3 ms·
A capital gains tax a good idea? No -- that would decrease market liquidity and make the problem even worse. France has high capital gains taxes and it means th
by briandear 10y ago
A capital gains tax a good idea? No -- that would decrease market liquidity and make the problem even worse. France has high capital gains taxes and it means that people are less willing to sell houses because capital gains taxes eat the profit, so people tend to hang on to houses in the hope that in many years they'll appreciate enough to make swallowing the capital gains hit worth it. I have a place in France that I'd consider selling but I am not interested in giving the government a huge percentage of the profit.
Meaning if I take a risk in buying and renovating something, my profit has to make the whole affair worth it. If I'm giving the government 34.5% of my profit, if my house was bought at €500k and my target profit is €100k, then that means I have to sell the place at roughly €635k instead of €600k. That knocks many potential buyers out of the market, thus means that the house won't sell as quickly. That also means that my capital is tied up in the house instead of moving the market in some other deal or otherwise putting that money into the economy some other way. The net gain from a capital gains tax is actually a negative when you count the lose of market liquidity resulting from capital gains taxes.
Increasing the price of something lowers demand. If you increase the price of selling, less people will sell, causing house prices to increase.
Capital gains taxes are always a bad idea. Capital liquidity is critical for an efficient economy. The only people who support capital gains taxes are typically people with little capital -- they don't actually understand how it works and the stunting effect it has on an economy.
- hga 10y agoNote also that capital gains are seldom if ever indexed for inflation, certainly not in the US. So you're frequently paying a big tax on purely paper gains.
- EdwardDiego 10y ago> A capital gains tax a good idea? No -- that would decrease market liquidity and make the problem even worse. Depends on the level. At the moment, the big problem is that nearly all of NZ's capital goes into housing - the significant tax advantages (no tax on your profits and LAQCs/LTCs) are one factor in this - inflating the price of living, and starving our businesses of capital to grow and actually be productive with. I'd ask you why it's a good idea for an economy that profit from running a company is taxed along wit the incomes of all your workers, but not the profit from trading houses - especially as a lot of our property investors are rolling by on the minimal amount of capital necessary - their debt is liquid more than their capital.