5 ms·
Some good insights here. Rishad Tobaccowala tweeted: “you are right. What we want closed (our data) they want open. What we want open (create and transfer) the
by stcredzero 17y ago
Some good insights here.
Rishad Tobaccowala tweeted: “you are right. What we want closed (our data) they want open. What we want open (create and transfer) they want closed.”
There's room for someone to give us what we want. What if there was a P2P open source app about communication / status / notification?
A web browser would be a good platform for this to reside in. There would have to be a daemon/service component as well. Perhaps a cloud component, but with distributed control and controlled encrypted access, so only immediately linked nodes could ever be compromised.
- nfnaaron 17y ago[something like] tor + [something like] rss + some kind of permission/auth mechanism your browser client gets permission to subscribe to a "friend" and keeps up to date via [something like] rss over [something like] tor.
- nfnaaron 17y agoor: modified google/blogger, default private + existing rss that blogger already has + some kind of permission/auth mechanism Not as free/open as you might like, but quicker/easier to implement.
- _delirium 17y agoThis is why, despite being too young to actually have experienced them, I miss the days when people who actually had the good of the network in mind hashed out ideas over RFCs before rolling something out. I imagine they would come up with something with some parameters vaguely in that space (though maybe not including tor).
- stcredzero 17y agoI was thinking something more like encrypted storage in the cloud for pull and offline access to feeds. Realtime updates would happen over a push mechanism. (Otherwise polling would make things expensive.) Everything would be encrypted and in complete control by the "local" segment of the graph.
- roc 17y agoOr, just use Wave. Even though Google is fumbling this service, it really could launch decentralized social networking services. They just need a 'phase 1' client that draws better imaginary walls between the 'parts' of the service, to fit most users' current conception of how the internet works. People aren't 'getting' the idea that an email, a chat and a picture archive are the same thing under the hood. Google, meanwhile, is so proud of the technical possibilities that they won't shut up about that part. And it's confusing the crap out of the users they should be enticing. Google needs to build that more-traditional-looking client and pitch it as a decentralized Facebook competitor.
- nfnaaron 17y agoMy first thought was Wave. My second thought was Wave sucks (in my limited experience). I also like the idea of minimising the use of proprietary protocols. Can you imagine if email were invented today; lots of non-connected email islands.
- bbuffone 17y agoI completely agree with the P2P approach, for sometime I was thinking about P2P as a means to deliver a social network for families. Everyones graph and data would be under their control and "local" to just those that needed it. The one key element that makes the web possible, isn't HTML, HTTP, CSS, blah, blah, blah... it is the fact that it is decentralized. If for some reason we are tricked into moving away from this we are not longer using the web. We are just using AOL 2.0 - Google, Facebook, twitter, bit.ly.... are all trying take control of not users, but their information and the web. Don’t think it will happen... it already has. The URL is the essence of how the web works and you no longer control yours. Link shortening, makes it easier to paste and share links but it breaks the web. Currently, I am sitting in China writing this comment and every link that bit.ly has under its control are completely useless to every person in China. My slogan that I came up with for Bit.ly is "Billions of links useless to billions of people!" Please don’t respond its China’s fault; that is too simple. The issue is that we haven’t responded fast enough from a standards perspective to combat this hijacking. The solution is actually quite simple to implement.
- stcredzero 17y agoPerhaps shortened URLs should be a standard? This could be managed in the same way DNS is.
- wheels 17y agoThe problem is that what "we" really want is to be able to mail, chat, play games with, send photos to and do other random stuff with our friends. What a subset of geeks want is an open architecture that with fine-grained privacy controls. The average person wants that about as much as they want to ensure that they have access to the source code of their operating system. Social networking requires a critical mass; the critical piece of building an open architecture isn't writing the software and putting a site up, it's convincing enough people to join to make the experience worthwhile. And for that you need a better carrot than geek fodder.
- DrSprout 17y ago> What a subset of geeks want is an open architecture that with fine-grained privacy controls. The average person wants that about as much as they want to ensure that they have access to the source code of their operating system. That's extremely condescending. Everyone I know wishes they had better control over their privacy on Facebook. The problem is that properly understanding and maintaining Facebook's current privacy controls would probably take several hours a month of analysis. That's intentional - Facebook is making the privacy controls too complex, and changing them too frequently for anyone to manage them properly.
- singer 17y ago> Everyone I know wishes they had better control over their privacy on Facebook. Sure -- everyone you know. However, the average person has little or no interest in learning about and/or configuring privacy features.
- stcredzero 17y agoBut what average users want is so little. Done correctly, social networking could do what they want without such a heavy price to pay in terms of loss of privacy and control over personal information.
- nooneelse 17y agoThis is manifestly not just a geeky thing. Go read the news coverage of the last few major Facebook changes and you will see that the chorus of concerned people has been growing quite well. "It does what you like about Facebook, except only you control who sees your stuff" would be a simple sell to lots of people.
- balakk 17y agoYou've invented Opera Unite. As usual, opera's way ahead of the curve.
- stcredzero 17y agoNot exactly. This is something that could be built on top of Opera Unite. There would have to be a lot of functionality implemented to make it viable.