3 ms·
What a bizarre article. It has nothing to do with Airbnb, and everything to do with arbitration. If your interest is Airbnb or discrimination then skip this ar
by ars 10y ago
What a bizarre article. It has nothing to do with Airbnb, and everything to do with arbitration.
If your interest is Airbnb or discrimination then skip this article.
Try buying a car without agreeing to arbitration - you can't.
It's a problem. But Airbnb is not the right company to use to talk about it.
- supercanuck 10y ago>It's a problem. But Airbnb is not the right company to use to talk about it. Why?
- ars 10y agoBecause you'll get lost in a whole discussion of discrimination, if it's Airbnb's responsibility to prevent, if homeowners have the right to discriminate. If Airbnb is even legal, etc, etc, etc. (For example look at some of the comments in this thread that are talking about discrimination, when the topic is ostensibly arbitration. It should be two separate discussions.) Either talk about it in a Vacuum (without any particular company), or at least pick a case that is more "pure", i.e. unequivocally the company's responsibility.
- npizzolato 10y agoIt seems like the two topics are correctly being linked. Airbnb is trying to use arbitration clauses to avoid having to answer any questions about large-scale discrimination. Why should it be talked about in a vacuum?
- ars 10y agoBecause you can solve (try to solve) the discrimination issue without ever touching the arbitration issue. But the problem at hand (specifically the problem in the article) is arbitration. Mixing two topics, and then solving the wrong one is a very common and effective debate and political tactic.
- Steko 10y ago> without ever touching the arbitration issue It's a strange world where Air B&B can use arbitration to shield themselves and then when this tactic is pointed out people say "no you can't talk about that, it muddies the waters". The arbitration is absolutely relevant.
- scottshepard 10y agoThe author highlights why Airbnb is the right company to use to talk about it. > Often arbitration clauses are invoked in cases where consumers feel they have been financially slighted—seeing charges on their phone bills for services they never wanted, for instance—but the Times investigation found arbitrations used in more serious cases of medical malpractice, theft, hate crimes, and discrimination. The Airbnb situation highlights how far the practice extends. Other companies (like car dealers) have used arbitration for smaller scoped purposes, but Airbnb is essentially opting out of the 14th amendment.
- andrewprock 10y agoAirBnB is the perfect company to use to talk about it. In general, racial discrimination in rentals is a historic problem. If AirBnB wants to be the platform for "rentals of the future" they are going to have to be responsible for the degree to which they enable discrimination.
- ars 10y ago> AirBnB is the perfect company to use to talk about it. In general, racial discrimination in rentals is a historic problem. If AirBnB wants to be the platform for "rentals of the future" they are going to have to be responsible for the degree to which they enable discrimination. You realize the "it" in your sentence is "arbitration", while the rest of what you wrote is about "discrimination"? Your sentence is a perfect example of why Airbnb is exactly the wrong company to use to talk about arbitration. (This article is about arbitration. I'm not implying people shouldn't talk about discrimination, just that the headline is quite misleading.)
- andrewprock 10y agoIt may not have been clear in what I wrote above, but arbitration relates to systematic violations precisely because arbitration prevents pursuing class action suits. It is in that regard that AirBnB is relevant.
- ryuker16 10y agoIt's a one to one transaction and very hard to prove. Race isnt specified and many user profiles obscure the face. Instabook books automatically without host approval.
- rdtsc 10y ago> Try buying a car without agreeing to arbitration - you can't. I did. I refused to sign the arbitration agreement said I was walking out. They didn't like it but didn't like losing a sale even more.