3 ms·
Maybe if we didn't make it illegal to put homes next to jobs this wouldn't be an issue.
by CalRobert 10y ago
Maybe if we didn't make it illegal to put homes next to jobs this wouldn't be an issue.
- JBReefer 10y agoThe funny thing is mixed-use zoning and density have becoming increasingly allowed basically everywhere in the US ... except for SF. Here in NYC a lot of the NIMBY voice has been silenced by "look, they tried your policies, and it failed. Let's try these instead."
- hx87 10y agoThere's this weirdly common idea that density = skyscrapers, which ignores the fact that a community of 5-story walkups can easily support 70,000+ people per square mile.
- JBReefer 10y agoI never got that. SF is 17k per sq mi., Queens is 21k. Queens is 4 stories with greenery, courtyards, parks, etc - forever. It's really calm and easy to get around. People think SF will be Beijing when it needs to be Queens.
- ghaff 10y agoThat's a vast oversimplification for a study that's about the US as a whole. In the case of DC for example, which the study highlights: - A lot of people are commuting into government offices in the city. DC does indeed have a strict height restriction. But it's also worth observing that DC was generally considered to be a pretty dangerous city to live in and lots of people moved out to the suburbs because they didn't want to live in the city. - It's also just a sprawling metropolis with a beltway that's famously congested. It's not so much that people can't live nearby where the companies are but people want to live in particular communities and they change jobs and they end up having long commutes on busy roads. The fact is that there are lots of places around the US with plenty of places where companies and people can be nearby each other. But especially with two-income families where the couple work at far apart companies, or when someone just has a strong preference to live in the city or live in the exurbs--and that's not where the company is--you end up with long commutes.
- CalRobert 10y agoBut why are those things so far apart? * parking minimums require land that could be used to house people be used to house cars instead. It also means that people who wouldn't own a car due to the cost of parking decide to own one because parking becomes a sunk cost. (If I had free parking where I live now I'd probably own a car, but I don't in large part because parking it would be €250 a month or so). * Density maximums mean that housing a given number of people takes more space. This means you have to move through more space to get to your job. * Designing roads to the goal of moving cars at high speeds (rather than people to their destinations) results in land that could be used for housing and jobs going towards wide roads, support infrastructure (slip roads, etc.), and yards (because who wants a front door that opens to a road filled with cars?) * Zoning means that instead of an acre of space providing homes for 10 people and jobs for 10 people, it provides homes for 15ish people and jobs for 0 (or more likely 5 given the aforementioned density maximums). Then, in the acre over, land that could provide jobs to those 10, or 15, people does so for fewer people since so much of it is given over to housing cars. Note how the companion to a highrise in many cities is a big parking garage for its employees. * The above make the carless less able to participate in society, leading to poverty, leading to stigma, meaning even people who have the means to get by without a car will often be reluctant to do so because they don't want to be stigmatised themselves.
- ghaff 10y agoAs I wrote, it's in large part because people didn't want to live in dangerous corrupt Washington DC. They wanted to live in a house in Chevy Chase MD. I get that you wish they didn't have that preference and didn't vote for the laws and taxes that enabled their preferred lifestyle.
- CalRobert 10y ago"I get that you wish they didn't have that preference and didn't vote for the laws and taxes that enabled their preferred lifestyle. " This is false. I think they should live however they like. I just don't like it when they make it illegal to build apartment buildings down the road because _they_ think everyone else should live just like them.