3 ms·
"Americans tend to value abstinence above all else, an all-or-nothing approach that British advocates see as rooted in the United States’ Puritan culture, said
by mcguire 10y ago
"Americans tend to value abstinence above all else, an all-or-nothing approach that British advocates see as rooted in the United States’ Puritan culture, said Deborah Arnott, the chief executive of Action on Smoking and Health."
This is true.
You can see the same thing during the (alcohol) prohibition era: because ethyl alcohol is necessary for other uses, it was mandated to be "denatured" by adding chemicals that made it less appealing to drink. When they found people still drinking it (or managing to separate the alcohol from the denaturants), they increased the toxicity of the chemicals until they were actually poisoning people.
In this case, the primary goal is to prevent new smokers. Since many of the e-cigarette flavors are pleasant, they regard it as attractive to children. Now, getting someone who doesn't already smoke to vape is bad, but I haven't seen any significant evidence that vaping leads them to smoking, so there's that.
On the other hand, if you are already smoking, your soul is lost and, to a first approximation, it would be better if you were to die as soon as possible---outside of pharmaceutical companies, there is no serious interest in cessation. Inside those companies, making nicotine gum and patches is big business, and I know people who have been chewing the gum frequently for nearly a decade.
There is a certain amount of the same feeling in those who have quit smoking. To paraphrase an old joke, how do you know someone quit smoking? Don't worry, they'll tell you. If you can quit cold-turkey, good; if you can't, you are weak willed and a lesser human.
In any case, the bottom line is, like in all Puritan situations, that results matter less than perceptions.
- kstrauser 10y agoAmericans tend to value abstinence above all else, an all-or-nothing approach that British advocates see as rooted in the United States’ Puritan culture I think that's hugely simplified. There are plenty of drugs which are exceedingly difficult to use recreationally: - Crack - Meth - Nicotine - Heroin People who use those at all are very likely to use them a whole hell of a lot, and they have terrible health effects. I don't think it's Puritanism to recommend staying away from highly addictive substances. Now, getting someone who doesn't already smoke to vape is bad, but I haven't seen any significant evidence that vaping leads them to smoking, so there's that. According to HHS (http://www.hhs.gov/ash/oah/adolescent-health-topics/substance-abuse/tobacco/trends.html http://www.hhs.gov/ash/oah/adolescent-health-topics/substanc...): "Eighth grade students who use e-cigarettes are 10 times more likely than their peers who do not use e-cigarettes to eventually smoke tobacco cigarettes. This trend continues to a slightly lesser degree for older adolescents. Tenth and 12th grade students who use e-cigarettes are eight and six times more likely, respectively, than their peers to smoke tobacco cigarettes. This suggests that youth who use e-cigarettes are likely to become tobacco cigarette smokers as they age."
- the_watcher 10y agoThat stat isn't necessarily causal though. Have they controlled for the fact that 8th graders who start using e-cigs are already more likely to start smoking tobacco cigarettes? Which seems like a very reasonably assumption to make
- mcguire 10y ago"There are plenty of drugs which are exceedingly difficult to use recreationally:" Certainly. And the proper response is to discourage their use. But how do you treat those who do use them? As a health problem or as a moral failure? Thanks for the HHS link!
- kstrauser 10y ago> Certainly. And the proper response is to discourage their use. Totally agree, but that's an entirely different conversation.
- sithadmin 10y ago>they have terrible health effects Nicotine alone doesn't have 'terrible health effects' for those that are otherwise generally healthy. Yes, it is addictive and can exacerbate existing conditions (e.g. high blood pressure), but nicotine consumed through methods like lozenges, patches and gum poses negligible health risks.