totally abandon the Mac.
- grzm 10y agoInteresting take that I've heard elsewhere. What is this based on? If I understand what you're saying correctly (and please correct me if I'm wrong), can we infer that most people who buy Macs are iOS devs?
- imron 10y agoWithout the mac there is no iPhone. Before disagreeing, ask yourself what every single piece of iPhone software was written on. Someone has to make the software and you ignore developers at your peril.
- douche 10y agoSimple solution: allow virtualized build server licenses. Or they could offer a cloud build service a la TFS online. Having to have an overpriced piece of hardware in the loop in order to run software to compile other software for a third piece of hardware is, to use the German, verrückt.
- pjmlp 10y agoThe developers agry at Apple aren't the ones doing iOS apps, rather the ones using a UNIX with pretty UI, which contribute zero to the amount of iPhone apps. So it doesn't matter that Apple ignores them.
- imron 10y agoIt does matter, just not in the short term. As people leave the platform, the amount of revenue it makes the company diminishes. As the revenue earned from Macs diminishes, its importance to the company diminishes and they put less resources towards it. As its importance to the company diminishes and it gets less resources, the quality diminishes. As the quality diminishes, they lose other developers also. It's a slow decline that will take maybe 5-10 years.
- tempodox 10y agoI think the article has some good points but I disagree on calling the keyboard an “indirect” input method wrt text. Until touchscreen keyboards feel like a physical keyboard, I don't see them holding a torch when it comes to entering more than a few characters. There's a good reason you can connect a physical Bluetooth keyboard to the iDevices. And while a keyboard / touchscreen combination is certainly possible, it's also not as ergonomic as moving your hand just a little bit to reach a trackpad or mouse from the keyboard. Excitement about new tech is not a good long-term replacement for ergonomics.
- bshimmin 10y agoNot that it really matters, but "wherefore" means "why", not "where". Juliet wasn't wondering where Romeo was, she was lamenting that he was born a Montague.
- xkcd-sucks 10y agoThis is the shibboleth of having taken high school English
- conistonwater 10y agoNo it's not! There are tons of places in Shakespeare where he uses wherefore, and that one place in Romeo and Juliet is literally the only usage that's somewhat ambiguous. > Beatrice: Why, how now, cousin! wherefore sink you down? (http://shakespeare.mit.edu/much_ado/full.html http://shakespeare.mit.edu/much_ado/full.html) When your cousin faints, would anybody ask where they have just fainted?
- schoen 10y ago"Shibboleth" doesn't mean "mistake", it means "way to check whether someone belongs to a group". "The shibboleth of having taken high school English" means "you can tell if someone took high school English by whether they know/say this". (It also happens that if they know/say this, they are correct.)
- conistonwater 10y agoI know that. It's still not a shibboleth: on the contrary, the meaning is so clear from the usage (except that one place in Romeo and Juliet), that any fluent speaker will recognize the meaning quickly even if they'd never seen it before. At best, it's a shibboleth for having watched any Shakespeare, but that's not what they meant to say. There are many places in Shakespeare that are unreadable to a modern-English speaker without explanatory footnotes, but this isn't one of them.
