4 ms·
"...what space can do to a human body could be a huge problem. “They’re going to be sick when they get there.”" I see this time and time again, but nobody has
by sandworm101 10y ago
"...what space can do to a human body could be a huge problem. “They’re going to be sick when they get there.”"
I see this time and time again, but nobody has given me a proper reason why we cannot send a spinning ship, one where zero-gravity wouldn't be an issue. Radiation is certainly a problem, but again that is a matter of shielding/weight. I don't see any monumental reason why we couldn't send perfectly healthy people. The only real issue seems one of cost.
- idlewords 10y agoCost is the monumental reason. Start with a design that can produce 1G from spinning with a suitably gentle gravity gradient that people can live in it. Then try to figure out how to accelerate that very large structure so it can get to Mars. (You can use the fuel as a radiation shield, since there will have to be a metric assload of it.)
- neaden 10y agoIt takes energy, have to design the ship to withstand the rotation, and it would have to have a pretty long radius (like 300+ meters). Almost certainly you wouldn't be at full gravity either, but like half. It adds a whole bunch of headaches that might not be worth it.
- sandworm101 10y agoRings are only one of many 'spinning' options. There is something to be said for two objects tethered by a long rope. Such a structure can spin and still reach 300+ meters with ease. And building such a thing in orbit is awkward, but not in the same league as constructing a 300m ring.
- CapitalistCartr 10y ago"The only real issue seems one of cost." But that is a real issue. A tiny ship is billions of dollars. A ship big enough to provide even half a G is more like a trillion dollars. It can't simply be a tiny spinning wheel. It has to be dozens of meters across. Of course, trashing Iraq cost us over a trillion so far, and will likely exceed 2 trillion before all is done, but that's different.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- atrus 10y agoWell, we can't even send a non-spinny ship full of people to Mars, so sending a ship that would be more complex, and much larger is out of the question, no?
- thescriptkiddie 10y agoThe possibility of practical artificial "gravity" isn't the only reason that's a stupid argument. We regularly send people to the ISS for longer than it takes to get to Mars and they're fine. Sure, it takes them a few hours to fully re-adapt to gravity and a few months to regain their muscle mass, but they're not sick.
- gph 10y agoNo we don't. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight_records#Ten_longest_human_space_flights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight_records#Te...
- blhack 10y agoThe trip to mars takes about 6 months (~180 days). Every single record in the table you linked is longer than that.
- gph 10y agoAh, I guess I was assuming round-trip. Article mentioned 3 years as the likely shortest round-trip. I suppose if we are talking about a one-way death trip then yea. Maybe some people will do that initially, but long-term you'd have to think our goal of reaching Mars would include being able to return.
- rch 10y agoTravel to Mars will be significantly different w.r.t. cosmic ray exposure: "Exposures on the ISS average 150 mSv per year, although frequent crew rotations minimize individual risk. Astronauts on Apollo and Skylab missions received on average 1.2 mSv/day and 1.4 mSv/day respectively." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_threat_from_cosmic_rays https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_threat_from_cosmic_rays
- Thnboi666 10y agoso the issue is reduced load on muscles and bones. 10x rate of bone resorption in osteoporosis. bones are the biggest worry imo. even though the astros work out 15 hours a week, it's still not enough to cover this rate of resorption, and (this is an asspull) pretty sure it affects them for months or years after doing long stays at ISS. I'm not sure if there's any proof that we could create artificial gravity such that these decreased loads wouldn't still occur. wouldn't it mess with their inner ear as well? And yeah, the only real issue is cost, but that's a doozy of an issue. what country is going to spent monumental budgets on making this ship with all the financial crises going on currently?
- Grishnakh 10y ago>I'm not sure if there's any proof that we could create artificial gravity such that these decreased loads wouldn't still occur. Acceleration is acceleration. Your body doesn't care whether it's coming from a big hunk of mass in the form of a planet, or from continuous rotation. Yes, artificial gravity will work just fine in completely eliminating the negative effects of microgravity on humans. >wouldn't it mess with their inner ear as well? Only if the diameter of the structure is too small. Then you get coriolis forces large enough to cause these side effects. Effectively, the "gravitational" force felt at your feel is smaller than what you feel at your head. And also, with a small diameter, you have to rotate the structure at a high rate to achieve 1g. With a sufficiently large station, these aren't a problem: the rotation is very slow (maybe 1 rpm) and the difference felt between your head and your feet is negligible. But building a large structure in space like that is difficult and costly and we haven't done it before. But now's a fine time to start.... >what country is going to spent monumental budgets on making this ship with all the financial crises going on currently? That's the main problem, and it's entirely the fault of the political leadership in those countries, who are mismanaging resources and allowing corruption. George W Bush's Iraq war is a prime example of this: for the cost of that war, we could have built a rather nice space station.
- Neeek 10y agoWasn't this solved by the vacuum weight set shown on smarter every day? They use a piston in a vacuum with an adjustable pivoting arm to produce consistent resistance (a spring will provide more resistance as it is compressed or stretched than in its rest state). I thought they were saying it was the first time some astronauts were returning home with higher muscle/bone density than when they went up.
- kitsunesoba 10y agoIf you cut the trip time down far enough, the need for artificial gravity is greatly diminished. Taking Musk's ITS/MCT plan as an example, the trip will take only 2-3 months and the destination (Mars) has 0.38 Earth gravity. In that situation, there should be little to no physiological issues and the astronauts should be more than strong enough to deal with Martian gravity levels upon arrival, especially if they exercise on the way over. Mission plans that call for much slower travel (6+ months) are much more likely to cause trouble for the travelers, which in why in my opinion any plans that are seriously considered should minimize travel time as much as practically possible. The logistics in getting a craft into space, getting it spinning appropriately to produce artificial gravity, and hurling it towards Mars are significantly more complicated than, say, refueling in orbit to allow for reduced travel time.
- jonshariat 10y agoIn the article says the engineers said its a matter of adding too much complexity. Also consider that its a few months trip (Scott Kelly did over a year) and the real problem is when they live there. Mars gravity is only 38% of earths. So the problem while slower, still will be an issue.