33 ms·
How do you know they are safer? My understanding was that many ingredients, particularly for flavored formulas are proprietary and unknown.
by Spooky23 10y ago
How do you know they are safer? My understanding was that many ingredients, particularly for flavored formulas are proprietary and unknown.
- snarfy 10y agoI make my own unflavored VG/PG e-juice. I buy the nicotine separately. I don't like the idea of inhaling flavors. I just want the nicotine. But yes, you are correct. A lot of the flavors are not regulated. I recall there was an issue with a carmel like flavor recently.
- nom 10y agoI also omit the flavors to minimize the risks. I also vape only on very low settings and with increased nicotine. I see people using devices beyond 150W and super hot coils to 'make dem sick clouds'. They have essentially created some nice portable catalytic converters. You can even buy coils made from different alloys like Ni-Ti and some devices measure the coil resistance to control the temperature.
- pault 10y agoWhere do you buy the nicotine?
- snarfy 10y agoMost vape stores sell unflavored e-juice + nicotine. I buy the high strength stuff (24mg) and dilute it to 6mg.
- tmearnest 10y agoI would never claim that they are safe without a lot more scientific evidence, but safer is plainly obvious. Vaporizers do not combust the material. Incomplete combustion of plant matter generates tons of carcinogens. The material in ecigs is vegetable glycerine, propylene glycol, nicotine, and flavors. The first two have been inhaled regularly for decades (asthma inhalers for one). Nicotine has been shown to be mainly harmless. The only thing iffy is the flavorings. They are well-known to be safe to ingest, but there's no real data on their regular inhalation.
- soylentcola 10y agoWell, you can get the ingredients list for one. Like a lot of things, there are some less reputable companies making it and a lot of reputable ones. If anything, I've been pleasantly surprised at how seriously a lot of the vaping "community" takes this, sometimes going as far as to have samples analyzed in a lab and sharing the results when there's a concern about one of the flavoring agents in a mix. Then there's people like me and the person who replied to your comment earlier who just make our own. It's surprisingly simple and pretty inexpensive. The other commenter eschews flavoring altogether whereas I only use a small amount of it and only buy stuff from companies that list the compounds included so I can make sure there are no particularly nasty components that would make them dangrous to inhale in typical concentrations. I agree that there are no long term studies on the effects of inhaling this stuff for years on end but a lot of the things that stick out as hazardous are easy to identify and even when they exist, it's typically at a level that's a small fraction of what you'd run into when talking about combustible tobacco. Basically it's harm reduction. Like how you read about the dangers of eating char-grilled meat because it has some of the same things as cig smoke. That may be the case but you're not getting nearly as much of it so you won't likely get cancer from eating a seared steak a few times a year like you would from smoking cigs daily.
- SparkyMcUnicorn 10y agoIt's true that flavorings are the biggest variable and it's a risk that people are taking because many feel that risk is extremely low. For example; some flavorings contain diacetyl which, if inhaling too much, will lead to Bronchiolitis Obliterans or "popcorn lung", but the amount actually inhaled in e-cigarettes is 750 times less than cigarettes and vastly less than the amount inhaled by people that have developed popcorn lung. Yes, there are some chemicals in the flavoring, but the amount is fractions of that in cigarettes (flavorings usually account for less than 10% in my liquid, and much of the flavoring is more base liquid; VG and PG). I've taken the risk assessment and decided that e-cigs are much safer. Each person must do that for themselves.
- mcguire 10y agoFor anyone who hasn't followed this, "popcorn lung"[1] is named that because it was found in workers at factories making (microwave?) popcorn products. In other words, they were dealing with diacetyl in industrial quantities. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bronchiolitis_obliterans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bronchiolitis_obliterans
- peteri 10y agoThere's a snopes piece that debunks the popcorn lung worth knowing about if anyone mentions it. http://www.snopes.com/vaping-causes-popcorn-lung/ http://www.snopes.com/vaping-causes-popcorn-lung/
- indigo_rex 10y ago"If you’re reading this as a member of the public, please don’t be put off by the conflicting headlines – we all agree cigarettes are bad for you, most of us agree vaping is probably much safer than smoking regular cigarettes, and if you’re a smoker we all really want our research to help you to quit. Don’t let us get in the way." https://www.theguardian.com/science/sifting-the-evidence/2016/sep/14/why-cant-scientists-agree-on-e-cigarettes-vaping https://www.theguardian.com/science/sifting-the-evidence/201...