4 ms·
Do e-cigarettes really have a reputation as a 'menace'? I've never heard anyone express any significant concern about them on an individual level (certainly now
by taneq 10y ago
Do e-cigarettes really have a reputation as a 'menace'? I've never heard anyone express any significant concern about them on an individual level (certainly nowhere near as much as about traditional cigarettes), and yet I've read countless news articles decrying them.
It seems odd.
- linkregister 10y agoOnly in U.S. cities will I see scare-tactic advertisements against e-cigarettes. What's strange to me is that the Truth campaign is sponsoring some of them. The Truth campaign is a result of a liability suit of several states vs the cigarette companies, and it is intended to pay for anti-smoking advertisements and smoking cessation programs. It appears to be a blatant violation of the terms of the judgement.
- josho 10y agoWow, that's a dirty tactic. Especially when you consider that what's bad about smoking is tobacco and e-cigs don't necessarily have tobacco.
- NTripleOne 10y agoWhat's bad about smoking is burning tobacco. Important distinction.
- montecarl 10y agoYou can be even more general than that. Inhaling burning organic matter is probably worth avoiding. There is some good evidence that wood smoke is also quite bad for you.[1] [1] https://www.uvm.edu/~susagctr/Documents/Woodsmoke.pdf https://www.uvm.edu/~susagctr/Documents/Woodsmoke.pdf
- cr0sh 10y agoe-cigs don't even necessarily have nicotine. I like to vape on occasion - mostly at home, indoors, when I am coding or doing something similar on my computer in my office. My vape of choice is a custom menthol blend with caffeine - and zero nicotine.
- bcook 10y agoCaffeine?! That's very interesting. Got any links about vaping caffeine?
- nv-vn 10y agoWell for one thing, in my state you have to be 18+ to purchase them, which makes it just as convenient to smoke actual cigarettes for kids.
- WorldMaker 10y agoOn an individual level, I find them nearly as obnoxious as normal cigarettes even without tobacco in them and someone is just smoking "perfume" around (why bother at that point?). I have allergy sensitivities to aerosols and perfumes and strong smells and just about any smoking tends to infuriate me. I see so many people use e-cigarettes as an excuse to smoke indoors, even in light of public smoking bans, and get upset when I complain that they make me feel sick. Indoor air quality isn't just about carcinogens or aerosolized tobacco, but allergens and respect for common spaces that we all have to share.
- foobarchu 10y agoThere's a couple of big things against them right now. A) they are unproven. Many people believe that something that isn't proven safe or unsafe is not better than something unsafe that has been heavily scrutinized and studied. What if there's a much worse effect that we dont' know about yet? B) They are unstandardized. Each producer can be putting who-knows-what in the oils. C) It's still smoke. When they first came out, a lot of people got e-cigs with the idea that they could get around smoking bans, such as on planes or in bars (in places that banned that). This has resulted in a massive backlash, because it really wasn't health problems that caused those bans, it was the fact that nobody wants to sit in someone elses smoke cloud. This is causing a big social stigma against e-cig users.
- exprA 10y agoIt isn't smoke, and it isn't burnt plant matter. In theory the vapour might have as strong a smell as cigarette smoke; in practice even the most strong smelling vapours are mostly comparable to the smell of personal fragrances, and we are ways off from banning those as well.
- mcguire 10y agoOn the other hand, it's a big thick cloud of vapor coming from someone's mouth.
- unethical_ban 10y agoWhat about a thick cloud of... carbon dioxide and water vapor, from the people standing around you?
- mcguire 10y ago...which is difficult to perceive unless they are close enough to be obviously breathing on you. Or have bad breath. Neither of which is appealing.
- yuubi 10y ago