4 ms·
OT: I teach computational methods and even as much as I dislike teaching/conflating it with web dev, I have included "let's build a web app" because students li
by danso 10y ago
OT: I teach computational methods and even as much as I dislike teaching/conflating it with web dev, I have included "let's build a web app" because students like building and deploying a thing, and because Heroku has a free tier.
I've considered the possibility of having students do things on AWS (beyond web dev), including Lambda, and just expensing the costs. It seems feasible to quickly set up every student with controlled access via IAM...but is there a way to set up rate-limiting, ideally through a policy? That is, shut an IAM down if a student accidentally invokes a million processes? Or, for that matter, limiting the storage capacity of a S3 bucket?
- tokenizerrr 10y agoAWS has a free tier for a year
- rspeer 10y agoIt becomes a problem when you're a student and people expect you to use AWS's free tier for different projects in two different years.
- sorenbs 10y agoYou can easily set up multiple accounts with same credit card and they will all be eligible for free tier. I use gmails email+alias@gmail.com feature for this.
- autotune 10y agoI would just set up a new account for each student, have them use their own billing info, have them use the free tier, teach them how to set up billing alerts, and let them go to town. They're going to need to learn to take cost into account when working at a real job with AWS so this is the best way to teach them to take accountability.
- PetahNZ 10y agoI'm not sure its reasonable to expect your students to have a credit card.
- autotune 10y agoDepends on the age group. Anyway most could get a secured credit card if needed.
- danso 10y agoYeah that's the thing. Most students do have a credit card. But I've had a few who are very much against it, for financial or privacy reasons. For me, it's not worth compelling them to change their ways (which I'm highly sympathetic to) for what could amount to as little as $5 of AWS costs.
- cobookman 10y agohttps://cloud.google.com/edu/ https://cloud.google.com/edu/ Google cloud gives free edu grants.
- ranman 10y agoCheck this and the github education pack out: https://aws.amazon.com/education/awseducate/ https://aws.amazon.com/education/awseducate/
- danso 10y agoOh, very nice! I hadn't heard that AWS had a program. I've used Github's education pack, once as an educator to get a free org with 20 private accounts, and once where I asked students to signup. The former situation was too cumbersome (I had to create a repo for each student, and students constantly confused their own personal account with their org account), and in the latter, only a few students out of 20 got approved by the time the course ended -- I think someone told me the process was backlogged. I'm willing just to expense things on my account for the sake of simplicity but will see if AWS has a more streamlined process for class/per-student approval. Thanks!
- CephalopodMD 10y agoI am taking a cloud computing class. We each use our own account and have registered for some free educational aws credits that come with the student developer pack. I think teachers can also request credits as well since we get an extra $40 or so from the prof. Whenever a student accidentally leaves an m4xlarge on for a week, which happens occasionally, he just calls up amazon support, explains what happened, and usually they'll fix it up if it doesn't happen too often. If you go serverless though, it's probably not going to be an issue. I would be amazed if a student used more than $10 doing anything with lambda.