6 ms·
I try not to generalize personal experience to a company's stock price. But in GoPro's case I'm picturing a bunch of folks like me who bought one, and then swor
by mikestew 10y ago
I try not to generalize personal experience to a company's stock price. But in GoPro's case I'm picturing a bunch of folks like me who bought one, and then swore to never again buy anything with GoPro's name on it. And those people tell their friends who are considering an "action camera". So you end up with a segment of customers from whom you'll never extract another dime, plus all of the people who might have bought one had they not spoken with current customers. (I'd recommend the Garmin offerings if you're in the market.)
I won't reiterate my complaints with my GoPro camera because I've bitched enough already on HN. The summary is that it is probably one of the most disappointing, and frankly, aggravating pieces of tech I've purchased in the last decade. It's not a matter of "cheap Chinese knock-offs" being almost good enough. It's that what the Chinese are copying wasn't all that good to begin with, so it's not terribly hard to match on quality and then undercut massively on price.
- mtw 10y agoI haven't read your account. What's bad about GoPro? Note : I have an action camera, but it's from Garmin
- noarchy 10y ago>Note : I have an action camera, but it's from Garmin Fwiw, I own a GoPro, but use Garmin's video editing software. Not only do I find it easier to whip up quick edits, but I can also overlay my Garmin Edge cycling data.
- mikestew 10y agoWait a minute, I can use the GP for video, but then suck in GPS data from my Garmin and overlay it using Garmin's software? Oh, wow, thanks for the tip, I'll try that tonight.
- noarchy 10y agoAbsolutely. VIRB Edit can handle your Garmin data files, and gives you many options for how you'd like to display the data. And as I mentioned, I import my GoPro videos, as VIRB Edit doesn't seem to care. The software, for those who are interested: https://buy.garmin.com/en-US/US/into-sports/apps/virb-edit/prod573412.html https://buy.garmin.com/en-US/US/into-sports/apps/virb-edit/p...
- vatotemking 10y agoNice. I remember GoPro Studio crashing everytime. its frustrating. Good luck if you havent saved your project.
- mikestew 10y agoMy main complaint is that it's difficult to determine camera state. My main use case is having it mounted to a motorcycle where I can reach the buttons but can't safely or easily see the indicator LEDs. Is it on? Is it recording? I have some awesome videos of me sitting on a curb in front of a gas station drinking a Gatorade because I thought it was recording the whole time, and it turns out that when I pulled up and stopped the recording I was actually turning it on. That can and should be fixed by making a button that isn't so mushy. Even with bare fingers I can't tell you if I really turned it on without looking at the lights. With motorcycle gloves, it's a complete (and as noted above, often wrong) guess. Okay, I'll strap my Pebble to the handlebars as there's a GoPro app for the Pebble. But the Pebble needs to go to the iPhone, which then talks to the GoPro iOS app, which then talks to the camera. Yeah, you can see where this is going: I spent more time trying to get all those devices to stay connected than I did riding. Fine, I didn't want to do it, but I'll buy your $80 remote with status LCD. That piece of shit didn't work any better. I spent most of the time looking at an animated WiFi icon because it couldn't find the camera literally 50% of the time. If it did find it, it often wouldn't stay found. A single company made the hardware and firmware on both ends, and they still can't get them to stay connected. Additionally, the thing eats batteries. I wouldn't mind so much if there was a way to power the thing while its in the case. There is a way, but it'll cost $65 for a waterproof case with USB port from a third-party vendor. I bought one. And about half the time when the bike fires up and pumps power to that connection, the GoPro's little pea brain gets confused and needs a reboot. This is the kind of stuff I expect when I bought the cheap Chinese knock-off instead of the name brand. But I did buy the name brand, and specifically for this reason. And I end up still having the cheap Chinese knock-off experience, only at name-brand prices.
- ghaff 10y ago>My main complaint is that it's difficult to determine camera state. Agreed. I gave one to a friend as a Christmas present a few years back and this was her big complaint. Mounted on a helmet (for whitewater paddling in her case), she was never sure whether she was turning it on or off. In general the whole UI was just pretty awful in my experience. I get that it's hard but this strays pretty close to the "You only had to do one thing" meme. (Well, the rugged case, but that's not rocket science.) Their main innovation looks more like great marketing and community building to me.
- bnchrch 10y agoI would like to echo your sentiment with my own story. I've owned a GoPro since Christmas of 2014. After less than a year of use the camera would start washing out videos while recording with flares of green and pink then freezing typically after 11 seconds of filming. When I looked on support forums I found that this was a known issue with my GoPro version. However GoPro would not admit the defect and after talking with support they could do nothing for me. I decided to keep using the camera as I use it for primarily 1 second videos. 2 months later I take it diving, the housing fails at 30 feet (its rated to 120 feet). I call support again: I'm offered 10% off my next GoPro. In my opinion GoPro is a dishonest company who does nothing to stand behind its products of which their price does not match their dismal quality. ProTip: Ebay sells action cameras with all the same features, better build quality for a third of the price
- gbog 10y agoI have a Ricoh wg-m1 which is not too bad.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y ago> I won't reiterate my complaints with my GoPro camera because I've bitched enough already on HN. Yeah. Too much of that and they might issue another fraudulent DMCA takedown.
