4 ms·
> It is just as unjust to allow someone who deserves death to live as it is unjust to execute someone who deserves life. No, it's not. For one thing, 50/50 gui
by vkou 10y ago
> It is just as unjust to allow someone who deserves death to live as it is unjust to execute someone who deserves life.
No, it's not. For one thing, 50/50 guilty or innocent is nowhere near sufficient to qualify as 'proof beyond a reasonable doubt' that can convict someone - which is exactly what your moral equivalence implies.
There are plenty of arguments to be made about how convicting an innocent person creates far more injustice then not convicting a guilty one, the difference between a well-oiled, 'cool-headed' criminal system meting out injustice, compared to a crime of passion, systemic bias...