3 ms·
Jumping directly to discrimination in society seems a bit hasted as an explanation for the data, since men entering the teaching profession also show the exact
by belorn 10y ago
Jumping directly to discrimination in society seems a bit hasted as an explanation for the data, since men entering the teaching profession also show the exact same data. When hitting a roadblock, men a several times more likely to quit the teaching profession than a woman hitting the same roadblock. Surely it not an issue of men knowing that they're worth something in and of themselves, competing against women in the teaching profession.
Theory should be testable. Failure rate after interview rejection should be fairly easy to gather over any number of profession, so why not do that. Rather than just studies on teaching and tech profession, lets have 20-30 different profession, about which 50% will be male dominated and 50% female dominated (should be easy since about 90% of all profession in Sweden have major gender imbalance, and >80% of both women and men are employed).
Rather than explaining the odds, and rather than talking about intrinsic value, maybe we should be talking about the psychological effect of diverging behavior. If 60% of people in a restaurant pick vanilla ice-cream as desert and 40% pick chocolate, the 40% is more likely to have buyers remorse than those in the 60%. Being in a minority, be that based on gender, race, language, or ice cream preference, will have an confidence impact. When it comes to carer choice, that impact has then a very noticeable effect.
- taneq 10y agoVery interesting, I'd never heard that about male teachers quitting more often than females. I wonder if that holds true across different cultures? Here, at least, teaching is often seen as a bit of a fallback plan if you don't succeed at your chosen profession or you hit mid-20s and still don't know what you want to do. I like the diverging behaviour angle too. That actually sounds like it could have a serious impact, and doesn't rely so heavily on stereotyping one particular teen experience across each gender.
- belorn 10y agoIf it culture has a major impact, it should be fairly testable. Any differences, after correlated to gender distribution in the work force, should hint to it. Theories that can be tested to either be false or true is always valuable in this kind of discussions.
- HemanHeartYou 10y agogonna need some sources for that data, friendo
- geebee 10y ago"since men entering the teaching profession also show the exact same data" This is really interesting, could you provide a citation?
- belorn 10y agoYes I can. But first I would like to say that I could too just have requested citation from the parent comment and be done. Finding papers you read a month/year/years ago take times, and links goes sometimes dead, and in a online forum like this it is generally appreciated if the requester has done some initial attempts themselves to search online for sources. Anyway, it was a polite request and I happened to save the pdf. Source: Rapport 2009:7 R, Swedish national agency of higher education, title: Man ska bli lärare!.
- geebee 10y ago"I could too just have requested citation from the parent comment and be done" Been done with what? Yes, I know, sometimes people say "citation please" as a way of refuting without reasoning, but other times, people are actually interested in reading the citation. This is one of those cases. Furthermore, this is not one of those cases would something could be easily established through a quick google search, this sounds like a very specific study.
- belorn 10y agoThanks for showing that was the case, and Im glad that source was helpful. Chapter that begins at Page 27 is especially interesting since it directly address potential reasons, and the aspect of being in minority vs majority.