- bobjordan 10y agoIn this case, the Chinese originally were not copying anything, GoPro just sourced the cameras from a CM here in Shenzhen, putting the GoPro name on it. I suspect the relationship stayed much the same through Hero 2 & 3, with the CM driving the design improvements in the camera.
- mikestew 10y agoYou know, I was tempted in one of my several comments in this thread to make some snarky comment about how GoPro is a "cheap Chinese knockoff" that they just silkscreened "GoPro" onto. But that seemed unnecessarily mean and petty, and I only half-suspected it. But I'll be damned, according to you I was right.
- fezz 10y agoSkylight Digital was the ODM, AFAIK This was from a shipping manifest search a few years ago.
- barrkel 10y agoGoPro is a poor shape to use with motorbikes; helmet mounts in particular are ludicrous. Any particular reason you didn't consider Drift? Fairly happy with mine, using it as a helmet-cam.
- totalZero 10y agowhich drift do you have? i'm in the market for a helmet cam and was strongly considering a hero 5...until i saw this thread.
- barrkel 10y agoI have a Drift HD Ghost, but it's a couple of generations old by now. It still works great though.
- usrusr 10y agoYou have no idea how disappointed I am of the absence of said helmet mounts in a stereo setup. Is it really that difficult to merge the streams of two imperfectly aligned cameras with large parallax? We are missing out on the best Disney trademark infringement lawsuit ever.
- mikestew 10y agoAny particular reason you didn't consider Drift? Because, as I've outlined elsewhere in this thread, I'm an idiot who thought the name brand was a safe bet and didn't do enough research. That said, most of the time it's mounted to the front crash bar or a saddlebag. Not a big fan of protrusions on my helmet.
- barrkel 10y agoDrift is mounted on the edge of my helmet, opposite my Cardo Scala Rider intercom system on the other side. There's not much way for it to hit the road first without my shoulder going AWOL, and if it did, it would snap off pretty rapidly. A key advantage of the Drift and similar systems is the camera sensor can be rotated with respect to the camera body. So it doesn't matter that it's at an angle, close to your shoulder: the picture is still upright owing to one twisting the lens.
- bartread 10y agoThis. I first heard of GoPro back in 2010. Scroll forward a few months and I'm on sabbatical doing a couple of months snowboarding and a few guys I meet along the way have them. Needless to say I am entirely unimpressed: - The rectangular box shape of them is bulky and awkward, particularly when you add the protective case on top, and seems particularly ridiculous compared with other sleeker helmet cam designs, - The mountings seem prone to work loose. One guy spent most of the time with his helmet mounted GoPro filming the ground in front of him and he had to keep fettling the thing to get it back into place. - Turns out GoPros had the time had terrible dynamic range so everything that was covered in snow looked the same uniform white, particularly on brighter days. Picture quality sucked. This has improved somewhat in subsequent updates but I would have been fuming if I'd dropped the £300 (plus the cost of accessories on one). - When I did look at buying one knowing exactly which accessories I'd need was confusing. - Just way too fiddly to use when wearing any kind of gloves, which is hopeless for what's supposed to be an action cam, - In general seemed to lead to an awful lot of faffing around by owners; to me it just looked like one more piece of gear to worry about that was mostly going to serve as an annoying time-vampire. Apart from the picture quality issues, none of the above has changed as far as I know, only now there are so many extant models it's even more confusing trying to figure out which to buy. Part of me dies inside every time somebody gets out a GoPro (or one of its many clones) on a ski/snowboard trip because you just know it's going to lead to an inordinate amount of buggering around. I fully admit, #firstworldproblems, but as far as I'm concerned GoPro suck: they're an expensive waste of time and money. In the end, for various reasons (mostly because I wanted a camera for my motorcycle), I caved and bought a Garmin VIRB. This has the following advantages: - Doesn't need (quite) so much supporting paraphernalia, primarily because unless you plan on going diving it's waterproof enough without requiring an additional case, - Overall it's very robust, - Easy to switch on and off with gloves on (there's a big slider switch on the side of the camera), - Picture quality and dynamic range are good, even in very bright conditions, - Generally sleeker design. I've used it for motorcycling, skiing, and as a dashcam. All of that said it some bad points: - Still a certain amount of confusion over which you actually need for your chosen activity, - Mounting brackets are somewhat fiddly and can work loose, - Battery life isn't great, - Batteries take hours to charge, - Apart from record on/off, the interface is kind of clunky, And there's one ugly point: - The software it runs is really unstable, and regularly crashes; this can be extremely annoying when it misses the crucial piece of action because of it. So, overall, I still wouldn't buy again.
- deelowe 10y agoSame for me and my brother. Stupid proprietary application for file transfer and editing. Extremely confusing model line. Crazy expensive assessories. Never again.
- sjg007 10y agoThe ui sucks..