- 10y ago
- jerf 10y agoThe future is not touch. The future is mobile. Mobile is constrained to using touch interfaces, or even more precisely, mobile is constrained to using touch interface on the active screen (as opposed to the touch interface of a trackpad or something). Mobile did not choose this, it was forced on it because there is no other choice. There's no room to put any other input devices on the phone itself, and nobody is going to carry around extra mice or something. (We could barely get some people to use styluses that fit in the device itself.) It's weird to hear people waxing poetic about touch nowadays, because now that we've all been using touch interfaces for several years, we all should be realizing that they aren't necessarily that awesome. We've all by now used a map app that, as nice as the touch interface was, just didn't quite gel in terms of whether we were zooming, panning, twisting, or trying to select a single location. We should all be able to observe that the act of using a touch interface also means that we must block the line-of-sight to that same interface, meaning both that the touch thing we are interacting with can't feed back in the most natural place to do so, and that touch interfaces must be very large to accommodate the lack of precision. We must all have dealt with the accidental dialing brought on by the touch interface that can't distinguish between fingers and buttocks, or the stray emails we deleted in the act of simply picking up our phone, or the accidental order placed when we tried to clean a drop of water or a speck of dust off the screen. And I don't care how good you are with that touch keyboard, you'd be better on something that could have custom-built haptic feedback, and ideally, haptic feedback you can "feel" without triggering inputs, too. Touch screens are still the best solution for mobile, but they are clearly not "all that". From this point of view, where mobile is the future but touch just happens to be along for that ride, bodging touch on to a laptop isn't that impressive and there's no reason to believe it's the wave of the future. I've actually got "touch" on my laptop, in the form of my trackpad, and for a 2D slab, I get rather a lot of distinct inputs out of it. Remember that everything I can use that for comfortably is one more opportunity that I don't need a "touchbar" for. (That's been my real criticism of the touchbar; it's not necessarily intrinsically a bad idea or fundamentally useless, it's that the list of things for which it is the best solution is rather short. And I'm not saying it's empty... just short. In particular, it's much shorter than the list of things that it could be used for, but for which it's not the best solution.) Further, despite not particularly wanting it the laptop I'm typing this on has a full touchscreen. Mostly I remember this when I go to clean the screen of some bit of dust and my mouse cursor starts jumping around. I don't need it for much. Even when acquiring a button on the screen, the touchpad is faster than removing my hand from the keyboard and clicking. My touchpad already has several useful gestures, draining away the marginal utility of other touch interfaces. It's not that useful, even though it's sitting right in front of me. Now, it's not a 2-in-1, where I can at least see the use case, but, neither is the new Mac, right? It's just not that useful. Not useless, but not very useful. It's not touch that's the future, it's mobile. The still-not-yet-mature-but-still-inevitable "mobile phone that docks to a desktop and provides its guts" will be a hybrid device, and the "touchiness" is irrelevant. (Actually, now that I think of it this way, the Nintendo Switch may be the closest thing to a successful implementation of that I've seen in a while. Perhaps if that succeeds, it'll open the doors to computer versions of that idea.)
- auggierose 10y ago> capturing over 60% of the available PC hardware profits These profits are not available, they are MADE. Mostly by Apple.
- addicted 10y ago"It remains indirect, a defining characteristic of the second wave. Indirect inputs are powerful and lend themselves to muscle memory with practice" It's not indirectness that lends itself to muscle memory but rather staticness. To illustrate this, consider a keyboard that randomly switched between Dvorak and QWERTY. This keyboard would not lend itself to muscle memory at all, despite being as indirect as a normal keyboard. I think the touchbar could be beneficial in the muscle memory sense if it remains static within an application. At that point it simply becomes a more easily looked up version of Fn key shortcuts (but with potentially poorer tactile feel).
- kleigenfreude 10y agoThree things that could have been better about this post: 1. Too long. 2. That graph with the unlabelled red line was really distracting; I had no idea what to make of it. Similarly, the "Percent of Time Spent" had the key cut off on the right for me, so I just saw: Deskt, Mobile, Mobile. Be sure to adjust your browser width to see how you post looks at different widths, and use good graphs. 3. One thing that has to be helping Mac sales is this, yet it wasn't mentioned. IBM's had a lot of press about switching from Windows to macOS: https://9to5mac.com/2015/10/15/ibm-mac-support/ https://9to5mac.com/2015/10/15/ibm-mac-support/
- supercoder 10y agoYeah this guy is bad at his graphs
- Paperweight 10y agoiPhone = notepad iPad = clipboard Mac = desk
- morsch 10y agoThis is a leap forward and a big deal. For 32 years the UX model of the Mac has been two-handed typing with one handed gesturing. Now we have the option of two-handed indirect manipulation: one hand on the touchbar and one hand on the touchpad. Imagine you’ve been playing guitar with one hand for years and then someone lets you use your left hand. Holy cow. I'm trying to keep an open mind here, and I'm really hoping people come with revolutionary input experiences, but at this point in time that paragraph sounds completely ludicrous to me.